Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Anyone read Breaking Dawn by Stephenie Meyer yet? Your thoughts on it?


Question: Anyone read Breaking Dawn by Stephenie Meyer yet!? Your thoughts on it!?
Okay, so alot of people hated the book, but i for one loved it with all my heart!. I'm totally obsessed about reading it over and over again!. What are your thoughts on the new book!? What parts did you like and hate!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Ok, really now!. People are being unrealistic!. They are complaining about the sex scenes!. They were very tasteful!. There is worse on daytime TV!. Who cares!. The sexual tension has been there for three books and has been building up!. And when you are 18-19 you think about sex a lot!. I dont think she should have wrote this book for young adults if they cant handle that!. And if she didnt then she could have went into more detail and gotten more graphic!. People are complaining about the sex scences but not when they kill the animals or are in fight scenes!. People get a grip!. The Jacob imprinting thing was weird!. I dont like Jacob anyway he's a whiner and he always screws stuff up!. He should have died!. I think the book could have went into detail a little more about Bella being a vampire!. Her power was quite awesome!. It explains the reason why the Volutri and Edward couldnt read her thoughts or harmless!. This book connects all the things from the previous three books!. And how would Bella know she could get pregnant as i have seen on some postings!. He is dead! If you dont know what the implies go to Sex 101!. What is the age group for young adult!? Anyways, Edward was TRULY himself in this book because he no longer had to protect Bella after she became a vampire and they were the same now!. Both living as the undead!. You people need to read all the books again in a row and see the connections brought forth into this book!. The child i could have lived without but hey whatever!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I hated the pregnancy, which is most of the book!.

I hated the point of view switch twice!. once I got into jake, I didnt want bella's back!. and when I was in bella's, I didnt want jake to start,

I hated jake's imprinting!. NO jake, stay away from bella and her crazy family!

I did like the pack split!.

I wanted more action!
I felt as tho there wasnt enough action!.

this book just didnt fit with the other three!. I know last books usually arent that great because they are tying loose ends up, but this wasnt even LIKE the other ones!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i liked the parts where Jacob separates from the pack and seth and leah follow!. That was really good and well-written!. i hate hate hate how jacob imprints on Renesmee!. its gross!. will they ever tell Renesmee!? "oh btw darling i made out with your mother annd was in love with your mother until i met you!" ummm!.!.!.ick!. I like the Volturi, i hate how Alice runs away!. Renesmee took away all the romance!. i think SM should have just made Them get married, have a normal honeymoon, make Bella a vamp and go off to college happil ever after!. no mutant babies or weird imprinting!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

YES, people have read it!. Look at all the questions about it!. Wow!.

The only parts I liked where some in Book 2 (which is the only book in it that I liked)!. I loved when Jake broke from Sam and then Leah and Seth followed!.

I basically hated everything else, especially Nessie!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

EW!
You liked that book!? It's disturbing beyond all means!.
I mean, she made the birth scene more graphic than the sex scene which IMO is just "WTF THIS SHOULDNT BE IN A YOUNG ADULTS NOVEL"
And then, Edward is offering Jacob to pimp out his wife so she could kill the kid- WAIT WHAT!? Edward wants a abortion!? Dude, what the hell is this sending to the readers!? "Yo your wife is gonna be in pain when she gives birth kill your kid"

and then the most creepy thing of all-
Jacob falls in love with the kid!. called Nessie!.

Wait, waht!? can we say pedophillism and some degree of incest!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

*i was really disappointed!.!.!.it just wasnt the same writing that i was used to in the previous 3 novels!.!.!.
*i just dont think that bella having a kid would give people closure!.!.!.i doesnt seem right

*team jacob forever:)Www@QuestionHome@Com

you sound like you are talking about a child

"i love it with all my heart"

seriously, the book sucked

=DWww@QuestionHome@Com

Total crap!. Edward and Bella having a freak baby is just disgusting!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Hated:
Firstly, this is supposed to be a teen series!. I hardly think our generation needs any more reason to think it's okay and normal to want sex every single second!.!.!. i mean, come on! it's all bella thought about!

and the baby!? no!. no no no no no! that's what ruined it for me!. Mature in the mind or not, she's A) 18 and B) Now going to love something more than Edward!. This book wasn't supposed to be about a pregnant teenager!. it was supposed to focus on BELLA AND EDWARD! now, Edward is second to Renesmee!. That would be fine, were this MEANT to be a book about a young HUMAN family!.

also, it was too perfect in the end!. it was so perfect that it was dissapointing!. the volturi go without a fight, bella is superwoman, she gets to keep edward, she has a baby, charlie is still in her life, jacob is still her friend, and she has no REAL desire for blood!. this was a book about sacrifice!. all she lost was the ability to sleep through the stress!.

