Question Home

Position:Home>History> HITLER? pure evil? mental problems? true beleive he was doing the right thing? a


Question: HITLER!? pure evil!? mental problems!? true beleive he was doing the right thing!? a genius!?
whats your opion!?

I find it hard to beleive in evil in a person i tend to think its based on there environment growing up, a mental condition or a emotional disorder but hitler just seems really evil!.

What are your opions!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
First, there were other humans who did cruel things!. Leaders and ordinary man (For example Stalin, Jack the Ripper)!. I think all people got good and bad sides!. But that is not your question!. If you want do you know more about humans violence and killings, i suggest you to read "The Third Chimpanzee" by Jared Diamond!. I think Hitler wasn`t pure evil, but a good example how worse a human beeing can be!. Well, depends on the definiton of mental problems, but i think yes!. Yes, true believes what he was doing the right thing!. Genius!? I don`t know, but many Nazis which were defendanted in Nuremberg showed a higher-than-average IQ!. Not all defendanted, but many!. Remember, Goebbels had his Phd!. Although it seems many Nazis were convinced what they did was right, many knew it was a crime (Holocaust)!. But back to Hitler!. I answered to a smiliar question, thats why i copy just my writings: I AGREE WITH YOU (but i dont think that`s true, but i agree hitler may believe it), but that wasnt the one and only reason!. It was a mix of diffrent reason for him!. The one you mentioned and the other reason was, the Nazis with Hitler thought the jews were responsible for germanys lose in wwI!. Another reason could be bad experience with Jews!. Prejudices against jews and radical theories in magazines and books of that time possibly brought him to a Jew-Hater and racist!. Writing like those of J?rg Lanz von Liebenfels, Georg von Sch?nerer and Kar Lueger!. Don`t forget that in all of europe of that time were strong antisemite behaviour!. Example Dreyfuss http://en!.wikipedia!.org/wiki/Dreyfus_aff!.!.!. Plus the centuries old antisemitism of the christian church; roman-catholic like protestants!. (The Nazis allowed everything which was against jews or the church, true or not true!. Like a book of Martin Luther against the jews or a book called "Der Pfaffenspiegel" against the christian church, mainly against the roman-cahtolic!. Both books were written before Hitlers birth!.) [Popular Antismeits during Hitlers Lifetime were famous Henry Ford and Richard Wagner] I also believe he didn`t care about Jews, so he didn`t give a **** if jews live or not!. A plan was to move all jews to madagascar!. But all solutions to move out jews alive failed or were unrealistic, so he or they (nazi government) decided for the "final solution for the jew problem"!. Lot of stuff got written about Hitler!. It`s said Hitlers Mother was a strong roman-chatolic!. It is known that Hitler wanted to be a professional painter at the academie of arts in vienna, but were refused like dozens others with him by a jew!. He tried it later but was refused again!. Such things and stories told to him by others who got to do with jews, may affirmed his racist believes!. Like "the majority of jews generally is bad" Thats toally dumb to think so!. Just you know some bad people doesnt mean all people are bad, but hitler was a human beeing and human beeing are diffrent and act different!. Some postive experience are the jewish doc of his mother Eduard Bloch!. A theory is hitler got antisemite because the doc couldn`t save his mother, but thats very questionable!. Eduard Bloch was the only jew who got protected by the Gestapo in Linz and who could immgrate to the USA - orderd personally by Hitler!. Other positive experience is his award!. He got awarded because a jewish officer thought so!. Or after he got refused in vienna, he painted pictures and selled it via a hungrian jew!. Hitler didn`t want to get a normal job, he titled them as "breadjobs"!. He wanted to be a painter!. also, he didn`t like to be aroung humans!. Thats why he selld his painiting over a jew and not himself!. He was also a "stranger" for his comerades in ww1 who prefer to be alone!. It said he was a correct soldier, but was disliked by some comerades for beeing 100% loyal to their officers!. Doing everything without question, but doing as orderd!. Hitler was also a bit esoteric!. It seems Himmler was much more!. By the way it is proven wrong, hitler was half jew or had jewish ancestors!. Personaly in my opinion it is a mix of hitlers character, personality, the time he lived in, circumstances and the racist theories he readed and believed!. Maybe thats why he forced his "aryan ideal" of a blonde strong blue german, altough he wasn`t blond himself!. He thought the jews want to destroy the germanic race and claimed many problems in the world caused by the "international finance jews" However, fact is; he wrote himself, he first got interests in politics after the ww1!. I am sure if the academy of arts in vienna, had accept him, the world would had never known or heared of Adolf Hitler, maybe as a painter, but nerver as a politican or dictator of germany!. But it wasn`t!. The rest is known history!.

