Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Is this good and how old do you think the author is?


Question: Is this good and how old do you think the author is!?
my friend wrote this but doesnt think it is good for her age!. how old do you think the person who wrote it is!? and do you think it is good!? constructive critism would be nice and sorry it is so long!.

The walk home from school that day seemed unbearably long!. I tried to tell myself it was because of the freezing weather, but I knew it was the thought of hearing John's big news!. I hoped the news was that he and Erika had finally broken up even though he would never be so excited about that!. When I arrived home, fingers numb and toes frozen, the familiar smell of warm dinner greeted me!. My mom was home from work early and had began preparing dinner!. It was John's favorite, chicken and cheesy potatoes!. I rushed up to my room, avoiding the repetitive after school conversation my mom and I have daily!. I started working on my homework when the doorbell rang!. Downstairs, I could hear John's low voice addressing our parents!. "Lindsay, John is here," my mom called up to me!. I rushed downstairs to see my older brother and our parents relaxing in the living room while dinner was finishing!. I was glad to see no sign of Erika for the first time in months!. "Maybe I was right, maybe they did break up," I thought!. John and I were only four years apart and we had been best friends up until he left for college last fall!. Before he moved out and met his girlfriend Erika, we did everything together!. He took me to all kinds of places like movies and sporting events!. He was also one of the few people I could tell anything to and it seemed like Erika replaced me when he left!. About ten minutes into our conversation, a shiny blue car pulled into the driveway!. To my disappointment, it was Erika!. The second John saw the car, he ran to the door to invite her inside!. "Sorry I am late, I got caught at work late today," Erika explained, "and hi Lindsay!. How is school going!?" "Good," I replied as I faked a smile!. Dinner was done and we all sat down at the table and got ready to eat!. "It smells delicious mom," John yelled into the kitchen as the last minute preparations were finished!. Time passed in silence when dad finally asked, "So what's the big news John!?" John looked over at Erika and she pushed her long brown hair behind her ear!. Erika smiled as John announced "We are getting married!." "Wow," mom began "I am so happy for you two!." I began chocking on a piece of chicken and mom directed me to take a drink!. After calming down, I said "Yeah, me too!." John replied with a disbelieving look on his dark, tanned face!. "Honest," I added in hoping the family would trust that I was telling the truth!. I wasn't happy for them at all!. Inside, I just wanted to tell everyone I don't want my only brother to get married and have his own family and forget about us!. I knew I had to be supportive though, just like he was always supportive of me!. Everyone had finished eating while my plate was half full!. I guess I wasn't very hungry after such thrilling news!. I asked to be excused from dinner and went back upstairs to my room!. It was impossible to concentrate on homework when thoughts of loosing my brother and best friend to some girl kept crossing through my mind!. I gave up on the homework and sat on my bed when suddenly Erika called for me!. Walking down the stairs once again, I noticed all the attention in the room was on me!. I took a seat in the nearest chair and Erika began talking to me!. "I know you and John are very close," she started "and I just wanted to let you know that we are going to try to include you as much as we can!." I quietly replied with a quite "Really!?" "Yes," Erika continued, "and we were wondering if you would like to be a bridesmaid in the wedding!." I began to think that maybe this whole thing wouldn't be nearly as bad as I thought it would be!. "I would love to," I replied back with a smile and this time it was a real smile!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Hmm!.!.!.on one hand, the grammar is that of a ten-year old!. On the other hand, I get the feeling it's written by a young teenager!. So something around that, I suppose!.

The grammar and some spelling really does need work!. Your friend needs to start a new paragraph for new speakers!. For example:

"Hello," I said to my friend!.

"Hi," she said back!. "How are you!?"

In this example, the person and the person's friend are talking in different paragraphs because they are different people!. If it was just one person speaking, you could keep the dialogue in the same paragraph!.

There are also some problems with tense!. Near the beginning, the person says, "I rushed up to my room, avoiding the repetitive after school conversation my mom and I have daily!." One can't have RUSHED to their room and avoid a repetitive conversation they HAVE daily!. Because the rest of the story is in past tense, "have" should be switched to its past tense form, "had"!.

"Downstairs, I could hear John's low voice addressing our parents!." This should be switched to "Downstairs, John's low voice was addressing our parents" or "I could hear John's low voice addressing our parents downstairs", since the original sentence implies that Lindsay herself is downstairs!.

Your friend is also using the characters' names too often!. Occasionally use "she" or "he" or "they" instead; it feels more natural!.

"John replied with a disbelieving look on his dark, tanned face!." It makes John sound like someone who jumps to conclusions!. Unless there's something like Lindsay noting that her voice sounded flat, or monotonous, or fake, it makes no sense for John to immediately think she wasn't actually happy!.

Your friend uses things like "replied" and "announced" and "continued" much too often!. Once in a while is okay, but the standard word for this sort of thing is "said"!. It might feel boring and repetitive to her, but chances are the reader is going to focus on the actual dialogue, not the words describing the dialogue!.

The last part is just way too simple!. It's like all the previous conflict about Lindsay disliking Erika is just thrown out the window with a few words!.

There's also too much telling and not enough showing!. For more information on that, go here: http://users!.wirefire!.com/tritt/tip1!.htm!.!.!.

This story does have potential, but the way it's executed is just not good!. It reminds me of the way I used to write when I was eleven!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's pretty good!.!.!.!. and I'd say the author would be around 13-16!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's good so far as grammar and spelling goes!. It adheres to all the conventional rules of writing, but I'm a little put off by the style!. It's hard to explain, but writing is more than just rules, it's something that has to flow freely from the heart!. A lot of writers get stuck there, and they write things that look just fine, but they don't touch and inspire the reader!. I'd have to say this writer is 11 or 12, and no further along than 7th grade!.

As far as improvements go, I'd move away from what actually happened and develop further on why they happened or how the characters feel about them!.Www@QuestionHome@Com