Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Would you care to comment on a short story?


Question: Would you care to comment on a short story!?
A Thanksgiving Story
by C!.S!.Scotkin



The Thanksgiving I was eleven was a nightmare that lasted two solid days, when it was over I knew my calling in life!.

It was as cold as it can get in New England in November!. Gray, snowy, Mom with red eyes that plainly screamed, “No questions”!.
My sister and I were getting more and more worried…we had learned way before then not to ask anything when Dad came home drunk every night forgetting stuff, like groceries!. I think we had learned that in the womb!. There was nothing in the ice box except a bottle of milk for the baby!. On a lower shelf, half a jar of mayonnaise and about four slices of bread!.

Now, we knew we’d be going to Grandma’s for dinner, that wasn’t the point!. The point was that my Mother wouldn’t ask for help in her shame!. To ask for help was to be defeated, there was no greater sin than to be on welfare!. If you had the choice between welfare and killing yourself and your kids you didn’t choose welfare!. But she always stocked up on macaroni and margarine!. Grandmother would send canned vegetables once in a while!.

Well, Dad came home at eight, drunker than Cooter Brown, barely able to walk, tracking in snow and beer stench, carrying a 35 pound turkey, twice the size of the baby sleeping in the old crib and three times too big to put in the oven!. When he shoved the turkey at Mom, she snapped into slow motion, totally silent insanity!. Took the bird, chucked it through the closed kitchen window!. That crash was not silent, nor were Dad’s curses!. Mom went to her bedroom, dressed in all the clothes she could layer on!. She went out to the car, got in, curled into herself on the backseat, didn’t come out till the next morning!. The old man passed out on the kitchen floor!.

My sister and I looked at each other!. Now what!? More food on the lawn than we had seen in weeks!. We went out, brought it in, really butchered it, but we got it in the ice box without butchering ourselves!. Got all the pieces of wood we could find in the cellar even though my sister was afraid of monsters under the stairs!. I was more afraid of the ones upstairs!. I nailed the wood over the window, smashing my thumb, raising a blood blister, but I would not cry!. I threw a blanket over the old man, who never woke up once!. We took the baby into bed with us, piled up blankets, coats, prayers for morning, mourning prayers, and prayers to wake up anywhere but there!.

When we woke up the baby was gone!. Went into the kitchen where Dad was fixing the window, there was hot oatmeal on the stove, Mom rocking the baby!.

“Hurry up and eat, so we can get to Grandma’s and help”!. !.

Then I knew my calling!.

To be sane, that’s all, just be sane!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I think it's really good!.

Needs a little brushing up though - I think the "Well," whcih starts paragraph 4 could be removed, as it's a little too conversational, and there are two full stops at the end of the third to last line!.

But I really liked it!. You may want to develop it, add more detail perhaps, as I got brilliant flashes of the scenes you were describing, but they were over all too quickly!.

Is this part of a longer work perhaps!? If not, then maybe you should try to have it published in a magazine, or enter it into a short story competition!.

Good luck, well done, and keep writing!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Interesting!. Fairly well written!. The idea of it is kind of depressing!.!.!. But still interesting!. Had a sudden and turning ending that I wasn't expecting!. but it ended fairly well!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Aside from a few grammerical quirks and excessive use of adjectives, I kind of like this!. It's real and easy to relate!. Write some more!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I love it! I think you should try and get it published in a short story magazine!. Or write more short stories and turn them into one book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I was engrossed!.

Sometimes our epiphanies are not joyous!.

Www@QuestionHome@Com

To be sane - picking up the pieces - and taking care of people in need ?Www@QuestionHome@Com

A memory!?
If so, I thank God, that I don't have memories like it!.
Great story!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

What a story hun!.!. i love it!.!. has this been ur life!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

An interesting story!. As for technique, the paragraphs could be divided whenever there is a subject change!. I would put the last two lines into a single paragraph!. I would also use more powerful vocabulary!. For example: "Went into the kitchen!.!.!. baby!." There is also material for at least two sentences here!. The subject keeps changing and it confuses the reader!.

Just my opinion!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I had massive problems with getting my 3 month old son to sleep!. He would just lie awake and cry for hours, then when he finally went to sleep he would wake every hour or two hours through the night and cry again! Talk about pulling our hair out !.!.!.!. we were absolutely desperate for sleep!