Pics:
Hitler 1 year old and later
http://www!.welt!.de/multimedia/archive/00!.!.!.

12 years old
http://upload!.wikimedia!.org/wikipedia/co!.!.!.

1914, short before the outbreak of ww1
http://z!.about!.com/d/history1900s/1/0/U/!.!.!.

As a soldier
http://www!.idefix!.headroom!.at/images/Pro!.!.!.

Training-Pics
http://www2!.dsu!.nodak!.edu/users/dmeier/H!.!.!.

Birthplace 1889!. He saw 3 differnet houses from 1889 to 1907!.
http://www!.geschichteinchronologie!.ch/eu!.!.!.

If you want to know why he got refused, look at some paintings of him!. In my opinion just average, nothing special!.
http://blog!.uncovering!.org/en/archives/2!.!.!.

P!.S!. Sorry for my many spelling mistakes!

It seems he didn`t liked his father much!. He forced him to do a job as a public servant, which Hitler strongly disliked!. He wanted to became a painter!. His father hitted him, which was a normal thing that time!. His father died when hitler was 13 of a hearattack in a bar in the morning time!. His mother died when he was 17!. Possibly the most loved woman his life was his mother!. He had other relatives!.
Hitler was hurt to his eyes, which caused some day blindness in ww1!. He became the mainleader and mainfigure and mainspeaker of the NSDAP and later number one nazi-germany!. He liked animals and loved dogs (but it is not uncommon for psychopaths to be nice to animals and cruel to people) and women with big ****!. But his Eva got small ones!. After the Stalingrad defeat, he did only rare public speeches!. At the end of war he had parcinson and looked older then he was!.

Example a scene from one of his speeches, for what he is infamous for!.
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=FDbmB_QKP!.!.!.

If you look carefully then you noticed, he hid his left hand, because thats the one with parcinson!
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=X8xPsgdTc!.!.!.

I reached the max numbers of allowed links!. Go to google pictures and search for "Hitler animal"!. At page 2 and 3 you see Hitler wiht his dog Muck and on page 1 his new dog Blondi!. The people among hitler decided to give him a new dog after Muck died, because Hitler was comfartble with a dog!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

~Time Magazine named him Man of the Year, 1938, for a reason!. You might want to do some fact checking to learn who he really was!.

True, his racial policy left something to be desired!. However, as late as May, 1940, Hitler and Himmler agreed that mass executions of the "socially undesirables' and 'racially impure' was a Bolshevik idea and not the German way of doing things!. The British had already floated a plan to create a Jewish homeland on Madagascar and to "encourage" the Jews of Great Britain and Europe to move there!. The British had also proposed by the Balfour Declaration in 1917 to create a Jewish homeland in their Mandate of Palestine but world resistance put the plans on hold for a few decades!. The Nazis intended to follow a modified version of the British plan, but the war prevented implementation of it!. No one particularly wanted Jews within their borders!. (See the Spanish Inquisition, the Jewish Pale, the Evian Conference, the SS St!. Louis and scores of other illustrations of the point!.) Of course, Jews only represent about half of those who died in the Extermination Camps and less than 1/4 of those who died in the Concentration Camps and a large percentage of the Jews in each type camp would have been sent there even if they had not been Jewish!. Had the Red Army not repelled Operation Barbarossa and won the war, another 10 to 30 million would have been targeted for extinction, most of them Slavs!.

