What are your thoughts on breaking dawn

Position:Home>Books & Authors> What are your thoughts on breaking dawn

Question:

i didn't like it!. every thing ended too happy for me, like every thing fit together perfectly!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

i was completely unhappy with it!. you're right, it really did just tie everything up, and honestly that was it!. personally, im team edward, so i was thrilled with the wedding and the beginnings of the honeymoon, but bella getting PREGNANT!? vampires shouldnt have fluid other than venom!.!.!.i mean if edward cant even produce tears to cry with, how can he keep his sperm fine and dandy after a hundred odd years!? plus i didnt like how the whole book was just bella being selfish, and it reallllllllllllly detracted from her relationship with edward!. they honestly seemed kind of fake through most of the book, and i wasnt happy that edward was willing to let someone else have sex with bella so she could have kids!.!.!.i mean come on, its like hes begging jacob to turn bella into a tramp! the characters all seemed to change their personalities!.!.!.alice was just missing most of the time, rosalie disgusted me, and bella disgusted me for dealing with rosalie, obviously edward had a few issues!.!.!.!.and all the extra characters at the end, with very little depth to them, just didnt make sense!. especially if there was no fight to be had by the end--what was the point!? i mean since when do the volturi chicken out, especially if theyre supposed to be the big bad guys!. if i were writing it, i think i wouldve drawn out bella becoming a vampire until closer to the end!. she wouldve gone on her honeymoon, decided she wasnt quite ready to be immortal, gone to a semester of college [maybe], the volturi would have come looking for her and there would have been some running and some fighting and at least a few people would have died [though im all for those people being evil, such as jane or demetri], jacob would either imprint on someone human and faded back into bellas friend or been killed in a fight, bella would have eventually turned into a vampire and the volturi would have backed off or been defeated, and im thinking maybe bella would be at least slightly more normal of a newborn and she and edward could have gone off to some remote place together and she could have just become good really fast instead of never struggling in the first place!. i think the book needed different kinds of struggle and heartbreak, the kind we were led to believe there would be, such as jacob's resolution, bella leaving her parents for good, and slightly different stresses with the volturi!. more than anything, i was just disappointed!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Ah, the ever-disputed question: Was "Breaking Dawn" awful or okay or good!.!.!.

Personally, I liked it the best of the series!. Why not let everyone have their happy ending!? I understand it did fit together perfectly, but I liked all the characters too much to want any of them to miss out on a happily-ever-after!. True, we could have left out Renesmee, but then what excuse would the Volturi have found to pop up at the end!? Perhaps it was a little perfect!.!.!.but I found what I was looking for!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I liked it!!
The only thing I didn't like was the characters were different!.
Edward was suddenly calling Jasper and Emmet Jazz and Em
What up with that!?
But I also wanted a fight w/the Italians!Www@QuestionHome@Com