Question Home

Position:Home>Poetry> You ever believe that things can hold memories?


Question: You ever believe that things can hold memories!?
Please give me your analysis of the following poem, and any constructive criticism!. It IS a work in progress (as so many of 'em are) and I will listen!. You just gotta trust me on that!.

Carved In Wood

I remember when I first moved in!.
I was still just a small sapling-of-a-tree;
The house smelled of fresh saw dust somewhat,
And the yard was big enough I could grow free!.

I remember the chimney catching fire,
And what a daze that blaze put me in!.
I wasn’t the same for along time after that,
But I ended up growing stronger from within!.

I remember the tree-house and the friends:
They thought I was cool, so they all hung around!.
Twenty-seven different pets and their shoe-boxes—
Their bones and marbles—later would be found!.

The sweet magnolia that once lived next door,
And the old garage that used to be at the end of the drive!.
Those were the days—back’n I’s hard as an oak and strong,
Not falling apart and favoring my one side!.

Times are a lot different now!. All the kids are gone;
There’s no one to rake up the leaves!.
Not much left, but
The memories!.


Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I believe that as it is, this poem is a work of art, and it should be untouched!. But, that is entirely up to you!. I loved the imagery, and I felt as if I was actually listening to the old tree where I used to live, which was in much the same condition when I moved out of my old house at the age of 19!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

At first, I thought it was about a child, then realized it was a tree!. I like Iano's changing "moved in" to "arrived!." It is a touching poem, and I enjoyed reading it, and did several times!. We will always hold our memories!. But, it's not really about a tree!.!.!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Magnificent imagery here! Metaphors are well done, as also personification!
Applause! For these, the gold of memories!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I believe with all my heart!.
I like this piece of work
I am not one to give critcism lightly!.
I shall abstain as it gives me deep paws for thought!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Can't find any fault!.
It brings me to my own memories!.
NICE!. VERY NICE!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

My friend, I don't know enough about poetry to give you the critique you are looking for on this piece!. I do love where it is going and agree that it has a 'feel' to it that you are not there yet, but I cannot put my finger on it!.

And a comment on the additional details!.!.!.!.you tell 'em!

PromiseWww@QuestionHome@Com

I'm with Promise on this!. It has a very good feel to it!. keep refining it and "growing" it!. I'd like to read more episodes!. The voice of the Tree is very strong but I agree the "moved in" phrase needs replacement !? "planted roots", "took root"!. "claimed my position" "came to stay" etc otherwise developing well!.
Thank you for your statement too!. I respect your thoughts!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

A very worthy effort, but the phraseology is a bit unnatural in places (but trivially so) in order to make it rhyme!. With a bit of revision it should brush up nicely!. I believe "saw dust" is one word - "sawdust"!. In line 1, I'd change "moved in" to something like "arrived" or "was planted" because it's not really applicable to a tree!. Or even just put it in quotes to show it's not meant literally in the way that humans "move in"!. Otherwise, on first reading, it sounds as if you're saying the tree moved in to the house!.

(Surely there must be someone else on this site who finds Vision even more annoying than they do me!? And as for the one above, they do say that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery!.)Www@QuestionHome@Com

U R NUMBER SEVEN WE LOVE TO KNOW WHEN WE ALL GO AND we shall meet u know when IN heaven as i am also seven hbdtu

SAGITTARIUS

Sunny feelings brimming with youth,

Aware of ones opportunity and beaming strength,

Go getting an attitude, till the end but never make amend,

Are characteristic traits of dear friends Saggy!?

To befriend many and move along with their baggy,

Towards greener pastures and heavenly blues!.

All my friends do know, is cease an opportunity,

Remembering that it may not pass their way,

In the event of time as times do stray!.

Universally Saggy, do display love and affection politely,

Such is their demeanour to show they are really friendly

Copyright ?VISION
!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com