Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> What do you think of the beginning to my short story?


Question: What do you think of the beginning to my short story!?
I know I already asked this, but when I write something I like a lot of opinions!. So what do you think!? This is just the beginning, and I can't think of a continuing plot line for it!. Thanks!. Constructive criticism please!. =]







Mama's sick again!. Papa says to leave her be, but her screams echo through the house like bats crying out in the darkness of a cave!. I close my eyes and ears, trying desperately to block out her blood-curdling shrieks!. She's afraid, I know she is!. It's dark, she's seeing and hearing things, she doesn't know what they are!. She thinks that by screaming she can keep them from talking to her, telling her things!. She thinks that maybe if she screams loud enough, they'll go away!. But they just grow louder and louder, filling her ears, then her head, then flooding down to the rest of her body, until it feels as if the voices are grating against her bones from the inside out!. Scratching, trying to get out, to be heard by her!. She doesn't want to listen, can't listen!. She knows what they'd say if they knew she was listening!.

She starts beating on the door of her bedroom, locked in by Papa before leaving for work!. She thinks that if she could just get out of the room, of this house, maybe the voices will go away!. She doesn't remember the other times, how even when she gets out, the voices follow her, because they are her!. I hear her nails, fervently scratching at the door, the hinges rattling in their sockets!. I listen until I can't hear it anymore, to be replaced just with moans, cries, and whines of agony!. Not from her, from my own hands clawing at my arms, my head beating against the wall!.

It's the only way I can think of to get the voices out, since screaming isn't working!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Well written and disturbing!.!.!. which I'm sure was your goal!.

However, if I were an editor looking at this piece, the first thing that would jump out at me is point-of-view (POV)!. You've got a first-person narrative, but the "I" character is able to see into the mind of her mother, and able to know what she is feeling physically!. That means you're really inside the head (POV) of the mother, not the daughter!. How does the daughter know what her mother is thinking and feeling!? Have they had a conversation about it when Mom wasn't feeling so bad!? Or maybe the daughter knows because she's going through the same thing (your last sentence seems to imply that)!. If that's the case, you could add a subtle remark in the paragraphs describing the mother's condition!. Something like, "I know!.!.!. I know!."

also, try to avoid overused throw-away words like "just," and "that!." Try reading the sentence without those words!. If the sentence still makes sense, cut the extra word!. And with a sentence like, "She starts beating on the bedroom door!.!.!." When does starting become doing!? Unless the action is interrupted in some way, it's better to tighten the sentence to: "She beats on the bedroom door!.!.!."

Hope this helps!

Cheers,
DianaWww@QuestionHome@Com

is this about someone with schizophrenia (pardon my spelling not sure if that's right) you did a great job describing it!. It's sad!. it's also a little confusing like who's sck and who's point of veiw is this!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

its kind of creepy!.!.!.!.!.
but it could work!.
!.!.!.!.!.
although i dont really get it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It brings the reader in wanting to read more!.
My opinion is that you have what it takes to be a really good author!.
Maybe you should finish the story and enter it in a writing contest!?
The only part I don't get is what type of sickness causes that!? Maybe you should explain more in your writing!.
Other than that it was very good!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I like it, it has a very good opening that will hook a reader!. I really think that this story has potential, and I love the description you use!. I only have one critique: the very last sentence, I am confused, is it from the mom's perspective or the other character's!?!?!? Anyway great story, use lots of description and I think a possible way to continue is having the mother die and the main character somehow gets the strange sickness!.Www@QuestionHome@Com