Everyone was WAY too out of character!. it was ridiculous!.

She changed her style completely!. It sounded like she got someone else to write it for her!.

The fact that Edward's very dead sperm made a baby!.

The fact that she was pregnant at all!. It repulsed me!. It was abnormal, and wrong, and beyond gross!. She acted like a zombie through it all, and then was all!.!.!. not bella!.

i hated the way edward changed her!. i expected it to be the big finish; what we had all been waiting for!. It was supposed to be an almost magical point of her life, her symbol of giving up herself to him!. Instead, it became a race to safe her "life!." Terrible!.

It was trashy!. How many sexual refrences are needed it a teen book!? I'd say none!. Lingerie!? Sexual refrences on EVERY PAGE!? Details every night!? Always thinking about it during the day!? Tearing down houses!?!?!? Two thumbs down!. Three, if I had another hand!.

The Volturi!.!.!.!. oh my!. We suffer through page after page of graphic and terrible writing, only to finally see some action!. So what happens!? They TALK IT OUT!?!?!?

She threw away mortality like it was garbage!. Stephenie could have made SUCH a dramatic goodbye scene to Charlie!. But it was like "Bye dad!. I'll never see you again, but I'll just not think about that!" COME ON! No normal person could bear that!. They would sob, at least CRY! They wouldn't be able to forget during their honeymoon!. She might as well have seen him dead: she would NEVER get to see him (had things gone as planned)

Charlie's "Need to know" thing!. If I was a parent and my child completely changed, looking nothing like the daughter I raised!.!.!. I wouldn't sit back and decide I didn't want to know! If her "adopted" daughter had my eyes!.!.!. Any REAL parent would die trying to figure out what was happening to their child!. Unrealistic!.

Edward was in the background through the whole book!.

Liked:
Book two!. Jacob was hilarious, and the only time we saw ANY action was here!. He took on his role as Alpha wonderfully!. I respected him when he refused to get Bella pregnant naturally!. Even when he imprinted, I wasn't repulsed, I felt happy for him, despite how weird it was!.

Jacob's chapter openings: hahahahahahaha!. brilliance!.

Seth Clearwater!. Who knew!?

That moment when you THINK the volturi will attack!.

Charlie in general!. I wish I had a Charlie!.

The wedding!. Especially when Jacob comes!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

I hated it!.

The things I hated about the book-
* Jacob imprinting on nessie!. The worst things in the book!. Its twisted, disgusting, and it seems so perverted almost!. I hate it!. SM ruined jacobs character!.
* The wedding service was very short, and I was expecting this to be a key point in the book
* The wierd innuendos!.!.!.!.!. the feathers!? broken headborads!? it seemed like somesort of sick erotica!. I don' t see why that was necessary!. We're not stupid, we know what they were planning to do on their wedding night!.
* THE BABY!.
*the fact that we never got an explanation for how the baby existed, edward has magical sperm!?!
* bella drinking blood!. This made me feel sick!.
* the birth scene was very disturbing!. SM must have a sick mind
* that edward asked jacob to have sex with bella
* the way jacob acted in book 3
* bella acting like a complete sex maniac
* the kids name- RENESMEE!?!?!
* that we didnt get a proper fight scene with the volturi
* that about 1000 characters were introduced near the end of the book!. I couldn't keep uo!.
* that bella adjusted so well to being a vampire, and shes so pretty and perfect, blah blah!. I expected drama as a newborn!. urgh
* the love shield!. So cliche!.
* the last sentence!.!.!. urgh
* that we had so many unanswered questions!. who was embrys dad!?!
* that jacob imprinting was used as a way to make everything all happy for everyone, when leah wanted to imprint and didnt!.
*the characters didnt act like themselves
* basically everything about the book!. It didnt make sense, and it was just disturbing in places!.

things I liked
* book 2 in jacobs POV (except the last bit)
* emmett was funny
*seth and leah!. I love these characters now!Www@QuestionHome@Com