Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> How do you like my short story for class?


Question: How do you like my short story for class!?
I wrote this story for my summer writing class at my high school!. Its all totally TRUE, and happened with the past 2 years!. Tell me what you think!.


I can still remember the day, they day it hit me, the day that I realized just how far gone I really was!.
Well, for as long as I can remember, my parents have always acted as if my brother was always one step ahead of me!. And I could never live up to being him in their eyes!. And they played it off really well, trying to treat us the same when we were out in public or had people over!. But eventually I started acting out!. You know, the stuff that the one "strange" little kid in daycare does!. Yes, I was him!. But thats a different story!. But the only person that realized that I had potential as a person was my Grandmother, who basically helped raise me!. My best memories of were her and her small 1 floor yellow house, I loved it!.
But eventually, after battling with feelings of uselessness and not being up to par, I understood that my parents were leading me nowhere!. So at the age of around 14, I decided that the emotional abuse went on for too long!. And I moved in for summers at my grandmothers house!. Just so it looked good that I was with my parents for school years!. (Oh, how wonderful the family looked)!. And those WERE the best summers of my life!. But to make a long story short, my grandmother went to the hospital for a heart rate problem!. And they found stage 4 terminal cancer!. And she passed away within a year!. This started the downward spiral!.
After that I swore never to go near the house ever again!. And tried things with my real family one more time!. But things would never and will never work out!. The bought my brother 2 cars, 2 xbox's, ipod's, cellphones, computers, and everything else with a price tag above 200 dollars!. Yet when I asked for a few dollars to give to my best friend for a birthday, i was scolded for being "Ungrateful" !.
I never lived with them again!. And had several really close friends who's parents cared enough to let me couch hop at their houses, But eventually, I was becoming a burden!. It was even a drag for me, it wasn't home!. And nothing would ever be home!. So I was basically homeless after that, with my long, curly brown hair, and Fidel Castro hat, walking around wasting time over summers, sleeping on couches, and making occasional trips to Philadelphia with my guitar to make some money street performing and visiting a cousin!. (45 dollars a day isn't too shabby for a 16 year old hobo!) The few months after that are somewhat of a blur!.
Now it gets interesting!. While waiting for my 6:40 Amtrak train from Lancaster train station to Philadelphia, I was getting a little rest on a bench, And at around 6 I sat up from my cat nap, and took a look around!. It was the usual!. Mostly middle to upper class people going to take their kids to Phillies games!. And as I was about to get up and grab some coffee and a doughnut, I noticed a 2 year old girl looking over at me!. No big deal!. I got up and got my food, and sat down, and I looked up and saw the same little girl get up from her bench, walk over to mine, and sit down right next to me!. At that moment I realized, that there still is faith for humanity!. Swiftly, the mother scooped up the little girl and apologized, I explained that it was fine, I have younger cousins (Lie) and I'm used to it, and laughed!. She gave me a weird look and walked away!. So the thought going through my mind, is, if a child with 2 years of life lessons in her, can see something in a 16 year old homeless teenager that an adult cant, then whats wrong with people today!? Being how I saw myself in a new light, I decided to give it another try, and go home!. Yes, home!.
And as of now, I'm 17, living with my Godparents, I have an amazing girlfriend that I was friends with through everything, a job, and am working on getting though high school and into college!. And I still remember everything my Grandmother taught me!. I visit her grave often, just to remember the feelings I had when things were normal!. But for now, I'm happy!. I'm home!.

Thanks!Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
It's sweet!. But there are too many sentences at the beginning starting with ands and buts!. Get rid of some of those!.

Why were you wearing a fidel castro hat!? i dont get it!.

and what do you mean by 'faith in humanity'!? there is no explanation to what that means!.

If you feel that you want to send such private things out there then sure send it in to school!. But im sorry, it seems like you just want everyone to hug you and make you feel better, and feel bad for you!. I may be wrong though!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well, I like it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

To be honest, at first I was skeptical about your story but as soon as I was shortly into it I couldn't stop!. I'm sure you want to hear it was good but I have something better, I would probably buy it if you sold your work!. I think if you keep on improving it you can have one of the most beautiful pieces of work!. I hope you don't mind my critiquing but I think you need a little more description and I'd like to know more about your feelings about your brother being favored!. And I want to know what your grlfriend looks like!. I think that would make this story the coolest!Www@QuestionHome@Com

To me, there's far too much telling and a bit too much dithering about at the beginning!. I don't know if that makes sense, but it could do with tightening up a bit!.

And definitely too many sentences beginning with 'but' and 'and'!. While it is perfectly acceptable to begin sentences like this, too many starts to sound a bit disjointed!.Www@QuestionHome@Com