Position:Home>Books & Authors> Harry Potter deaths? why does she do all theses stuff?
Question: Harry Potter deaths!? why does she do all theses stuff!?
do you think that Rowling is abit heartless!?! She killed of every single character who even got close to being a parent to Harry!. Sirius, Dumbledore, Remus etc!. Doesn't it feel tough killin all those characters! I really hate it!. She also killed off ALL my favoirate characters:
Sirius
Remus
Snape
Dumbledore
Tonks
Dobby
Regulus Black
Fred (its terrrible alright!.!.killing one and leaving the other alive)
i could go on forever
INSTEAD she should have killed these people:
Draco Malfoy
Aberfoth
Hagrid
Dolohov
sTURGIS pODMORE
kreacher (stinky little toerag)
Fudge
Umbridge
and thats it
its really sad about Sirius, Remus and Snape's death!.
But I felt sad about Sirius the most! He spent half his life being inncorrectly accused of something and he died with that knowledge!
It would have been nice if Rowling freed him before she killed him!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Some of the ones you list as the should have killed though are crucial to the plot of Deathly Hallows - Kreacher for helping in the final fight and the story behind the locket Horcrux!. Aberforth helps explain the story of Arianna and does help in the final battle!. Hagrid helps connect Harry to his parents in having been James and Lily's friend!.
I too was very sad at the death of those you listed!. But like others have said it's a war and there are deaths of both good and bad (the bad deaths just kind of get overlooked - the death eater in the fight at the end of HBP, Crabbe with the Fiendfyre) I agree on Sirius though I wanted him and Harry to have a long and happy friendship!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
in the battle of good and evil
a lot of people die
Good/Bad
we notice the good more, because we're on their sides but have you ever wondered how many bad people died, that weren't mentioned!?
also, all these people sacrificed their livelihood and life so Harry could destroy Voldermort
and they were Happy too, if they weren't they would have stayed as Ghosts!. Think of all these deaths as sacrifice and you have to realize, everyone dies!.!.!.!.no one lives for ever!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I feel the same you do!. I cried as everyone died especially Sirius and Fred!. I knew some was going to die in the final book but I DID NOT especially Fred!. But I think JK did a good job overall!. I loved when Mrs Weasley cursed!. Don't know why but I thought that was hilarious!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
I know, it is really sad, but the story wouldn't have been the same without all of them people dying!.
I cried when most of them did
By the way you forgot about Hedwig!.
LOVE HPWww@QuestionHome@Com
first of all kreacher is not a stinky little toe rag! u should know that if u read the last book!.
and rowling is cruel!. but its war isnt it!? people die in war so yea!.!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
I agree w/ u about the whole killing off all the good pepes, but I like Kreacher, Aberforth& Hagrid: Hagrid was close 2 being a parent 2 Harry too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com
It's a little more realistic when people die!. In real life people die, so it would be weird if they got in this large fight and no one died!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
In the battle of good and evil, some must die!. ;) And some who deserve death, live!. It's art imitating life (and death)!. Www@QuestionHome@Com
She has to compensate for her lack of tragic flair by killing off in quantity rather than quality!. She also had to kill all the people that would make more sense to kill Voldemort rather than Harry!. Dumbledore should have just gotten together a bunch of the most powerful wizards in the world and made quick work of Voldemort!. But teenagers can't relate to a brilliant homosexual wizard riddled with guilt!. It has to be Little Johnny Everyboy who is only reasonably smart and talented and has his parents love, which is supposed to save him from hus utter lack of skill!. You'd think if both his parents were super smart he wouldn't be such an emo piece of crap!. She's just pandering to every mediocre child out there who thinks they're special for some inexplicable reason!. I liked almost every character better than Harry, because he's a sad device to sell books!. It's such a black and white book of good and evil, right and wrong, because it has to appeal to children!.Www@QuestionHome@Com