Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Why do twilight fan girls go insane when u tell them twilight is not a good book


Question: Why do twilight fan girls go insane when u tell them twilight is not a good book/movie!?
Ok so theres some girls at my school that are twilight freaks!. So at lunch there were no seats left so i had to sit at the girls table!. ( yeah 1 boy 12 girls 1 table -_-) Well as i was eating I noticed them talking about twilight!. Edward this Edward that I felt as if i was gonna throw up the food I just ate!. then i whisperd "Stupid book!." under my breath!. the table went silent!. I looked up to see all the girl glaring at me like they were gonna kill me with their sporks!. Then, oh God here it comes, they all start preaching me from their holy book of twilight "How dare you not like twilight!"*answer its a crappy book -_-"* You just jelouse of Edward *answer: no im pretty sure a 300 year old sparkliing vampire is the last thing I want to be* so now im asking u all WHAT IS WITH THESE TWITARDS!? and yes b4 u say anything i have in fact read most of the book then i feel asleep due to boredom!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Pooja and Twilight is my life are idiots!. Ignore them!. They're immature and they don't have the mental capacity to get that there are such things as freedom of speech and a right to your own opinion!. Seriously people, you can't hate a book unless you've read it first! You people just don't want others having legitimate reasons for hating the books because you're too stupid to actually be able to counter them! Seriously, if you feel like you've been insulted when someone says anything negative about a book, you need to rethink you're life and stop being so darn sensitive! Maybe they should get lives outside of the stupid books!. If someone insulted something I liked, I wouldn't go around calling them jealous!. That's just so stupid!. It's called a DIFFERING OPINION!Www@QuestionHome@Com

-giggles- "Twitards" nice!. And he's not 300! He's 109!.!.!.

The amazing Edward Cullen inspires a ferociousness in fangirls that is unparallelled in another other fandom, I'm pretty sure!. Tread lightly around them, and I'm sure you have no reason to fear!.

I wish you luck navigating the rough Twilight waters
-MaggieWww@QuestionHome@Com

I guess it's because you're insulting something that they love and in a way they feel you're insulting them!.
And you sort of are!. You did call them Twitards!.
And I think it would be pretty cool to sparkle!.
Give it some time and the Twilight-mania will fade out!. It's not that great a movie/book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yeah, I'm a twilight fan, but i'm not like a obsessed fan!. Some people take things too far, i can just imagine they were all like sharpening knives under the table!. As if you say that though, didn't you know they would kill you!? Twitards are a vengeful species, insult their Edward (or Jacob if hats what their into!.!. but twitards are generally Edward obsessed) and prepare to die! lolWww@QuestionHome@Com

hahahaha same happened to me!. my friend loves thee books sooooo much!. i decided to go wit her to see the movie(stupid) wasted my time && money!. i told her i hated thee movie & never read thee books!. she ignored me tho!. i think its just a stupid fan phase!. remind ur "TWITARDS" that they used ta say thee same about barney and all!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Simply put you're insulting something they are passionate about!. You'd be the same way if they insulted something you love!.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion!. If they like Twilight, good for them!. If you don't, good for you!.

Its a free country!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because you're basically telling them that something they love and cherish is no good!. How would you like it if someone told you YOUR favorite book sucked!? Would you like that!? No!. You wouldn't!.

THAT'S why!.

EDIT: Props to the thumb-downers for displaying their hatred of free opinion and approval of insulting others!.

And a little response to Anti Twi-Hats THOROUGHLY hypocritcal post!. You're right!. People DO have a right to their own opinion!. And that's exactly why Twi-Hards have the right to be twi-hard!. Everything you've said supports THEM!.

People who attack Twi-Hards ARE NOT "stating their opinion!." No, they're only being jerks for trying to tear others down!. Most people who insult Twi-Hards don't even dislike the book, they just dislike so-called "conformity"!. About that!. Non-conformists have been deemed ridiculous for their totally backwards views for quite some time now!. It is not possible to be a non-conformist!. Here's some light shed - it actually ISN'T cool to hate something because it's popular!. On the contrary, it's downright idiotic!.

