Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Why do people think Nessie and Jacob are gross? ?


Question: Why do people think Nessie and Jacob are gross!? !?
I have read a few statements about Jacob and Renesmee (Nessie) in which they feel it is gross!. I, first of all, am a Jacob fan!. Many people felt that Jacob was controlling, but I say that Edward was more controlling!. I feel that Bella is better off with Edward, but I always did not feel that way!. Jacob was always too good for Bella, in my opinion!. As long as Jacob gets to be happy, I was happy witTwilightk!. What I would like to ask is why do some Twlilight fans fel that it is gross having Jacob imprint on Nessie!? He does not think of her in a sexual way, yet!. Don't forget that Edward is over century older than Bella, is that gross too!? also, Jacob even said that they only reason he felt that strong love for Bella was because she would one day have his object form imprinting (not in those words though)!. So he really was in love with Bella, he was drawn to her because of what his future held with her (the mother of his imprint)!. I know that last sentence was confusing :) What do you all think!? Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I don't think it's gross!. The whole imprinting thing has been explained throughoutt the books that imprinting cannot be controlled and the way that the werewolf (or shape-shifter) feels about the imprint changes through time and stuff!.
And I think it's perfectly alright for Jake to imprint with Renesmee, afterall, Bella had her happy ending, so why shouldn't her personal sun!? (:Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well what would have happened if Bella never got back together with Edward!? What if Bella got with Jacob instead!? Would he have imprinted on his own child!? Www@QuestionHome@Com

I at first thought it was gross but than i thought oh well hes happy and i wanted him happy but i wanted edward for bella!


1 day!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I don't think that it's gross, a little weird maybe, but not gross!. I mean, wait until Renesmee finds out that her mom made out with her boyfriend :) Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think it's cute!. I'm also Team Jacob, so when he imprinted, I was so happy!Www@QuestionHome@Com

it was a stupid ending to a stupid book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

caz shes so young!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Being a Jacob fan, I do think that it's gross that Jacob imprinted on Nessie!. He was absolutely in love with Bella and when she didn't need him for anything, she treated him like dirt!. Now he's stuck with her daughter!? ew!. also, how will Nessie feel when she finds out that her mother made out with her soon to be husband! I think Seth Clearwater would have been a better person to imprint on Nessie!. Jacob deserves better!. I don't think that he was in love with Bella in the first place just because she would eventually give birth to his soul mate!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

i feel it's gross because he's an unaging 16yr old whos fallen in uncontrolable love with a new born baby!. i may not think of her sexually yet, but he doesnt date anyone and he cant stand being 3 feet away from her!. a little overdone

yeah, edward becomes a little more obviously contorlling as the books go on!. but jacob was, too, trying to tear bella away from the "bloodsuckers" and he was just so negative about bellas love for edward!.!.!.it was just annoying!. jacob was probably the only human character in this book!. he had flaws, weaknesses, strengths!.!.!.all the good stuff to make a good character!. but no matter what, all the characters got butchered in breaking dawn!. including jacob!.

Yeah - when I first read edwards like three billion years old my first thought was "excuse me!?!" its a little weird, but it's not like hes some wrikly old man like hes supposed to be!.!.!.as long as bellas comfortable with it i suppose its okay!. all the twilight vampires are older than each other by countless years - carlisle and esme have a big gap!. its just how the vampire age system works!.Www@QuestionHome@Com