Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Do you feel like turning to God solves all your problems?


Question: Do you feel like turning to God solves all your problems!?
Earlier today, when I went to go pay my bills, 1 of my neighbors saw me & asked me how come she hasn't been seeing me around!. I told her about my depression!. I have MAJOR Depression!. I guess you can say Clinical depression!. But anyway, I take Wellbutrin, & I'm still depressed!.

So, later, we talked some more, & she said, "You CHOOSE to be depressed!. No one can make you happy but you!. Just turn to God!." That made me feel very hurt!. Depression is NOT my fault!. I don't choose to feel this way!. Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
anyone who uses god in any way to counsel u towards mental health should be IMMEDIATLEY tuned out
Www@QuestionHome@Com

People who think this way have God confused with Santa Claus!. If you do not believe in God, simply tell them to have a nice day!. If you believe in God, explain that God hands you the "means" to improve your life, but they are sometimes a row boat and sometimes a pill, and sometimes, with patience, another solution!. If God fixes every problem now, why do Christian children die in fires or Islamic children get horrible diseases!? God does not favor his followers with magical gifts, (ala Santa Claus) but with wisdom and patience, when they are very quiet and listen for it!.

As I see it, God sometimes gives me a direction to paddle but moving the canoe is MY gig!. I try to be like the swans, serene and meditative on the surface, and paddling like hell under the water!.

Good luck with your illness!. I too have had bouts of clinical depression for 30 years!. I am doing okay with it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm not religious, but from everything I have heard and read, prayer in troubled times is to ask for the strength to get through your troubles, not to solve them!.
I hope you feel better soon!. Don't let people hurt you with what they say, especially if they have no experience with your problems!. But keep your ears open for good advice!. you never know where you might find it!.


Www@QuestionHome@Com

lol what she said made no sense!. you shoulda called her out!.

"!.!.!.No one can make you happy but you!." next sentence!.

"just turn to God"!.

hate to break it to you!. your neighbor's an idiotWww@QuestionHome@Com

I don't know!. People have told me that faith and religion will help me with my depression but I guess I'm too skeptical!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

your neighbor is an idiot!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

it is you only who wants what to do!. GOD WILL ONLY HELP YOU !. THANSWww@QuestionHome@Com

i am god!. pardon my sense of humor!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

What she means is Mind is something we have the ability to control!. Carnegie said "we are what we think about all day long!."
I'm not going to say that you don't have some physical contributing factors to your ailments I'm not a Doctor!. I do know that we have the power to choose our thoughts though!. Volition!. There is a quote I'm going to share with you I hope it has meaning for you and please visit the link if you like the quote!.

Mind is your ship, the spirit is your pilot, the human will is captain!. The master of the mortal vessel should have the wisdom to trust the divine pilot to guide the ascending soul into the harbors of eternal survival!. Only by selfishness, slothfulness, and sinfulness can the will of man reject the guidance of such a loving pilot and eventually wreck the mortal career upon the evil shoals of rejected mercy and upon the rocks of embraced sin!. With your consent, this faithful pilot will safely carry you across the barriers of time and the handicaps of space to the very source of the divine mind and on beyond, even to the Paradise Father!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

People are cruel!. The person who told you that has a very poor understanding of God and theology!.

Jesus Himself told us that we would face trials and difficulties in this life!. He didn't promise to take our troubles away, but rather send us a comforter to aid us and to be with us, always!.

You cannot make yourself happy, and God may in His infinite wisdom may allow us to suffer in this life, but do try to take to heart that, since God is all knowing, all powerful, and all wise, that if He allows you to suffer, then it is for your own future welfare and His glory!. Paul actually has the audacity to tell us to be thankful in all things!.

Believe it or not, when I am feeling especially down, or am hurting, or some other thing just isn't going my way, if I remember to thank God, that even though I don't understand how, that this is for my good and His glory, and that He is using this to make me more like Christ, it does actually help!. It doesn't make the pain go away, but it gives me a handle to take hold of it!. Prayer is a powerful thing!.

Make the time to study your Bible daily!. Find a good Bible-believing, Bible-teaching church and build relationships with the people there!. Try to pray constantly!. Prayer is merely talking to God in you head, you need not close your eyes!.!.!. especially if you happen to also be driving!. :-)

God Bless You!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Your neighbor is half right (the God part is not the part she's right on)!. You are making the choice to continue to be depressed!. You are an autonomous moral agent that needs to recognize that your life is your responsibility!. Humans can and do exercise control over their emotions!. We know this to be true since we educate children to change and modify their behavior!. We normally don't see a 20 year old crying and carrying on like a 2 year old!. What changed!? The 20 year old learned emotion control that changed them!.

The problem with depression is the reoccurring thought patterns that generate depression!. The quick medical answer of today is to give people some type of pill, which may help but seldom cures it!. Since the medical profession is more comfortable with the physical properties of the body they generally always look for the solution there!. The problem is that it doesn't change your thoughts, which means the pill is like drinking alcohol it changes you for a while but doesn't change you for good!.

You need to acknowledge to your self that your happiness is your responsibility!. That you have a sickness called depression but you are the one that needs to fight it!. The first thing you should do is find away to naturally to get your body to release uplifting chemicals!. Lucky for you there is an easy way to do this -- physical exercise!. Start exercising like crazy!. Run, walk, bike to the point of physical exhaustion!. Make a plan to exercise everyday!. Second, I would find a cognitive behavior psychologist!. They focus on getting people to change their thought patterns!. Don't go to a Freudian psychologist they're worthless!. Good Luck and remember it's your choice how you feel!.

To answer the main question, turning to God means turning to some emotional based understanding that you have about a God!. Generally this mystical notion is the one you grew up around and does nothing to change you; except and unless you are changing yourself into how you imagined this relationship with God would work!. In other words, it’s wish fulfillment, which may or may not work!. If it works it’s not because of God but because you choose to change!. Embrace the responsibility of your own life and you can change in anyway you deem necessary for your happiness!.Www@QuestionHome@Com