Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Twilight fans, how do you feel about Breaking Dawn now?


Question: Twilight fans, how do you feel about Breaking Dawn now!?
When I first read it, I was really really upset!. I didn't think it was very good!. But I let about a month go by and I read it again, and I found that it's not so bad after all!. I think it's definitely the worst in the series, but I was just shocked with what happened!. What do you think!? Did you like it or hate at first!? Do you still feel that way!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Prepare yourself, this is going to be long!. I live to talk about this stuff!.

I started reading Twilight pretty late compared to the rest of the world--about late March!. I finished all 3 by April, so that means I had over four months to wait for Breaking Dawn!. That time alone was enough to quite nearly drive me insane, so I can't imagine how people fared who had read Twilight when it first came out!. I think the main reason that so many people hated it was because of the intense build up!.!.!.I mean, millions and millions of people had been waiting for this book for soooo long!. In my opinion, the same thing is going to happen with the movie!. When something is so ridiculously anticipated like that, it is most likely not going to meet expectations!. I have to admit that Breaking Dawn definitely did have a different tone than the others!.!.!.but that's because so much changed!. Besides New Moon, Breaking Dawn was most dynamic of the novels!. We had Bella's familiar human voice, and then this crazy new vampire perspective!. Plus a huge section of Jacob POV! In addition, it was set apart from the other 3 because we had read and reread the others tons of times, and everything in BD was fresh!. I think that if it had been Eclipse instead of BD, a similar response would have come out about how it was a hugely different book from the others!. Well, of course!

My favorite book in the series remains New Moon!. Then I love Jacob's POV in breaking dawn!.!.!.that is the best part of the book!. Then Breaking Dawn, then Eclipse, probably, and finally Twilight!. That doesn't mean I didn't like Twilight--I loved it--i just have to priortize right now!.

At first, I was just shocked!. "WHAT!?!" That sort of thing!. I read a lot of Fanfiction, so the whole "Oh my god bella gets pregnant even though it's impossible-wow!" was the sort of thing that I disregared as ridiclous fan-workings!. haha!. who knew, huh!?

I didn't find it out for myself!.!.!.my friend send me a spoiler e-mail (she didn't mean to, it was an accident) about bella being "prego" when I was still at Esme's Island (swoon)!. But the jacob/renesmee shocker was completely geunine!. that impressed me!.

honestly, i sort of felt like jacob was the tiny piece of sanity holding us to the face of the planet throughout all of breaking dawn!. mutant vampire/human babies are cracking ribs, and edward's cutting open Bella's stomach with his teeth, and edward wants jacob to have sex with bella, and meanwhile, Jake is all cool and collected (at least he appears to be)!. I applaud him!.

I was satisfied with bd!. i feel sorry for people who hated it, not annoyed with them!. some of the things that bother me about it was the anti-climatic ending--even though i understand why SM had to do this, it's really annoying!. bella goes through that whole j!. jenks thing and then no one even fights!. i feel like stephenie, unlike j!.k!. rowling, hates to kill her characters!. not that i want everyone to die or anything, but sometimes you need to kill people!. anyway, i also thought the charlie thing was really ridiclous and random and pointless!. it was annoying because it just intensified the way bella didn't need to scrafrice anything when she became a vampire!. she didn't have to scrafice being a mother, she didn't have to scrafrice her freedom, her sanity, her father, jacob!.!.!.she got it all!. that kind of pisses me off!. i always saw twilight as realistic, oddly enough!. (that's why new moon is my fav!. it rocks my world when people--particularly edward-- screw up)!. and all the complusive sex in the beginning was kind of a turn off too!. although, i would have been dissapointed if there was none of that, too!.!.!.so i'm just being picky now!.

i guess i should shut up!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I thought it was!.!.!. Alright!. I think part of the reason I didn't like it was the fact that
1!. There wasn't a big fight scene, the confrontation with the Vulturi was quite dull!. And, more importantly,
2!. The series is over! =::(

I liked the first parts much better than the ending!.

I just hope she releases Midnight Sun soon! I haven't read the leak yet, because I don't want to have to stop reading 12 chapters in!

Seeya,
A!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I liked it because it's an adorable book and I love Renesmee!. Jacob and Edward became friends too, I thought that was amazing!. also, because they all get their happily ever after, including Jacob (he deserves it!)!.

I was upset that it's the LAST book, but I still liked it!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com

I absolutely loved it! I thought the end was a little crappy though!. I was so shocked when bella got pregnant! I mean how can a vampire and a human create a baby!? I loved the part right after edward changed bella into a vampire though!. I was like finally! I thought it was never ganna happen!! I still love this book!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Disappointed!.
I had hoped for this big resolution to Bella's problem with Jacob, The Wolfpack and the Volturi!. The mysterious pregnancy and super child really was no where on the radar for me and it seemed a sort of too pat answer!.

It was just a disappointment!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well actually Eclipse is my least favorite and this is second to least!. I think the reason some people were disappointed is because we all built it up so much as it was the last book!.!.!. for now!. Still, I really enjoyed it and thought Stephenie Meyer did a brilliant job of constructing a plot we would have NEVER expected!. I liked it a lot!. :)Www@QuestionHome@Com

i love breaking dawn!. it is my favorite besides twilight in the series!. i was shocked at first with what happened in the book but i loved it!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Actually, Breaking Dawn was my favorite in the series!. I liked the story and the plot twists!. I don't really have a least favorite!. They all have there high and low points!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i LOVE breaking dawn and think it is the best in the series and have always thought that!. in my opinion new moon was the worst of the series!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i loved it and still do!. Its a very fitting, happy ending and I'm kinda glad!. Apart from the Renesme and Jacob thing!. I wish she will keep writing about them though, there are so many questions still unanswered!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i expected much more out of it, and it wasn't my favourite in the series!. but i grew to love itWww@QuestionHome@Com

I loved it!.!.!.!. and no!.!.!. i think New moon is the worst (Bella and Edward arent together!!! :[) anyway i liked then then i loved it!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Its my least favorite!. I expected a better ending!. But it was okay!. It just seemed a little rushed!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I liked it but eclipse is still my fave in my opinion New Moon was the worst!Www@QuestionHome@Com