Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> If God is so perfect and all knowing, then how come he didn't make a perfect


Question: If God is so perfect and all knowing, then how come he didn't make a perfect world nor the perfect being!?
If god is real and what is said about him is true then why do We have a world with death and chaos!. A wold where we as humans are not so perfect!. If someone like god is as perfect as the books say of him/her/it!. Then why all this, us, The World!.

My point is that, this simple contradiction is all that is need to disprove the theory of such a Gods existence!. Unless of course someone were to provide a compelling argument or answer to follow this question!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Look up quantum logic!. Contradictory attributes can coexist!. As quantum physics proves, contradiction does not negate truth!. The only rebuttal is to suggest that God only exists on the Newtonian level!.

The conflict between Newtonian, relativistic, and quantum logics / sciences, only proves that the rules are not universal!.!.!. what holds true on one level doesnt on another!. So how can we use one form of logic to assert any sort of universal truth!?

Newtonian logic has done wonders for resolving Newtonian level social controversy!. God knows it doesnt work!.

Secondly!. God created all things!. That means he created physics, gravity!.!.!. AND LOGIC!. So what if our descriptions of him are logically contradictory!? They are his rules and he is not bound by them!.

Atheists constantly argue in favor of subjectivity!. Subjective this and subjective that!. So!.!.!. I ask you!.!.!. imperfect by whose subjective standards!? Yours/ mine!? Or Gods!?

Theists will argue that our imperfection is a consequence of our own choices in a world where God first gave us free will!. That was the point things deteriorated!. Humanity, not God, is to blame for humans making imperfect decisions!.

Most of your theological questions can be answered by actually reading the Bible!. Religious or not, if you care to know the answer, its not even a faith based answer!.!.!. its explicitly stated in tenet!. Feel free to read the texts!.

Furthermore, who is to say that we even understand God at all!? We site characteristics!.!.!. but those are characteristics that we assert ideally and presume to be true about him!. They are our interpretations of his being!. Perhaps they are true though!. The very contradictions you are concerned with are only how we perceive it!.!.!. not necessarily how it truly is!. Contradictory by whose subjective standard!?

Even if Christian dogma was true, we must contend with centuries of social, cultural and linguistic change which has skewed our translation and interpretation of the Bible!. Not that its untrue, per se, but some of the meanings and technicalities might be a bit off!. So that can account for contradiction yet again

The very logic we use is a bastardized human logic!. We have used what we were emotionally comfortable with!.!.!. we have shown confidence in!.!.!. and our intuition and instinct is what derived the rules of deductive reasoning to begin with!. Our logic was derived by and affirmed with emotion and rhetoric and everything else we assume to be irrational because it isnt logical!. Logic cannot be used to prove logic, and no tangible evidence exists supporting logic!. What could the rules of logic been derived with before logic was even known!? Pondering that you will realize that logic is only as good as the illogic that formulated it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm not sure there is any evidence that suggests God is perfect!. According to the Bible, someone named God did created the heavens, the earth, and man; but, I don't remember reading anything in the Bible that alludes to God being "perfect"!.

According to the Bible, God created "man" in "his image"!. No where does the Bible report that God was "perfect"!.

There is no indication in the Bible, or in any other writings, that people would not be subjected to death, torture, or chaos!. Yes, the Bible does indicate that Adam and Eve had a choice to "live happily ever after" if they chose not to "eat" of the "tree of life"; but, they "chose" to "eat"!.

Each of us is responsible for our own actions--helping or not helping the poor and unfortunate, those who are being forced to endure unspeakable cruelties, standing against tyranny and injustice, physically fighting, if necessary, to protect those who are no able to protect themselves!.

"Blaming" God for human imperfections is, to me, unacceptable!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

stop living in haluciation there is no god as such!.!.it's a myth which we have been hearing from centuries!. and we believe in god because we have been listening from our childhood!. and why you want to believe in god!.!.it is so for the simple reason that whatever wish you have you can ask him to fullfill those!.!.!.and if you look at your prayer they are nothing just begging!.!.god give us this give us that!.!.!.mere begging nothing else!.!.!.there is no god as such but there is existence which take care of your basic need!.!.!.like even before you born mothers breast fills with milk before asking anything!.!.please don't misrelate existence with god!.!.!.existence give you everything before you need you don't have to ask for it!.!.!.when i say existence it means tree,sea,wind,sun etc!.!.who plays a more important role in our life than a god!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Skirting the issue of existence of God for the moment, God, as depicted in almost all religions, did create everything perfect!. Humans (those intelligent animals) were also given free will!. The present status is the result of the way this right was exercised!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Up until the last 200 years, religion had the power to kill you as a heretic for question it!. Today, they're still getting away with murder, but to a lesser extent and within time, religion will be obsolete!. Ever see a futuristic movie where religion still exists!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Thank you, Mr!. Alpha Omega!.

