Position:Home>Books & Authors> What did you think of Breaking Dawn? Yes or No and why?
Question: What did you think of Breaking Dawn!? Yes or No and why!?
Personally, I thought the whole first half of the book was ridiculous! Bella getting pregnant by vampire venom!? Wouldn't the venom kill any sperm that Edward has!? And the eggs in Bella, they would kill that too while turning her into a vampire because the venom was in her system! I thought the whole "Renesmee" concept was really random, and it made the feel for Twilight and the lovable characters all wrong!. Plus, I like the ending-- don't get me wrong--, but Bella throughout the whole story has had to make no sacrifices of her own to get what she wants! (until she thought herself dead better than killing the fetus/baby/thingy) But seriously, she is selfish and in reality no one ever gets that happy ending without making sacrifices!. Througout the whole book, Bella has gotten whatever she's wanted no matter how much it hurt other people around her!. She's been babied into thinking that it's none of her fault, too, even though she knows it is!. I just don't understand how she can be all "Oh, I don't care that a freaky talking fetus is breaking my bones, smashing my intournal organs, and forcing me to drink blood so it can thrive in my abdomen like a parasite! I don't care that it's killing me, I'm going to love it anyway, no matter how much it hurts those other people I love! I don't mind that the only reason Rosalie is helping me survive is to steal my fetus-child, I'll let her! I don't care that I'm dying on the floor and Rosalie is pretending that I'm healthy again while she's cuddling and nudging noses with my baby! I don't even care that my baby bit me! I'd let it bite me a thousand times just to see it's gorgeous, parasitic face!!! Such a blessing!!!" So Meyer has oficially lost it, and written a crap-ending to the saga!. Who agrees!?Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
As far as the pregnancy, I shunned all the pregnancy rumors all along becuase it's just not possible, Edwards bodily fluids, as Stephenie Meyer herself has said, have been replaced with VENOM! But then again it's a work of fiction, and I think if Peter Pan can fly Bella can get pregnant if thats the way Stephenie wants it!. Was it necessary though!? NO!. Jacob could have imprinted on someone else, anyone else!. Her actually having the baby was a beautiful thing to me though, most mothers would give up there lives for their baby, not something I would do, but beautiful none the less!. I think the novel itself was ended wonderfully though!. Ah Rosalie makes me sick!. Bella knew she was the only one who would take her side and help her keep her baby, so I can see why she ran to her, BUT she was even shocked "Rose" still felt the same way about her!. I love the fact that Renesmee was only a 'baby' for about 3 days though, haha Rose in your face!! She didnt get a baby after all!.
I loved it, but I rushed through it, so I need to re-read it!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
YES!.
I dont know if she lost it, but she ruined the book with her maternal-ness!. I mean, she got the host, right!? WHY would she ruin twilight!?!?!?
Www@QuestionHome@Com
the whole nessie thing big big mistake i thought it was completely stupied and should have just leaft off with eclipse i hope she does not ruin The HostWww@QuestionHome@Com
Bella is'nt a weak character!. Everyone thinks she is selfish how many of you would die for someone else to live!? Not many Www@QuestionHome@Com
You're my new best friend!. :D
Haha, seriously, you're SO right!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
i agree that the whole pregnancy thing was random and odd!.!.but i liked the book as a whole!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I really enjoyed it!. I definately saw NONE of it coming, thats for sure!. The only theory i got right was that Bella'd become a vamp and Jacob would imprint!. Lol!. And he suuureee did imprint!. It was alot more complex than the other ones, which i thought was good!. I really like that Edward and Jacob are friendly!. :) I think the only thing that bothered me was the whole pregnancy thing!. It was alittle disturbing!. I didnt really like the first book!. But I LOVED LOVED Jacob's book and the final Bella's book!. It was alot better in my opinion!. And when Bella showed Edward her thoughts!.!.!. oh my god!. I have never read anything more romantic!. Idk why!. I just thought that it was just!.!.!. inredible what she did!. But yeah!. Um!. I really really loved it!. I give the Bellas first book a 6!.!.!. Jacobs book a 100,000,000,000 and Bellas final book a 100,000,000,000,000,000!.7943698 :) lol
Im so sad its over :(
!.!.!.so i guess i disagree lol!.
oh btw!.!.!. if you ever get pregnant and become a mother!.!.!. i think your views on that will change IMMENSELY!. dont talk about things you know nothing about!. and if you do know about it, shame on you!.
EDIT: ahhh!. well!.!.!. if your a guy!.!.!. then you DEFINATELY have no place talking about things like pregnancy!. lol!. thats sortof ridiculous!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
well said!.!.!.
well bella is really weak character!.!.!. i mean she's been like this for the whole series!.!.!.
eek sometimes i just want to punch her :)
i think the first book was really good, i remember i couldn't stop reading it!.!.!.but after that i think the stephanie meyer kinda let her praises get to her head!.!.!.
breaking dawn was rushed, so many things happened in it!. and Bella was suppose to be the character whose nice, and unselfish!.!.!.but she's such a moron!.!.!.
she's not a good main character!.
hmm!.!.!.unlike harry potter, he's not perfect, which makes him realistic and likable!. okay lol totally random
but yeh yeh good insight for boy ofcourse!.!.!.i never knew guys read the series!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com