Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Who is the biggest Mary Sue?


Question: Who is the biggest Mary Sue!?
I'm not really sure, I was wondering about everyone's opinions on itWww@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Believe, me, Bella is nothing compared to the three girls from The Prophecy of the Stones!. At least Bella describes herself as average!.

The author, Flavia Bujor, describes all three of her characters: Jade, Opal, and Amber, as being flawless and beautiful!. One of them even dies beautifully! And they fight beautifully! And they look so beautiful on the battlefield! And Amber's red hair is a halo around her head! And Opal's aloof blue eyes are gorgeous! My god!.!.!.Bella isn't even a Mary Sue compared to these characters!.

Jade is a stereotypical snob, Amber is a stereotypical shy girl, and Opal is a stereotypical cold girl, and they all play their roles so beautifully well that they don't even need character development throughout the entire novel!.

Flavia Bujor did not include one ugly hero throughout the book!. All of her antagonists were ugly though!. And these three girls all fall in love!. Bella falling in love with Edward at first site!? Yeah right! These girls literally fall in love the moment they lay eyes on the men they meet, and these girls suddenly have literal feelings of true love and I know I'm meant to be with you!. And the guys are gorgeous and flawless, too!. At least Edward's hair is described as coppery and messy!. The guys in this book don't have a hair out of place!

Even her character, Death, was beautiful, although Death insisted that she was ugly!

The point is, they were all flawless and beautiful and their only downfall was, well, nothing!. At first, it seems like their stereotypical traits are going to do them in, but they all have a sappy ending staring at the Tree of Hope (yes, Hope!) in a halo of glittering gold! What a perfect ending for three perfect girls!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Isabella Marie Swan!. In my opinion, she is a very big Mary-Sue!. She's written by an author who seems to enjoy promoting the fact that she is a bad writer!. Bella is a whiny, self-centered doormat who latches onto people for support!. She lacks a backbone!. She marries her first boyfriend, who she met when she was 17 going on 12, and had a baby fresh out of high school!. Extreme Mary-Sue, when you consider that the author had 2 kids by the time she was in her early 20's!. Not that I'm saying that's Bad, per se, but it's not something you want to promote, as I feel that someone (esp Bella) would need a bit more experience and more help from someone other than an abusive and controlling boyfriend when she starts out in the world!. Someone who won't bribe her into marrying him in exchange for some hot and might I add, unprotected sex!.
Angel_U

EDIT: Thanks, Aki!. I now know of one book I will never ever read!. :DWww@QuestionHome@Com

Nancy Drew!.
Bella Swan!.

Aki is also right-- the Prophecy Of Stones characters were Mary Sueish as well!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Going old school, I'd say Tom Swift or E!.E!. Smith's Tom Seaton are the biggest Mary Sues as they both are genius inventors that never seem to have a bad day they can't invent their ways out of!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Bella Swan from Twilight!.





!.!.!.

One day I will get rich and famous from inventing a device that allows you to strangle fictional characters!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Harry Potter and Bella Swan!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

bellaWww@QuestionHome@Com