Bottom line: Twi-Hards are enjoying life!. Twi-Haters need to get one!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because apparently, Edward Cullen is a GOD!.

Pshaw!. It's stupid!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

as the girls hav said u r jelous(dont deny it)!.!.!.!.!.and if u hated it dat much u would hav stopped at da 1st book!.!.!.!.bottomline:u do like twilight but cant stand the girls talking abt edward wen u r at da table!.!.!.!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

OH MY EDWARD! HOW DARE YOU NOT LIKE TWILIGHT!!! YOU HEATHEN! YOU'RE JUST JEALOUS THAT YOU'LL NEVER HAVE TRUE LOVE LIKE EDWARD AND BELLA!!!

MAY THE POWER OF EDWARD COMPEL YOU!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

The first time I read twilight i was like that specially my guy friend who said he coulnd't stand us screaming omg edward(thought I never did, you can't prove anything! lol!)I eventually calm down and being stupid for doing that I mean yeah who wants to be a sparkly vampire!? at least if you're gonna be one you could be a one that is a lot cooler than that!. Well good luck

p!.s!. I don't hate twilight excep Breaking Dawn, and Stephenie Meyer but I do hate how much attention they give it to the book hello!?! get over it! you're just making smeyer right you twilighters! again don't hate it just hate the attention they give it, too much!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

lol, at my school is the same!.!. at lunch there's ALWAYS people re-reading the books or talking about them!.
I myself loved the book/s and movie!.
But i think girl twilight fans get so crazy it is because they wish that they could live a life with romance but there be a twist!.!. like falling in love with a vampire!.
But the way the book was writen it really makes <some> people feel like they KNOW the characters and the feelings the character's feel!.
Twilight becomes part of their lifes (which is sad because it is only a book!.!. :C) and they wish that they could have their own "Bella Edward" thing!.

It just makes Fanpires/Twitards!.!. i dunno umm!.!. to want other people to feel the same way they do so that other people can love the novels / movie!.

Its hard to explain!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

This type of fandom is related to identity, and the teen years are very much about finding identity!. It provides a sense of meaning and belonging in a world where they may feel insecure!. It affects everyone to some degree!.

We all know someone, even an adult, who is a little (or a lot) "nuts" about a sports team or player, actor, author, series, or character!. Their sense of identity is entangled with the object of their fandom and to criticize the object they identify with is to criticize who they feel they are!.

Criticize a baseball team in the wrong bar and you're likely to get the pulp beat out of you by the fans who frequent that location (you've insulted who they are)!. Criticize twilight and the girls will react the same way!. Just hope that as the girls mature, they will find their identities and we won't have twilight bars and girls with knives at every table!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's alright to politely disagree with someone, but not to attack the person!. They're not -wrong- for liking something you dislike!. Disagree with them all you like, but never resort to insulting!. It just makes you look bad!.

But I agree, they overreacted!. If it was over something religious like the Bible, I'd understand, but this is just a YA novel!. Sold as FICTION!.

Sephiroth: You said not to insult people and then you insult Twilight haters!. Nice one!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

cuz a lot people love fantasy more than reality most of the time!.!.!.i mean c'mon!.!.!.didn't u not go through some phase where u loved something and no one else could understand that!.!.!.a lot twilight fans love the escape twilight provides them with!.!.!.its kinda like leaving the everyday norm and diving into a world full of bliss and the unexpected!.!.!.and to be honest w/ ya!.!.!.when u tell a twilight fan the book/ movie is not good, u r kinda of insulting them!.!.!.i mean how would u like it if someone walked up to ya and told you that something u love is just horribly awful!.!.!.how would u respond!?!.!.!.isn't that person doing the same thing that u did to the girls @ lunch!?!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com