The Nazis did with their undesirables much the same as the US did with Native Americans!. First, slaughter them in the field, them confine them to camps, then kill them off!. The US wiped out the buffalo to kill the Indians and to make sure they couldn't make a comeback!. They Nazis stole Jewish wealth!. Who did worse!? Which was less moral or humane, Nazi Concentration Camps or US slavery!. Yeah, slavery ended in 1865, but what was the status of African Americans in the '40s and how did that compare to the Jews or gypsies in Germany!? The Nazis were neither the first nor the last to operate a state sponsored genocide campaign!. Look a Darfur today!. Look at the Armenians, if you can find any!. Look at the Serbs and the Khmer Rouge!. Unfortunately, examples are legion throughout history, ancient as well as contemporary!.

By the way, the Death Camps weren't Hitler's idea!. Credit that one to Goehring, Himmler and Heydrich!. Hitler approved them to be sure, but only after the program was up and running!. The Death Camps were only in operation from December 1941 until Spring 1943!. Himmler himself ordered operations to cease and the camps to be partially dismantled!. Auschwitz II (Birkenwald) stayed open for another year or so!. Birkenwald's victims were split fairly evenly between Jews and non-Jews!. When Jan Karski took his first hand accounts and photographs out of the Warsaw Ghetto and Belzek to London and Washington in the Spring of '42, no one was unduly upset!.

Hitler did a lot of good for Germany!. The treaty of Versailles spawned the Nazis and was the largest contributing cause of the Great Depression!. The Nazis pulled Germany out of the Depression!. Science, especially in rocketry and medicine, leaped ahead under the Nazis!. Hitler rebuilt the German infra-structure and made Germany and industrial and economic power with few rivals!. Hitler could not have, and did not, accomplish all he did on his own!. Millions, German and non-German alike, agreed with much of what he did and supported him in doing it!. He racial ideas were neither original with him nor exclusive to him or his party or his nation!.

His downside clearly outweighs the good he did!. Calling him evil incarnate or insane, though, is not only stupid, it is dangerous!. Excusing him on those grounds simply makes it easier for charismatic, chauvinistic megalomaniacs like him to do it again!.

Listen to the people saying we should nuke Iraq and Afghanistan back to the Stone Age (not realizing, I am certain, that the US put the Baath Party and Saddam Hussein in Power in the first place, or trained, financed and armed the Taliban, the Afghan warlords and Osama bin Laden (all of which is confirmed by US government documents, if one only takes the trouble to look!.) See how easy it is to get it started!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

what is evil but an opinion of another person's actions!. In essence there is no good and evil, light and darkness, holy and unholy ect because they are simply just opinions of a person!. Hitler and his supporters did what they did because to them it seemed the right thing to do!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Look some people grow up and believe things that their parents have taught them and raised them!. Hitler I am sure his parents had something to do with who he became!. There is no evil really but I mean he was sick!. It's obvious he was sick and when u raise a child into ur beliefs then they take it on too!.
watch this family!. the mom and dad have brain washed their children and have made them totally rascist!. who do u have to blame now!?
the parents for forcing their beliefs on their children and not giving them the oppurtunity to believe what they want to believe when grown up!.

http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=nZccnGspo!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

If his plans would have been succesfull he would probably be concidered one of the great minds of our time, saviour of modern society!.

In History the good guys always win, as they get to write the historybooks!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Believe it or not, Hitler came to power to get rid of communism which was rampant in Germany, he did accomplish that, but then went over the hill!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I heard that he was on an all you can eat buffet of prescription medications for his mental illnesses, but who knows!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

He was a genius of his kind!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm the guy who does his job!. You must be the other guy!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

He had severe mental problems and a very inauspicious birth date!.Www@QuestionHome@Com