Question Home

Position:Home>History> Are there similarities between zionism and nazism?


Question: Are there similarities between zionism and nazism!?
Given that the Jewish people believe they are the chosen people of god and also considering their continuing propensity for land grab how does this compare to hitlers belief in the superiority of the Aryan race "master race" and his strategy of expanding germanys borders in order to provide more land for "the master race"!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Yes, there are many similarities!.

Both zionism and nazism emerged from the same nationalistic milieu of the early part of the 20th century!.

Both teach master race doctrines; the nazis focused on the Jews as their target; the zionists focus on the Palestinians as their target!.

Many Jews themselves recognize the similarities and are appalled by zionism!.

For more info, please see

Jews Not Zionists
http://www!.jewsnotzionists!.org

Orthodox Jewish Holocaust victims:
Neturei Karta
http://www!.nkusa!.org

The speech of Sir Gerald Kaufman, member of Parliament, just a few days ago:

UK Jewish MP: Israel acting like Nazis in Gaza
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=qMGuYjt6C!.!.!.

EDIT:

Yes, the analogy of the bullied person himself becoming a bully is apt!. The molested child often goes on to become the molester!. Similar historical examples include the persecuted Puritans of England themselves becoming the persecuting Puritans of America; and the persecuted Dutch Boers of South Africa whose families were left to die by British Lord Kitchener's concentration camps who later themselves instituted apartheid against the blacks of South Africa!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

hello

at my first glance i was shocked/ offended at your question

but with reflection its a very valid point

- Zionism is an international political movement that originally supported the reestablishment of a homeland for the Jewish People in the historic Land of Israel (Hebrew: Eretz Yisra'el, "the Land of Israel"), later on called Palestine, and continues primarily as support for the modern state of Israel!.

- Nazism has come to stand for a belief in the superiority of an Aryan race, an abstraction of the Germanic peoples!. During Hitler’s time, the Nazis advocated a strong, centralized government under the Führer and claimed to defend Germany and the German people (including those of German ethnicity abroad) against Communism and so-called Jewish subversion!. Ultimately, the Nazis sought to create a largely homogeneous and autarkic ethnic state, absorbing the ideas of Pan-Germanism!.

Although im a staunch supporter of Israel ,their recent actions in Gaza disgusted me !.!.!. killing a terrorist is one thing, but killing an entire family with the terrorist is morally wrong

And so now i have to agree with your comment !.!.!.!. zionism like nazism is an attempt to create a state consisting of one population group ,,, at the expense of othersWww@QuestionHome@Com

I wish you hadn't asked that, because my answer is yes!.
I had a difficult childhood!. My father called me a communist and for years my mother thought I was anti-semitic, because I supported the Palestinians!. She was fairly well educated and should have known better!. Arabs are also Semites!.
Not long before she died, my mother was reading the daily paper!. Some conflict between Israel and Palestine and she said, 'I think you might be right!.'
Zionism is extreme Nationalism which, by definition is fascist/national socialist!.
Religion is one thing, nationality should be separate!. There are British Christians, Muslims, Hindus, Jews etc!., but all who hold British passports and are resident in the UK are British citizens!.!.
Zionism tries to make all Jews Israelis!. Although Zionists were taken aback when black and dark-skinned Jews decided to settle in Israel!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

yes they are similar as they both promote the interests of their ethnicity's nazism promoting german purity and zionism promoting the jewish Israeli state!. However this is were similarities end with nazism promoting the idea of german aryan superiority forgetting the fact that todays real aryans are actually persians or modern day Iran!. Zionism on the other hand may portray jews as being Gods chosen people as it is written in the bibles old testament!. But God also punished the jews or Israelites by disowning them and according to the bible scattering them to the four corners of the earth!. Any christians who read the bible out there should know that jesus christ said any one who converted and follows his ways was a chosen one of God!. By the way i personally don't condone isreals excuse of zionism to expand its territory into that of palestines, this is because unfortunately people dont live exactly were their race originated from such as white people dominating the australia, despite it originally belonging to the aboriginals!. the same goes to north america with whites, blacks and latinos dominating a land that used to belong to Native americans!. And by the western world supporting isreal, zionism and the taking of palestinian lands is hippocracy as they are not supporting native americans reclaiming their lands or aboriginals reclaiming australia or even black africans reclaiming south africaWww@QuestionHome@Com

there are similarities!. But the similarities in purpose tend to lend to thinking there must be a similarity in the means and method to fulfill that purpose which is where some opposition to the suggestion might come from!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

didnt read but this may help
http://bocktherobber!.com/2008/01/zionism!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Neither had a problem with genocideWww@QuestionHome@Com

no!.Www@QuestionHome@Com