Position:Home>Books & Authors> Edward or Jacob?(for if youve read up to eclipse)?
Question: Edward or Jacob!?(for if youve read up to eclipse)!?
Who,why, and why not!!?good things and bad things on each character!
Edward:A vampire(which is fine with me cause jacobs a werewolf)but he is like a Statue!.!.!.a walking talking perfect ,good looking and smelling ,human eye candy!.Does everything almost perfectly and a fairytale!.cares about her anough to die because she dies
why not:well he has nothing else to really live for if you tihnk about it!.!.!.hes basically a old man, an 80 year-old man in a cute 17 year old vampire's body!.!.!.hes a living rock,A WALKING TALKING PERFECT STATUE!!.whats so special about HIM!?hes over protective and tempermental (sorry Edward fans its just the truth)
Jacob:is a tall realistic cute guy,hes not as tempermental as edward ,yes hes had his mood swings and stuff like a real GUY does but only for bella and that the guy she loves basicly is the cause!.also that Edward kind of ruined his life, Edward is not even really supposed to be in the world and he steals Bella !
thats what i tihnk so what about you!?Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
i think that bella is attracted to edward because of his good looks!. i mean who wouldn't be!. she was attracted to him the very first time she layed eyes on him!. at first she didn't like him but she did like him in some sort of way!. and when he met her in port angeles i think thats when she realized that she loved him!. i think the reason she likes him is the fact that he is a vampire!. and also the things he tells her!. like how she is the most important thing to him and basically how he woos her!. and then he leaves her!. which leads to jacob!. bella was so ignorant to jacob!. i mean he was so much in love with her and she didn't even realize it!. i mean she was falling in love with jacob in new moon but she didn't realize it until that one part in eclipse!. i totally understand her i mean her first love was fast and romantic but when she was falling in love with jacob it wasn't that romantic!. she just always wanted to see him a lot!. then edward comes back and bella leaves jacob!. and now hes heart broken!. but i think that the reason she goes back to edward is because some part of her still loves him a lot!. but why i think she goes back to him is because edward was her first love!. she doesn't want to forget him!. i mean when you are in love and especially your first love you think that it will last forever!. like nothing can get in the way!. so when she heard edward was in danger her first instinct was to save him!. and it also has to do with the drug thing!. like how jacob says that edward is bella's drug!. thats so true!. i mean she was hanging on edward like he was a drug!. and then he leaves because he knows he's bad for her!. and then he comes back and her going back to him symbolizes that she wants to take the drug again!. and drugs do kill a person in the end right!? so i think thats whats going to happen in the end!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
You have a really good point about edward i neverr tought about it that way but on the other hand edward is so caring and loves bella more than anything he cant live wihtout her and bell not without him they are meant for each otehr for better or worse jacob will find soeone else even if it takes him foerever where as edward may not!Www@QuestionHome@Com
I have always liked Edward over Jacob!. Cause I always though Jacob was too moody and pushy!. But Edward can be moody too and also very hardheaded!. The thing that I like about both of them is that they would do anything for Bella!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I have always liked Edward better!.!.!.Bella loves him more!.
also, it isn't really Edward who steals her from Jacob, Bella was with Edward first!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
Edward!.!.!.
Besides--She loves Edward, ONLY thinks of Jacob as a friend and Jacob is younger than her!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
Go team Edward!!
Bella only Loves Jacob as a brother!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
there is only 4 words to explain this EDWARD IS JUST BETTERWww@QuestionHome@Com
TEAM EDWARD FOR LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3Www@QuestionHome@Com
jacob is soo friekin stupid he cant just go kiss a girl with a boyfriend i also think bella is stupid for asking jacob to kiss her especially since she is engaged!. i know jacob was kind of forcing her i mean he was literally sayin kiss me or ill die!.
edward hasnt done anything stupid ecept leave bella so that she could find jacob!. also he says that jacob can kiss bella as long as he has permission from her i mean that is stupid!.
but edward is really supportive in a lot of bellas choices and jacob is against a lot of it so i choose !.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.
EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com
I totally agree with you!. Jacob is real, he has faults, and he does not have the characteristics and personality traits of a rock!. Edward needs to loosen up, and get a grip!. Yes, Bella loves him, now he needs to let her have some fun! Jacob is fun loving, wild, arrogant, 6'7'', halarious, friendly, easy to talk to, eager to please, and he is ALIVE!. ha ha, hes just like me, but Im not quite his height lol!.
But, I want Bella to stay with Edward, because she need to be with the person she loves!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
This is a difficult decision, but I choose Edward!. You forgot to point out he is smart and can play piano, both are big turn ons for me!. Jacob isn't as mature, and I wouldn't like to hang around with a guy who is always half naked!. That would be awkward!. And the size of him is literally scary!. also, Jacob didn't imprint on her, so she's not his perfect match!. The relationship between Bella and Edward, He loves her because she loves him and vice versa!. Edward never thought anyone would love him in that way!. Bella thought guys didn't like her!. That's a big part that brings them close together!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I like both of them i mean they both have there pros and cons!. Personally I think that Jacob would be better for Bella because I don't want Bella to become a vampire but Bella loves Edward and so I guess Edward and Bella should go togehter besides the fact that Edward is totally over- protective, a vampire and I agree half ot the reason Bella is with him is just because of his looks!. But Jacob is younger then Bella so that is kind of weird but Edward is younger than Bella to technically but at the same time he is also ancient so I am going to have to say Mike yeah i know go ahead and hate me for saying Mike but both Edward and Jacob have there pros and cons I can't chooseWww@QuestionHome@Com
Edward is abolutely AMAZING!!!!!!!! He isn't overprrotective, he just is so in love with Bella that he couldn't stand it if anything ever happed to her, he'd die himself!. I feel bad for him, Bella almost died right in front of his eyes three times in just Twilight, nevermind New Moon and Eclipse!. Jacob is just a jerk that tries to throw himself onto Bella!. She explains to him kindly, so as not to hurt him that se loves him as a friend and nothing more, but he still doesn't get it!. When she does realize she loves him, she still doesn't love him as much as Edward, which she also tries to explain to him, but he doesn't understand that either!. He thinks he is being the better person because he is letting Edward have her because it is her choice, but that takes him until he almost dies, and kills himself to kiss her against her will to realize that!. However, from the beginning Edward will let her go to him if that is what she truly wants, he is at no point to stop her and keep he if she would rather be with Jacob, but she doesn't!. Edward wants only Bellas happiness, no matter what she chooses, Jacob wants Bella with him no matter the consequences, which is incredibly selfish!. If she were to go with Jacob she would end up dead anyway because the volturi would come and kill her!. Edward is incredibly sweet and kind!. He cares for her, that is his world!. Oh well if he shouldn't be there, he is, he does NOT steal Bella, it is her own choice, she could have chose Jacob and Edward would leave Forks, no matter the terrible pain he would feel from her rejection, because it would be what SHE wants!. But, she chose EDWARD!!!!!! Edward is amazing, so what if he's 80 years old!? That doesn't matter to either of them , so why should it matter to anyone else!? Edward didn't ruin ANYONEs life!!! Jacob did it to himself, it's not Edwards fault Jacob is in love with Bella, and it isn't Edward's fault Bella chose Edward, she made her own decision, she met Edward first, and fell in love with him first, and either way, she loves him MORE than Jacob!. Maybe Jacob shouldn't be attracted to Bella, maybe he shouldn't have ignored Bella when he changed, maybe he shouldn't have ignored his place as pack leader, maybe he shouldn't have taken it upon himself to decide how Bella felt about himself!. None of this was Edward's fault, Jacob condemned himself, no one elsse, especially edward had anything to do with it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com