Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Twilight vs harry potter ?


Question: Twilight vs harry potter !?
i love harry potter but i hate twilightWww@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
SAME! Finally someone that agrees!
I think we should call Twilighters Muggles!.
lol!.
It would annoy the heck outta them!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I have read all of Twilight and 4 and a half of the Harry Potter books!. I can understand why they are being compared or "vs"!. They are both fantasy books for teens that became best sellers and have people of all ages completely addicted!. Personally, I don't feel they are very close in the which is more enjoyed, but I wouldn't have anything bad to say about anyone who may think differently!. To me, Harry Potter completely takes the cake because I believe more work and effort got put into Harry Potter and it is obvious!. JK Rowling created her own world of wizards!. She created in depth characters and plots!. You couldn't guess what would happen next or who would die!. It isn't the "happily ever after" story!. It has dimension!. She also brought in a multitude of characters and each stays true to themselves throughout the story!. She doesn't forget any and each played important roles!. Twilight I didn't feel did that!. It was very predictable and had only 2-dimension characters!. None of them had any depth and with how few there were, depth should have been easy!. Stephenie Meyer rushed to get the books out and didn't take the time to build much of a story!. Each book had the same plot lines!. Will Edward & Bella stay together and will the enemy vampires kill them!? Except for the last which you already know Edward & Bella are together, so it's just will they kill them!. The whole series just falls together perfectly!. There's no loss in the books at all, no real fight!. I found the books to be predictable and everyone got their "happy ending" except for Leah who seems to be forgotten half way through the last book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Both are enjoyable!. But here is the difference!.
Twilight is fun to read!. It is a captivating story with interesting characters!. The romance and "angst" are pleasant to read!.
Harry Potter has changed the world!. Whether or not someone likes it they know all about it!. There have been several college courses designed around these books and their impact on literature!. The Pope has commented on them, for goodness' sake!

I enjoyed reading both series, but I am an HP fangirl through and through!. I will pass these on to my children, and hopefully my grandchildren!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I like Twilight and I am completely obsessed with Harry Potter!.

I think they are two completely different books that cannot be compared anyway!. Aside from the fantasy genre they have nothing else in common!.

Twilight is a romance story!.

Harry Potter is about good and evil!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

I could never get into HP, I'm not a fan of wizards and the fantasy genre in general!. I'm a huge sci-fi horror fan though, and even though Twilight is very romanticized, it's still more up my alley!. I started by reading Stephanie Meyer's "The Host", and after that I got into the Twilight series!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Is this really necessary!?

Why can't we all just be friends!. Seriously, all this stuff about 'hating' books!. Which do you prefer would be better!. I love both books, but I have to say I prefer Twilight, because I love romance!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think it is apples and oranges when comparing them, but I agree with you!. I really enjoyed Harry Potter but really dislike twilight!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Harry Potter - a classic that I think will not be written anymore by any author
Twilight- a book that is loved by girly attitude girl who have interest in different sexWww@QuestionHome@Com

I really like both of them!. I think that harry potter is for all ages, and twilight is for teens!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Love HP!.
Hate Twilight!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

That's not a question!. But I am much the same as you!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Wow I haven't seen this question beforeWww@QuestionHome@Com

TWiLiGHT!!!!!! ALL THE WAY!! H!.P!. SUKS!Www@QuestionHome@Com