Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> In Breaking Dawn does Charlie know that Bella is a vampire?


Question: In Breaking Dawn does Charlie know that Bella is a vampire!?
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Like everyone said, he doesn't know that she is a vampire!. All he knows is that Jacob can turn into a wolf, and bella is not the same!.!.!.regarding Renesmee, i think he knows that its bellas baby because he was so surprised when he saw her eyes and he was like she has your eyes!.!. but what struck me was, bella was like to charlie, she has your curls!. So that was kind of saying, yes this is my daughter!. But Bella won't tell charlie she is a vampire cause that breaks the rule of vampires and it could harm charlie because of the volturi!. Bella didn't want to leave charlie so she decided that charlie could come to his own conclusion on what she now is!.
I hope that helps!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Charlie knows that she isn't what she used to be anymore!. He's on a need to know policy for himself, and he doesn't want to know everything!. He does know that Jacob is a werewolf, shape-shifter, whatever you prefer, and he thinks that Renesmee is Edward's niece and they adopted her!. And I guess he was pretty surprised when he saw Renesmee's eyes!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No!. He is on a strictly "need to know" basis!. He knows that something is different but he never knows she's a vampire!. He does however know jacob is a werewolf!. When Charlie comes to visit Bella wears brown contacts!. She also has to have Esme teach her human behaviors!. Ex: Blink, mess with your hair!. etc!.

also Bella's venom i her eyes desintegrates her contacts so she has to change them every so often!. I think it was Alice who said that that would be a good thing because humans have to use the bathroom, so Charlie won't suspect anything!.

But no!.!. he doesn't know she's a vamp!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

okay, i thought that whole thing was lame!. because one of the main problems with Bella becoming a vampire was, Ooh no! what will charlie think! and then, he didn't even want to know!. I thought stephenie meyer took the easy way out with saying he "wanted to know as little as possible"!.!.!.!.really, would anyone's dad say that!?!!?!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Charlie just knew she was part of a supernatural family, because Jacob phased in front of him!. He wasn't quite sure what was wrong with her, but suspected something was up!. Bella didn't want him to know for sure so the Volturi wouldn't come after him!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

no!. jacob tells charlie that he is a wearwolf
well he shows him
bella says that charlie will make up something in his head of what he thinks they are!.!.!.and she is okay with that

seh cant tell him cuz then the volturi will kill him or make him a vamp!. so yeah!.!.!.unles he guesses she cant tell himWww@QuestionHome@Com

he knows that Jacob is a werewolf and has guessed that Bella is something more or less than human, but doesn't know exactly what!. He also has guess that Renesmee is actually Bella's baby, despite what Edward told him!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

no!.
he said he was on a strict need-to-know basis, and i'm sure that is one thing he did not want to learn!.
after all, i don't think he was too excited to see jacob as a werewolf!.!.!.i don't think charlie would like it too much if his daughter was a vampire!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

no but he's obviously suspecting something, I thought it was pretty weird!. And a tad bit unrealistic that he wouldn't want to be involved!. but then again, nothing in the Twilight universe is realistic!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

he only knows that jacobs a werewolf and that bella and the cullens arent human Www@QuestionHome@Com

Nope; he doesnt even know there ARE vamps!.
He just knows about "shape shifters" (jake)Www@QuestionHome@Com

No!. He only knows that Jacob is a vampire and thinks Bella just adopted Renessmee!. I think Renesmee showed her like a picture of Bella while giving birth and he thinks she was REALLY sick and dying and bleeding!. He just said he was on a strict need-to-know basis and I don't think he would want to know who Bella really is!.!.!.Hope this helps!Www@QuestionHome@Com