Question Home

Position:Home>Arts & Humanities> What is the difference between what is "right" and what is "fair&


Question:

What is the difference between what is "right" and what is "fair"?

Pretty straight forward folks. From a philosophical/logical perspective, what do you see as the difference (if any) between an action/event that is right and an action/event that is fair?


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Here is my event that I will use to attempt to make a distinction. On "The Titanic" (The movie) there is a scene where Kate is lying on top of some debris and Jack is in the water trying to stay afloat. In this scene what is 'fair' is that both of them share the debris to both stay partially afloat. What is 'fair' is that they either both live or both die. What is 'fair' is that they offer this chance to others around them.
In all these 'fair' examples both would die.
What is 'right' is that one is given a greater chance than the other. Rose is given the whole piece of debris so she is out of the water. The debris is taken away from the main crowd so that Jack and Rose can use the debris to try and survive, ect.

Basically it seems that "fairness" reflects equality. Equal distribution and equal ends.
"Right" reflects a more subjective view of the event. This also represents views on "goodness" and utilitarian arguments like "happiness", ect. Is it ??fair?? that one person lived? No. Would it be ??fair?? if both died? Yes. Would it be ??right?? that both died? No. Would it be ??right?? that one lived? Yes.