Position:Home>Books & Authors> Did you like Breaking Dawn? (Twilight series)?
Question: Did you like Breaking Dawn!? (Twilight series)!?
To all, this is merely a response to a question, the real question comes later on!.!.!. Read below!.!.!.!.
See how Memorable - author of what is written below between the speech marks- says 'Geniva u wanted Jacob to imprint with his older sister!.!.!.!. I am just here to say you silly silly goose, jacob and leah are NOT siblings!!!!
''I think it's the weirdestshit I have ever read in my entire life!.
It's like the author is living in her own fantasy world!. Edward's character is way too over protective!. Bella is whiny, selfish, and making stupid decisions!. I haven't liked her character ever since she demanded that Edward stay with her when the reason the younger vampires are coming in the first place is because of her!. I think it's stupid how in Eclipse, she won't go see Jacob because of Edward!. Edward is not her father so why is he acting like it!. "Can I go see Jake!?!.!.!.!.please!?!?!?" Are you serious, Bella!? You're 18 years old you don't need permission like a 14 year old and you don't need to be 'kidnapped' every time Edward leaves Forks!. That's way overdoing it!.
Agree or disagree!?
Why or why not!?
Breaking Dawn is just weird!. The whole pregnancy thing ruined the whole book!. Bella gets pregnant because she can't control her hormones and forces Edward to have sex with her!. The baby gives her bruises and is trying to eat her organs!. She's stupid and wants to give birth to the monster any way, hoping that if she dies, Edward will turn her into a vampire and save her (why is she being such an idiot)!. Then Jacob has love at first sight with Bella's new born baby which is just weird!. Jacob is a 7 ft tall hormonal teenage boy and he just had love at first sight with an infant!. The whole imprinting thing is a weird idea and Stephanie Meyer went way too far with it and made it freaky!. It would have been better if Jake and his friend weren't imprinting with children like perverts/pedophiles!. that's disgusting!. I couldn't even be into it anymore because it's nasty to say that they're having love at first sight with babies and they just couldn't help it!. it was beyong their control!. Stephanie Meyer has issues!.
Oh and then Bella and Edward live happily ever after in a cottage!.!.!.wtf!.
Breaking Dawn sucked!. The whole story was weird!.
Did you like it!?
Why or why not!?
* 17 hours ago
* - 1 day left for voting
Additional Details
17 hours ago
Geniva- that's disgusting!. You wanted Jacob to imprint with his older sister!?
17 hours ago
Stephanie Meyer needs to be mentally evaluated!.''
My question: Does anyone else think Stephanie Myer needs to have her head examined!? Pedophilia, abusive relationships, necrophilia!? Are these things we should be allowing teenagers to read and to IDOLISE!?Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Oh yeah, I thought the Cullens had to move away coz they'd been in Forks too long!?!?
there's been much worse stuff written (how do I know!? i've read some twisted books)!. VC Andrews books, they're pretty wrong when you get down to it!. However, considering her audience was mostly adolencent girls who have little experience with relationships (let alone the scienfic naturae of giving birth), she's probably give more than a few several nightmares!.
I think SM wante deverything to end nicely!. However, given the world she created, her nice ending was extremely unrealistic:
!.!.!.we were told all along that newborn vampires were really dangerous to humans, go crazy etc!. Bella does none of this!.
!.!.!.we were also told that it takes a lot of time for newborns to recover!. bella snapped out of it in like 2 or 3 days
!.!.!.what does Leah do when her clothes are ripped off/then she turns back to a human again!?!? just wrong
!.!.!.Bella loves Edward so much, why wouldn't see want a HUGE wedding!?
and I could go on and on!.
