Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Your opinion on Bella Swan?


Question: Your opinion on Bella Swan!?
People have described her as dull, boring, clumsy and too dependent on Edward!. I didn't think she was so bad!. Actually, I thought she was kinda cool!. But, most people don't seem to share my opinion!.

Any thoughts are appreciated!. Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I don't think I should answer this in my current state but here goes:

Courageous!?! I think she's too damn reckless!. So Edward already tells her that he's fighting himself to not suck the corpuscles out of her, right!? What does she do!?! She still flippin' grows closer to him!. WTF!?

It's like Edward goes grrr!.!.!.!. }:>
Then Bella goes ^_^
So Edward goes O_O!?

She's teetering on stubborn and determined and I don't get her! I like her clumsiness and how she tames Edward with it!. So she comes out with a band-aid then ferocious mountain lion vampire goes "W-w-what happened!.!.!.!? T_T"Www@QuestionHome@Com

A Mary Sue character, babied and over protected by the author!. Optimistic to a fault!. Usually annoying traits become endearing and vise versa!.
She's supposed to be the 'every man' character but the averageness becomes too much!. equally, Edward and the rest of the Cullens (Except Alice) become too good to be true!. I would give Bella a few talents and Edward a few faults!. the most believable characters are Jacob, Alice and Charlie in my opinionWww@QuestionHome@Com

i would like do anything to be her!. and i can relate with her a lot

i love her and everything, and twilight is my fav book of all time, but really, the author makes bella look so stupid!

in twilight, she ran away to what was obviously a trap
newmoon- she jumped off a freaking cliff, and her thoughts were obviously drifting towards suicidal even though she denied it
eclipse- not so bad, but wanted to sacrifice herself when she was the person they spect all their time protecting
BD- haha, she was accually ok here

i love twilight and all, but bella is a little!.!.!. strangeWww@QuestionHome@Com

I think Bella is cool!. She's just a typical teenage girl and I can relate to her in a lot of ways

i mean yeah, she's clumsy, and a little dependent on Edward, but that's what makes her an interesting charecter!. IMHO she is not dull and boring!.

I think Bella's a great character and i'm sure a lot of people can relate to her easily!. Bella ROCKS!

=]Www@QuestionHome@Com

I find her dull, boring, clumsy and too dependent on Edward!.

Really, though, I think she's suffers from severe depression and low self esteem; I feel bad for her sometimes!. But then I remember that she's a two-dimensional book character who is not supposed to be depressed, and I go back to hating her!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think she's your typical teenager to be honest!. She was exactly what I think of when I hear the words "teenage girl!." She wasn't perfect!. She was clumsy!. She was insecure and self-concious!. And, she, like any other teenage girl, fell in love with a guy!.!.!.!. who happened to be a vampire!. I think that Stephenie Meyer did a great job in portraying your typical, ordinary teenager!. It made the story a lot easier to relate to, and a lot better to read because she wasn't the perfect blonde who gets the insanely gorgeous guy!. I loved Bella's character, she wasn't fake!.

xoxoWww@QuestionHome@Com

Biggest Mary Sue character in all of literature history- even the name implies goody little two shoes!. Too insecure, uncaring for her own life, hypnotized into an unhealthy relationship, cripplingly codependent, a personality as interesting as a blank sheet of paper!.

All in all, not a very impressive heroine!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Bella Swan is just a clumsy girl who happens to fall down a lot!. She is a girl who has dreams, like every other girl!. She was just at the right place at the right time, and found her true love & a whole lot of drama!. But it was worth it I think, because it ended happy!. That's all she really needed<3Www@QuestionHome@Com



i personally dont like bella!. she is pathetic and whiny and needy and obsessed with edward!. she is stupid as well!. she is attached to danger!. she doesnt know what she wants!. all she wants to do is be with edward!. it is not even real love!. it is obsession!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

Personally I like Bella, she is very normal!. She is clumsy, quiet, smart, just sort of plain!.!.!.somebody I can really relate to!. Lol I have more interest in fashion then her, but she just has a lot of relatable qualities to me!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think that Bella Swan is an average teenager that is loving, caring, sweet, and kind!. She can be annoying and stubborn at times, but who isn't!? Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well, for one, she's a major Mary-Sue!.
She's a hypocrite!.
She has no life outside Edward!.
She's so full of herself (WAH! I'm self-sacrificing because I MOVED! Worship me!)!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I find her to be boring!. Booooring!.
And way too emo, like she cant live AT ALL without Edward!.
A woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I would say that she is what is known as a "Mary Sue"!.Www@QuestionHome@Com