Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Is the Twilight books better thn the Harry potter ones ?


Question: Is the Twilight books better thn the Harry potter ones !?
Personally i'v only read two twilight books and taken a look off the Harry potter ones!. So this qestion goes out to all the people who have read them ; which one is better !? & why !?

okay thankyou !Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
well, its different for everybody!

it depends on what YOU like, and what you want to read!
we all have our own opinions, one book may be more popular than another ( a perfect example- harry potter as opposed to the sisters grimm) but it doesn't mean that verybody likes the bestseller more than the humble (well not really!.!.!.sisters grimm is hugely big) book!

but if you ask me (and yea, i know i sound like a hypocrite if you read my above paragraph) harry potter RULES!!! ive read both series and HP has a way more interesting and imaginative plot!.

but then, im only twelve and cant stand romance novels (ergh!.!.!.jane eyre!.!.the hardest and soppiest novel on earth) so make your own choices!Www@QuestionHome@Com

First of all, the girl that said Twilight has more detail and all of that hasn't read Harry Potter, or she would not have said that!.

I've read both series and like them!. Personally, I like Harry Potter better!.

Why!?

Harry Potter characters are amazingly developed!. It's like they are real people!.

The story has a very exciting plot!.

The story isn't cliche at all!. I knew extactly what was going to happen in Twilight before the series ended!. She make it very obvious!. Harry Potter on the other hand has you guess all the way!. Usually, the answer is even better than you imagined!

The writing is much better!. There are no cheesy lines, typos, and repetitiveness!.


You will enjoy both, but the Harry Potter books stands in a category all to itself!. Possibly, Lord of the Rings ranks with it!. It was an amazing series also!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Oh boy- you're aiming to spark a huge debate!.

Personally, I prefer Harry Potter!. While I found Twilight entertaining, and a fun book to fangirl over (I did attend the midnight release for Breaking Dawn), there is no place for discussion or an in depth analysis of characters with the books!.

The Harry Potter series presents a much more engaging, interesting, complicated one- you have characters with true personalities, rather than the ideologies of teenagers!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Harry Potter!. Don't listen to all those Twilight fan girls!. They totally over-hyped it!. I actually used to like Twilight!. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to be rude!. There are actually some Very intelligent people out there who like Twilight!. Just not a lot!.

Harry Potter just has a more complex plot and better developed characters!. I mean in Twilight, it's all about Bella and Edward's romance!. In Harry Potter, there is so much more going on!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

They're both great book series, and I don't see why people feel the need to constantly compare them!. I own and love all of the Harry Potter books (and even had to stand in a two hour line in Paris for the release of the last one), but I also greatly enjoyed the Twilight series!. JK Rowling is a better writer, but Stephenie Meyer creates truly dynamic characters and stories!. The two series are both worth reading, so have fun with them both!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

HP, definitely!. JKR has developed a whole world, whereas Twilight takes place in a little town!. Twilight is basically "He's a hot vampire", but in HP there are loads of morals and themes!.

Not to mention that all the HP books have sold 400 million copies and the Twilight books only around 10-20 million!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i love both the series deff!.

but honey, harry potter is better! the plo is SICK! i still dont know Rowling thought of such a complex plot =]

twilight is great, but its just a romantic apeal!. harry potter has that and more =] but thats my opinion

edit: did that girl just say that twilight had more detail than harry potter!?! is she partially blind!?! the longest twilight book is what!? 4-500 pages!? harry potter: 780 pages!? right!? WOW how could she even think that was true =DWww@QuestionHome@Com

harry potter by far!!!
i liked twilight but its like vomit compared to harry potter!.
to katiekat- twilight does not have more detail than harry potter at all!! how can you even say that!? the whole book is basically saying how gorgeous edward is over and over again, at least HP as a plot!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well I love them both and i think that they are each amazing and that one isn't personally better than the other!. J!.K!. Rowlings writing is wonderful and she has done a great job with portraying each characters feelings!. While Stephanie Meyer came up with a beautiful story line that brought me in immediately!. so basically they are each good in there own ways!Www@QuestionHome@Com

i am SO happy you are reading books!.


your mom is happy, too!.

does it matter what people's opinion is about which is better!?

probably neither are particularly well written!.!.!. read some Christopher Moore if you want a well-written book, but its a start!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Hi there,

This is one of these questions that have been asked a large number of times already!. Please use the search box next time!.

And Harry Potter is better in every sense of the word!.

Cheers
SWww@QuestionHome@Com

Opinion question nothing is better nor worse!. Get that straight, understand what an opinion is and then you'll find out for yourselfWww@QuestionHome@Com

HARRY POTTER BABY!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I prefer Harry Potter!. All the way!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

TwilightWww@QuestionHome@Com

TWILIGHT it's so sweet and romantic!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

oh twilight is better! by far!!!!!!!! they have more deatail and are funny and just over all morre awsome!Www@QuestionHome@Com