Most shocking death in Harry Potter?x?

Question: Most shocking death in Harry Potter!?x!?

In your opinion, what was the most shocking death in the series!. I would have to say mine is a close contest between Cedric, Dumbledore and Fred, all of which reduced me to tears (I'm not a teary person!. I've never ever cried while watching a film or reading a book)Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

I knew after I read the second book that Dumbledore absolutely had to die if Harry was ever going to face Voldemort, so for me it was just a matter of time and curiosity to see how and when Rowling would do it!. I was sad when he died, but it was right that he died, so I wasn't terribly upset!.

I felt terrible when Cedric died, but I will tell you honestly that the two deaths which hit me the hardest were Dobby the House Elf, and Fred!. Dobby's death hit me hard because he was brave enough to go back into the Malfoy house where he had been treated so badly, and he he did it freely to help the good guys!. But Fred's death!.!.!.we'll that one really got me!. Fred and George are such a package deal in the books that I couldn't even imagine how George was supposed to go on afterward!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I would have to go with Dumbledore!. Not that I didn't like Cedric and Fred!. But Dumbledore played a main part in each and every book/movie!. Second I would have to pick Fred, because he was just a good kind hearted character that everyone could love!. Third I would go with Sirius Black!. Just as Harry had finally found a family member to love and be with, he gets taken away from him!. How devastating it has been to watch Harry go through all these constant blows!. It really is a shame for all the characters because in one way or another I grew fond of all of them because each played such a large roll in Harry's life!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Lupin and Tonks!. Here's this entire 7-book series about a boy who grew up with no parents, and now JK Rowling is condemning yet another baby boy to grow up without parents!? I understand that her purpose was to show how differently Teddy grew up, because Teddy was raised a wizard and had so many people who loved him, unlike Harry being raised by the Dursleys!. But understanding her purpose doesn't mean I have to like it or approve of it!.

Lupin and Tonks deserved a long life together and many more children!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Hedwig disappointed me the most!. I kept thinking they were going to go on reconaissance and find her injured!.!.!.or she was going to show up later in the story!. (It always hits the worst when there are animal casualties)!. I understand a war was going on, but this was a really shocking book for me!. I agree with the above comment about George going on without Fred!. That aspect alone deserves a spin-off book!.

Cedric's death was so shocking because it was the 'first death' actually witnessed by the reader in the series!. It was the pivotal point, we were now moving from kids stuff to adult-type magnitude!. And the books just got darker and darker from there!. Can you imagine the controversy if JK flat-out outed Dumbledore in the series instead of hinting at it!? You think the Christian groups were freakin' before!? But I digress!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It was severus snape's death that brought tears to my eyes!.

all along from the 1st book to the 6 th book!.!.!. i thought snape was a mean bastard!.!.!.

then in the 7th book!.!.!.!.i felt so sad when they explained snape's real character!. it was so heart warming!.!.!.especially since he loved Lily potter till death!.!.!.and his sacrifice for harrypotter!.!.!.all of it was great of him/

fred and dobby's death was also shocking!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Cedric wasnt a major character!.!. Fred was awesome and il sure miss his part!. But dumbledore's death shocked me as it was really unexpected!.!.and i would think that he needed to survive in order to help harry in destroying voldemort!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Um i would have 2 say Fred! but than maybe dumbledore but mostly fred!

-Twilight <3 Nick Jonas
Days till breaking dawn:11Www@QuestionHome@Com

Oh, very hard choice to make!.!.!.
Fred's, Dobby's, Sirius's and Snape's would probably be most shocking for me!. They all made me cry sooo bad, but I cried most at Fred's and Dobby's!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

dobby or sirius!.
dumbledore had lived a long life and sirius could have looked after harry :(Www@QuestionHome@Com

Fred Weasley!. George and Fred were my favourite characters, and I was really, really upset when Fred got killed!. I still wish Rowling hadn't done it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

fred!.
it was uncalled for!.

i cried!. hell yea i cried!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

My death!.!. By far wins, after that Fred Weasley's death!.!.

Lord Voldemort's death saddened me, for it meant the end of the series that is all!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

All of them are sad!. and there was no need for Fred to die!. But the one that made me cry was Hedwig (sorry if i didnt spell that right) Harry's bird!. TT_TTWww@QuestionHome@Com

I'd say Sirius!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

it's between dumbledore and fred!. they were both sort of unexpectedWww@QuestionHome@Com

Fred hit me really hard!. The fact that he was killed just felt so impersonal!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Fred - that was just wrong!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

fred
hes nt supposed 2 die!.what is wrong with u J!.K!?!?!?!?!?Www@QuestionHome@Com