Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Why can't Bella, in the Twilight series by Stephenie Meyer, just choose a gu


Question: Why can't Bella, in the Twilight series by Stephenie Meyer, just choose a guy, Edward, or Jacob!?
Bella is always like, "I like Edward, now I like Jacob, now I like Edward, now I like Jacob!." Why doesn't she just pick one!? Is it just me, or is Bella messed!? In 'Eclipse', when she "escapes," why is she holding hands with Jacob!? She says that they're "just friends," but she knows that Jacob doesn't feel that way about her!. Can anybody help me understand this!? Who do you like, Edward, or Jacob!? Why!? The best answer will recieve the best rating!. Thanks!Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Personally i think it is because she likes Jacob but she knows that if she chooses Edward then she might break her relationship with Jacob and the other way around so that is my theory why she didn't just chose one or the other! You will find out which she chooses in breaking dawn if u already haven't!
Hope this helpsWww@QuestionHome@Com

Well, Bella has always been messed up!. All of the answers to your questions are: Bella is messed up!.

Anyway, she chooses Edward but not before dragging both guys--and the readers--through the mud a few hundred times!. Shallow much!? She thrives off of this attention and drama!.

Why does she mess with Jacob even though she knows he wants more from her!? Because she loves to be the center of attention! She was trying to cover up that darn hole she kept complaining about in New Moon and then feels so guilty, then she kisses Jacob--well, he forces himself on her--and she not only enjoys it, she realizes she "loves" him!. So after that it's one helluva ride until she chooses Edward!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

She does wind up picking someone but im not going to say who i dont wanna spoil, but the reson why she does that is because edward (since he has been on the planet for over a 100 years) was her soul mate then, since he was still on this earth with her being there she wound up having jacob(her soul mate for this centry) and edward(her soul mate for centeries ago) at least thats what i think, thats why its so hard because they are bothher loves and it was hard on her!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

thats a good question and i've thought about that too!. if shes so in love with edward who the hell cares if shes hurting Jacob!. Just buck up and tell the guy instead of leading him to believe that she loves him!. bella drives me nuts!. shes the weakest in the whole series!. my edward deserves better!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Bella did chose Edward!. Jacob is planning to hook up with Renesmee, E/B's daughter!.



? M ?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because she is an immature little girl who knows nothing of real love!. You cannot love two people at the same time; it's a farce for cheaters!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

she loves them both and its difficult for her because she doesn't want to live without either!.
however she does choose and you will figure out who in breaking dawnWww@QuestionHome@Com

She did choose!. She always knew who she would choose!. She just didn't want to hurt Jacob!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Erm, well in Breaking Dawn, Bella kinda forget about the whole Edward/Jacob fight! We all know that in the end Edward won, but when Nessie grows up!.!.!.Jacob can say 'I made out with your Mum' Ew!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com