Is this photo any good?

Question: Is this photo any good!?

http://i285!.photobucket!.com/albums/ll67/!.!.!.

i took it for an art project that i am currently working on!. [halfway done] what do you think!? rate it 1/10!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

I think it may have started as a good photograph, but there is a little too much post production on it right now!. Remember, LESS IS MORE!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Why not put a tiny white new moon in the sky off to the right!? I like it -give it an 8!. Ok maybe the moon is too much!. Less is more but the contrast is kind of stark between the sunset and the white and black of the tennis shoes!. Why not make more of a triangle with the trees, shoes and moon!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

I give a 9! Great dof shoes are up front and big- sun is setting- theme would be Game over! Every one's gone home- win lose or draw it was a great day! I'll pick up my shoes again tomorrow and get the winning point! Its not 10 because that would be perfect- I have yet to see a perfect photograph- some real close but not quite! I think shoes make great subjects too!
http://www!.flickr!.com/photos/21125021@N0!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yes!.

It's an imaginative image!. It's in focus and well exposed!. What is the connection you're trying to make between the sunset and the shoes!?
That part I find a little confusing!. Give it some thought!. I'l look forward to seeing your next image in the art project!.

Nick
Www@QuestionHome@Com

i give it about a 4!.!.!.!. i think youve done WAY to much post editing!.!.!. i like the less is more quote the first answer'er had!.!.!. to me, theres way to much going on!.!.!. the whites are blown, the flash was to bright!.!.!. and it looks like you 'sharpened' the heck out of it!.!.!. keep trying!.!.!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

The whole picture itself feels a bit staged!. I like the composition and exposure though, good job! However, the key to every inspiring photo is that it tells a story!. Use your imagination and think of creative links! Www@QuestionHome@Com

not quite my style, but it's original and that's great!. there's no need to have a connection between the shoes and sky- that's the beauty of photography!. i'd give it a 7, mainly 'cus there's too much glare on the grass!. keep it up, girl!. you've got talentWww@QuestionHome@Com

6 move the shoes a bit back Www@QuestionHome@Com

8 maybe, i agree with the-how does the shoes and sunset connect- but its a great photoWww@QuestionHome@Com

10
i like it a lot;]Www@QuestionHome@Com

I like it, it's really cool!
=]Www@QuestionHome@Com

10 so cool! I love it!Www@QuestionHome@Com