Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Who shouldn't have died in Harry Potter? (Harry Potter fans only. I don'


Question: Who shouldn't have died in Harry Potter!? (Harry Potter fans only!. I don't need to know if you don't care!)
I think, (After reading number 7, Snape, Tonks, Lupen, or Hedwig should have gone, What do you think!?!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I think that nobody except Voldemort and Bellatrix should have died!. I cried so much when Tonks and Lupin died!. And I think that Hedwig and Dobby shouldn't have die!. I mean come on what have Hedwig done!? He was just Harry's friend all the time!. And Dobby!? He saved Harry's life a lot of times!. It was so unfair!. And Tonks and Lupin died right after they had their baby!. It was sooo unfair to kill all those people!. That book was sooo sad to read it!.

RIP all of the dead people and creatures in Harry Potter and the deathly Hallows!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think the Weasley twin ( I can't remember if it was fred or george) should have lived!. But Tonks and Lupen had to die!.!.!.it was symbolic and wrapped up the story!. I was really sad when they did but it was necessary for the story and made it so much more emotional for the reader!.!.!.in a good way!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

i think the only people really necessary were Sirius!.!.it pains me to say that!.!.!. (<3) Lupin, Tonks, Dumbledore, Lilly and James, and Snape!. Although it woudn't have been bad if she let any of them live!. The main "protectors" of Harry had to die so that he could face Voldemort on his own!. Fred!.!.!.no!.!.!.I loved Fred!. I dont exactly get that!. I am REALLY glad that Bellatrix is dead!. SHE KILLED SIRIUS!!!! my favorite! and voledmort!.!.good thing he died!. I think she killed Hedwig to show that ti was going to be a long, hard journey!. Dobby didnt have to die!!! He was amazing!. Mad Eye, same reason as Hedwig!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

Tonks and Lupin were both very sad deaths!. They had a kid shortly before they died!. Collin Creevy was also sad, because he was just 16! Hedwig was sad because I liked her so much!. Fred's death made me almost cry!. Dobby also made me very sad!. He was so sweet! But Luna was such a good person, she helped Harry make Dobby's grave even though she never really knew him!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

OMG, FRED SHOULD NOT HAVE DIED! Either should have George! I cried my eyes out!. also, Tonks and Lupin!!!!!!!!!!!!! They had a baby!!!!!!!! I'm glad voldemort died though :)Www@QuestionHome@Com

SeriousWww@QuestionHome@Com

i definitely don't think hedwig 'should have gone'
i love her, haha!.


malfoy can fall in a ditch!. he's annoying!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com

Snape and Hedwig!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Bellatrix!.!.!.!.i was like!.!.noooooooooooo = [
Fred!. omg that was so sad!. I feel for George!. Dobby too!. So sad!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Tonks, Lupin (I cried so hard when they BOTH died), Fred, Snape!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com