Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> If your suicide results in the suicides of others, is that considered murder in


Question: If your suicide results in the suicides of others, is that considered murder in the spiritual sense!?
I'm not sure if it's really any better than murder since if you hadn't killed yourself those other people wouldn't have, but then again you didn't force their hands technically!.!.!. What do you think!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
no, the person that first committed suicide isn't the reason the second committed suicide!. instead, it was the second person's flawed judgment that lead him to kill himself!.

Although the first person may have contributed, he is not directly the cause!.

Should he be accountable for the others suicide because his action inevitably lead to the others suicide!? NO!.

If we were all fully accountable to each other, it would necessarily imply that we do not have freedom to live our own lives and must always be confined by the judgment of others!.

Social life is a compromise and we are ultimately only PARTIALLY accountable to others!.

If someone wanted to commit suicide, there is nothing to which he has more of an indelible right than to his own life, no matter what people's judgment of the action may be!.

If you left your gf/bf and he/she killed him/herself, is it your fault!? No!. Their actions are the result of their own judgment- whether adequate or inadequate!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

suicide is bad!.!.!.you are actually convicting yourself with it!.!.!.when love and hope is gone!.!.!.this will be your course!.!.!.complaining isn't bad!.!.but then we are given choices!.!.!.to do what is good and what is bad!.!.!.if you have no hope and love for yourself!.!.be willing to share your love to others and share your hopes!.!.!.!.killing yourself is not good!.!.!.if you do it!.!.!.!.you judged your self and condemn you as a person!.!.!.!.!.!.so what good is it!.!.!.!.there is always a choice!.!.!.there is always hope and love!.!.!.just turn around seek God!.!.!.!.and you will be surprised life is worth living!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

well ultimately its there choice!. your not going to be judged for there actions because if there going to do it then eventually something going to trigger in there mind that makes them follow through with the act!. but remember there is a difference between suicide and sacrifice!. sacrifice is for others benefit but suicide is selfish act and is considered one if the greatest sins!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No it is not murder!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

What other people do is their own choice!.Www@QuestionHome@Com