If I was a parent I would let my kids read the first 3 books but not Breaking Dawn!. And when I'm a teacher I'm gonna make it perfectly clear I don't think it is quality reading!.
yes: the series IS NOT QUALITY READING!. It's not well written, it's a lot of rambling about some whiny girl who is in love with a pompous arrogant idiot (aka Edward)!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I liked it!. I thought it was a cute story and it's a book about vampires and werewolves of course it's going to be weird!. I do agree with Bella being really whiny and stuff but I still like the book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I thought it was ok but some of it was pretty wierd!. Like i agree w/ the imprinting thing!. I thought the ending sucked!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
No!. That's just the kind of genre that she likes to write!. If you don't like it, then go find something you'll enjoy!. I'm tired of people talking about her !. !. she did nothing to you!. Why can't we just all get along!? LOL :)Www@QuestionHome@Com
we teenagers should totally be allowed to idolize edward cullen!. i was a little disturbed by the physical abuse and labor (almost puked-yay), but really in context it's not as bad as when you just throw it out there, especially the abuse!. i thought the detail of the labor was kind of unnecessary-of all places to add extra detail!.!.!.
first third- good!. i liked it!. who doesn't love the romance with edward!? i don't know about you, but in my head the picture of bella looks an awful lot like me!.!.!.
2nd third- okay!. labor is gross, we all agree!. really gross!. ew!. and she drank human blood!. ew!. but jacob is cool, even if he's not my favorite; at least we didn't have to see vampire pregnancy through bella's eyes!. imprinting is ridiculously weird and creepy though!.
3rd third- !.!.!.ehh!. pretty bad!. vampire bella is even more unrelatable than she was before!. and renesmee took up all the edward time except the 10-hour sex, which i was pretty pissed about!. it took me a while to figure out who the hell irina was, and after all the depressing exciting stuff i read through there was never even i fight!! what the frick!!?!!? the whole cheery abrupt happy go lucky ending pissed me off!. i didn't really make me care at all!.!.!.i'm sorry to offend anyone, but in order to make that ending worthwhile there needed to be a fight and a cullen had to die!. yes i said it!. it's the truth; i would have cried and it's good to move the reader!.
i enjoyed the first three, but i wasn't a big fan of the fourth!. the last third of it kind of ruined it for me!. sorry!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
do i like breaking dawn!.!.!.well here is my answer to that question:
as much as i love renesme, i would take her out Breaking Dawn!.!.!.i would of like to see bella as an action-packed vampire with no intention of settling down quite yet!.!.!.twilight, new moon, and eclipse were written to build up the suspense of bella's vampire transformation!.!.!.and then when breaking dawn came around, i was like "who-oa what happened!"!.!.!."what happen to the blood thirsty vampire i was expecting"!.!.!.i mean c'mon, bella preggers!?!!.!.!.it was a huge let down after reading the 3 amazing books leading up to the final installment!.!.!.i mean don't get me wrong, i love all the books so much, especially twilight and eclipse, but it almost seems as if Stephanie rushed the last book into 700 pages!.!.!.it would have been nice to spread things out a little more!.!.!.it was 2 dense for my liking!.!.!.
Does anyone else think SM needs to have her head examined!?!.!.!.well here is my answer to that:
No, i think she just has an overactive imagination!.!.!.definitely not crazy!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
Yeah it was a little weird, but come on, I picked up a book on vampires!. How traditional did I think the story would be!.
People can't put the lable "weird," on it because it is completely made up!. Isn't that the point of being a Fantasy writer!. So you can come up with the stupidest stuff, yet still get it published!. lol
Don't get me wrong, the book went way to far, and was actually "awkward" to read, but whatever!. Let Stephanie live out her twisted fantasy's through her books, and I'll continue to read em and when finished, I will surely ask myself!.!.!.!."wtf was that!?"Www@QuestionHome@Com
Julia made a good point!. It is a vampire book, so how realistic is it going to get!? And again, like she said, it's a fantasy book!. Vampires, werewolves, imprinting, etc!.!.!.fantasy!. If you don't like it, don't read it!. And no, she does not need to be mentally evaluated (though I am sure that person was joking)!. If you think this book is strange, you haven't read many books!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
i hated it and loved it at the same time!. i hated the route she went with it but i loved how everything ended (edward and bella together, bella a vampire, jacob happy, etc) but i was just really dissapointed with stephanie meyers!. i feel like she took the eay way out!. there was soooo much build up but NOTHING happened!.in the end,!. when i was reading it it made me want to kill bella if the baby wasnt gonna cuz shes just such an annoying, whiny little baby!. she got EVERYTHING and did nothing but put people thru hell!.
that book combined with the disastrous movie left me hating it!. stephanie tried to do wayyy too much and shouldve left it with twilight!. it was the only good book in the seriesWww@QuestionHome@Com