It was a baby sleep audio program recommended by a friend that finally saved us!. We followed the advice and began by creating a baby sleep routine which included bathtime, dimming of the lights, putting Paul into his crib, final nappy change and then lullabies!. We also made recommended changes to his naps during the day and used some of the other recommended techniques!. Within two weeks he was sleeping through the night most nights with just the odd night where he would just wake once!

Definitely start by creating a good baby sleep routine though and you could find that solves most of your baby sleep problems!.

Good luck!

Www@QuestionHome@Com

At the ripe old age of eight, my father started taking me with him to to taverns, so that I could drive him home when he got too far gone to drive!. He was a kind and gentle man until he drank, then he could get mean and hard to deal with!. My calling was to be a great race car driver, but after a couple years on dirt tracks, I figured I better get a day job!. Life with an alcoholic can be really hard for family members!. I am glad you achieved your calling, even if I didn't!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

This well written in my opinion, which is not at all professional, but that of an avid reader!.
We share many similar memories (if this is non-fiction), except when my mom left it wasn't to sleep in the car!. She left and didn't come back!.
Thanks for sharing your story!.

*EDIT: What in the world does Keith's reply have to do with this story!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think you are going places!. It was a deep, dark story, and that's what we need sometimes!. A story to awaken our view of the world and to truly see what is going on!. Please right more!. And let me know when you do!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I really like this, there are a few parts that I kind of stumbled over for example the part whre is says " more food on the lawn!.!.!." I am nout sure if you ment to add something before it or not but it seems a little awkward!.
Other wise I really like this !.!.!.!. good job!.

could you take a look at my question!?
http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index;!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I Think at times we all lose our sanity!. The answer here is to remember what we have how, ever little is worth holding on to!. Your Story was a slap in the face where I am concerned!. I am a recovering Alcoholic, among other things!. Though with hand on Heart I can honestly say, I am a Far Better Person for it!. A Very Lucky one too I might add!. I never once lost the Love and respect of my children, nor did I pass out in a Heap
in front of them!. But then that's another Story!.


Thank you for reminding me [as if I needed reminding,]
That sobriety is Life, and with Life comes Hopes and Dreams and Happiness!. Even if short lived!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I've tried to read this absolutely not as a critic, or some-one who knows you!.!.!.just read it like you would if I'd found it in Reader's Digest!.
It worked for me!. The text was simple, almost child-like!.!.which fits this perfectly as it is a child-hood recollection!. It avoids drama and histrionics!.!.!.what do children know of drama!? They only know about what is!. That isn't to say it isn't dramatic, it is for us the reader, but not for the children involved!.
Only one word would I change!.!.!.!.the word 'butchering'!.!.!.!.since you've said 'butchered' I felt another word was needed there!.!.!.or a phrase 'without cutting off any of our limbs!.
What I like about this story is you are just retelling a series of facts, not making judgemental comments, not trying to manipulate the reader!.!.!.and it has this nice circular feel!.!.since the last sentence answers the first!.
But!.!.!.!.I'm not an expert on short-story writing and I have no knowledge of, say, what a competition judge would be looking for in a short story!.
But, as I said!.!.!.it worked for me!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I did not find this the least bit confusing!.!.
I could easily follow it from start to finish and I related to some extent especially to the calling !.!. To be sane!.!. not sure I fulfilled it but what the hay!.!.!.!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Thanks for your question,

I 'scan-read' your story and it does seem to paint a picture of your thanks giving!.!.!., although I do think that you could consider a more specific title something compelling that makes your reader want to read it!.

'A Thanksgiving Story' doesn't seem to say much, for example a title
like 'The mystery of the dissapearing Thanksgiving Turkey' will make you wonder what's it's all about!.

(it goes without saying that it would be a completely other story, but it's just as an example!.)

All the Best,
To your Happy - Writing - Inspiration,
HP

http://hpshappywriting!.blospot!.com

Www@QuestionHome@Com

My question is twofold: Was this meant to be just cathartic, or do you plan to leave it for someone or submit somewhere!? If cathartic, which it would be by you taking the time to write, it is a great write, engrossing and troubling too!. If you plan to submit or leave for someone, then the editing table needs attention!. There is much here that could be stated clearer, developed more and tuned to really stand out as a look of America in your era and also a look of what a disease can do to a family!. We all have skeletons!. Thanks for sharing!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Your prosaic poetry is beautiful!. It is gripping as it takes me on your journey, afraid of what might happen to the children; then to see how brave they were in the middle of this massive overload!. This is a winner!. I hope you enter it into a short story contest!.tWww@QuestionHome@Com