He's real, he's tricking you, and you fell right into his trap!.
He's probably playing a game with you and he's definitely winning!.

He want's to see if we can make ourselves perfect, if we can make the world perfect!. Or I'm insane, because DUH we can't be perfect!. It's like he expects us to be just like him!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

God have make a man i!.e!. human body!. It is a wonderful gift of nature!. wonder of wonders and king of miracles!. Human brain is super natural!. Gift of wisdom is added to it!. And more over thinking power is given to the man!. He also has given the freedom of deed!. It is up-to human being to act accordingly!. There is laws of nature, " As you think , so you become"!. So how to think is in the hands of man and not in the hands of God!. God has nothing to do with it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

He did not make a perfect human because he made us with free will!. We can either believe in him or not!. He gave us freedom to do what we want!. Unfortunately, some people take advantage of their free will and thus comes the world as it is today!. We cannot be perfect because we can do what we want, and what is perfection anyways!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

How are we to know what G*d's plan is!?

As you say, G*d is a perfect being; and therefore this statement of yours proves the existence of G*d!.

For a perfect being to be perfect, it must exist; therefore G*d does exist!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

you know the meaning of perfection because of imperfections with which you can compare if everything is
"perfect" it is'nt infact it will be completley imperfect!
so perfect is imperfect vice versa!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

If god exists why should he/she create a perfect world!? what makes you think you or I deserve a perfect world, and would you recognise a perfect world if one is created for you, besides, define perfect!? perfect for what!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

How can one be sure that a "God" even exists in the first place!?
And if he did, how would you know that his motive and desire was to create a "perfect" world and a "perfect" being!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

god is everywhere change your outlook , is there any factry who can make blood ask to your self yes you are that factory and god is making your blood he became your labour to making blood and you blaming him
world is gr8Www@QuestionHome@Com

God has made the perfect being; very perfect ones until these beings can even arguing His existence by all their perfectnesses!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

God gave humans a choice, and the human factor is what creates chaos!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

well i think that GOD has made everything perfectly
but it is us who r doing things imperfectlyWww@QuestionHome@Com

poverty and death and war a human which manufacture these things!.!.!.to see the lives of most Creation of God's you will understand what I meanWww@QuestionHome@Com

because man made god!. gods not real!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because we were given choice!. If we were not given choice, we wouldn't be able to choose to do the wrong thing, we wouldn't be able to choose to believe in God!. Most people look at choice and don't understand the true significance of it!. If we weren't given choice, we would not even be having this conversation right now!.

We were created in His image!. God wanted to create something that would love Him because they wanted to!. If we didn't choose love, it becomes less significant in the grand scheme of things!. Just like that saying that if you don't have bad experiences, you can't possibly appreciate the good ones!. Would you want to be loved by a souless partner who loved you because you made them!?

Have you ever seen Bruce Almighty!? A lot of stuff wasn't really God related!. But the one thing he couldn't do was mess with free will!. In the end, his ultimate prayer was that Grace would find happiness!. It meant that much more when she chose to love Bruce anyway than it would if Bruce had forced her to!.

"In His image" means freedom of choice and more complex thought to make choices!. All other beings on earth only have lower brain function and do things purely based on instinct!. They don't choose against it like we often do!.

The next question is typically 'if God loves us, why does He send people to hell!?' This is also choice!. If we were without choice, we would be without sin and no one would face hell!. Since the human race chose to sin, God sent Jesus to pay the debt so that those who wished to accept the payment reach heaven!. People think good works get them to heaven, but the only thing that does is another choice!. We choose to accept the gift for real in our hearts!. That's it!. We can't earn something like salvation when we were not born supreme beings!. Jesus earned it and gives it to us, but many people let their choices get in the way!.

Hope that helpsWww@QuestionHome@Com