Question Home

Position:Home>History> Dictators who were Good?


Question: Dictators who were Good!?
In my social studies, I've been given an assignment to write an essay about "Democracy Vs!. Dictatorship" where I give my opinion, on which side I believe is better!.

Well, I decided to side with the dictators, just simply because I find it more interesting and challenging!.

And so, I asked my teacher if there were such things as "Good Dictators", she said there were, and she called them as "Philosopher King" from Plato's philosophy as she believed that they had the ability to understand or already possessed, Good!.

She told me that I should look up these people that she believes to be considered as "Philosopher Kings"

Napoleon Bonaparte
Catherine II of Russia
Marcus Aurelius

Of these people, what was one or two good things they've done that has been very beneficial for their country, and perhaps something bad thing they've done or some kind of disadvantage characteristic they had!.

And if you like to add on a good dictator that you believed to be good, please tell me :)

Thank you :)




P!.S!.

Please, I don't like bias opinions about these dictators, I just like some facts please, since, people like to justify whether or not they're actually evil!.

Especially Napoleon Bonaparte, I can only vaguely remember of the things he's done, but know that he's done both good and bad for his country!.

And I find it, very bias for us (and society) to judge such people for their negative actions, since, society is written by the winners of history!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
A few good dictators

- Augustus Caesar
- Emperor Tai Zu
- Mao Ze Dong
- Kaiser William II

You can search them on google for roe inf oif you want!.!.!. But I'll answer your original questions!.

Napoleon = 1- He helped stabilise teh French society, which was in chaos and turmoil
2 - he helped the French win many battles and built a French empire!. When they were weak before (they owed a large amonut of mnoey due to the last French Sun King Louis XVI)
3 - He protected France from attackers!.
4 - He made reforms on the police and the judges (the law)!.
5 - He made new administration and reformed the economy such as taxes and France's finances!.
6 - He boosted and icnreased education in France!.

Catherine II of Russia = I don't know anythnig about her except she was a Tzaress, her other name is Ctaherine the Great, and I can't be bothered researching people I don't know, so I will skip this one!.

Marcus Aurelius = 1 - I know he is a Philosopher
2 - He was one of the Five Good Emperors and was actually a good emperor unlike Nero
3 - He was wise and had a good education so!.!.!.
4 - Basiclly he helped the Romans in wars and consolidated the Roman Empire's power
5 - He made reforms whci hebenefited hte general populace!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

My opinion!? Anwar Sadat, Muustafa Kamal Pasha/Ataturk!. But if you're interested to see what millionheads thinks - go to www!.millionheads!.com and ask your question there to tap the collective wisdom of crowds!. You'll get a pie-chart back giving you a definitive answer, rather than a bunch of opinions!. Good luck!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I don't quite understand the assignment you have!. Are you supposed to write about supposedly good dictators or write about who other people say were good dictators!? If you're looking for information on Napoleon there is no shortage of it online!.Www@QuestionHome@Com