Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Is anyone dissapointed with Eclipse, especially with Jacob & Bella? Is Breaking


Question: Is anyone dissapointed with Eclipse, especially with Jacob & Bella!? Is Breaking Dawn better!?
Okay, well I have almost finisehd eclipse and am really dissapointed!. Everyone thought it was like the best book but I disagree!. Twilight and New Moon were heaps better!. At some point of time I really liked Eclipse, especially after Bella punched Jacob for kissing her!. I don't like Jacob!. Sure, he can be a friendly, happy person but half of the time he is jealous, aarogant, mean, and just bad!. Okay, I understand that he is in love with Bella, but he is only hurting himself, Bella and Edward!. He hasn't even imprinted on Bella which means that if Bella had picked him, he could just dump her when the right one comes!. How dare Jacob call Edward a manipulator!? He was one that manipulated Bella into kissing him saying that he would commit suicide! GAHHH i got so pissed of, especially when Bella said she was enjoying it!. AND Bella is really annoying me too!. She does not deserve Edward!. How can she be in love with both of them!? Damn Jacob!. The only character I really like at the moment is Edward!. He has done nothing wrong!. He was with Bella first, not Jacob!. I hate Jacob! Grr! I am so annoyed with Stephanie Meyer! LOL!.


Can you tell me your reflections on Eclipse!? What annoyed YOU!? And do you think Breaking Dawn is better!? Eclipse has put me of it!
Thanks guys!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I love Eclipse it is by far my favorite!. But I really do have a hard time saying that!. I enjoy them all about the same!. Breaking Dawn is okay, it defiantly doesn't top Eclipse!. But since you dislike Eclipse, you may like Breaking Dawn!. Get used to having a love/hate relationship with Bella!. Sometimes I adore her, others I just want to hit her!. She really is a lovable character, but she does ignorant things, like kissing Jacob and running off to La Push!.
In Eclipse actually Bella, not Jacob is the character that annoys me most!. Jacob is annoyingly immature and creepy though!. But first she decides she doesn't want to marry Edward, the man, or vampire, she knows, KNOWS she will spend the rest of eternity with!. Why not!? I just cannot understand her sometimes!. Then for kissing Jacob back, it was okay that she was doing it to save his life, but in the end she likes it!. Bleh!. Then she decides she loves Jacob, just not in that way!. What is the point!? But other than Bella's annoying behavior, and bad choices, Eclipse IS my favorite book!. I think!. Twilight and New Moon are great too!. I guess you could say all 3 are tied for me!. Breaking Dawn is 2nd favorite!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I agree with you!. I HATE Jocob too!. But in Breaking dawn it does get better even though Jocob imprints on Bella and Edwards daughter!.(gross!)!. Believe me it does get better!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com

I wasn't disappointed in Eclipse but it still didn't make since because she done all her hard to keep him away then she kissed him what was that!. But Breaking dawn is better!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Dear, Breaking Dawn is worse!. Give me Eclipse any day over Breaking Dawn!. Have you read it already!? I won't spoil anything just in case you haven't!.!.!.

Bella doesn't deserve neither Edward nor Jacob!. Hey, as much as I hate Edward, I sometimes feel sorry for the guy!. Running around doing Bella's bidding must be torture!.

The real manipulator here is Bella!. She used Jacob in New Moon when Edward was gone!. She took advantage of Jake!. Jacob was always there to save her or accompany her, but when Edward came back Bella just dumped Jacob like garbage!.

It should have been Bella that was dumped like garbage!. That assface is a flirt and a user!. If you gave me a choice of picking Bella or Edward, I'd pick Edward!.

What annoyed me in Eclipse was Bella starting to show signs of a needy, sex addict!. Typical!.

LASWww@QuestionHome@Com

You are not liberal and you don't see the situation in a real light!.
I'll tell you!. You see just what you want!.

So , you didn't like Eclipse , just because you didn't want to end that way!? Honey , there are more important things when it comes with reviewing or liking a book!. The plot , the story , the characters , their development , the author's writing style etc!.!.!.!.

You are Edward lover!. I get it!. But , learn to accept all characters , their personality , dislikes , likes and what they are and who they are!. Including Jacob!.
Just because Jake has flaws , unlike Edward , who's goody two shoes
and flawless , doesn't mean that he's a bad character!.
I can relate better with Jake than any other Twilight character!.

Jake is not mean , arrogant or immature!. He just wanted to help Bella!.
In New Moon , I felt bad for Jacob , because Bella was using him all the tme!.
Jake helped her trough her depression , he became friends with her , and eventually fell in love with her!.
When Edward came back ,in the end, she just ran off to him!. So , she particullary used Jake!.
How would you feel if you were in Jake's shoes!?
I'm sure you wouldn't feel great!.
But , it's easier when you talk in your point of view , isn't it!?


Edward is the manipulative one!. Why!? He stalked Bella all the time!. He's like a shadow to her!. He never leaves her!. He is self righteous!. He thinks that everything what he is doing is right!. He banned Bella from seeing Jacob , he kidnapped her trough his sister!.
He actually thinks that Bella can't bring her own decisions , he thinks that Bella is weakling!. Hence , He doesn't respect her , he has a low opinion on her!.

He is far from perfect boyfreind!. He's cold , self centered , abusive , stalker and manipulative!.

Jacob just acts with out thinking sometimes!. He has impediments and flaws!. He's a decent and realistic character!. Actually , he was , until Breaking Dawn!. But I don't want to give you away spoilers!.
You'll find out yourself!.

xx GreetingsWww@QuestionHome@Com

I liked Eclipse although it isn't my favourite but I loved the action of it all!. Jacob got on my nerves ALOT his arrogance annoyed me so much!

Breaking Dawn is better in some ways but I didn't find it to be as fast paced as the previous books!. When it was supposed to be fast paced I couldn't really get into the action because I think it came too quickly and didn't build too much on the suspense of what was going to happen (I hope that makes sense, if not hopefully it will when you read Breaking Dawn) I did have higher expectations for Breaking Dawn BUT I still loved it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com