Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Twilight books....bad??? dont think so!?


Question: Twilight books!.!.!.!.bad!?!?!? dont think so!!?
well i am reading the twlight books!.!.!.but my mom was talking to some other moms who said thy were inaproriite!. so now she has to read them before me to "aproove" them!. what i want to know is if they are not good for an 11 year old!.!.!.!.should i read them!?!?!? plz help!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
They are not bad at all!. The most that they do is kiss, and in the 4th bok something else but its not descriptive!. Its definetly not bad for an 11 year old as long as you are mature enough to handle it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's not sexually explicit, but it sends out some very anti-feminist messages and gives kids bad ideas about how relationships should work!. I know y'all think Edward is dreamy and everything, but once you REALLY start to look at it he's very manipulative!.
I wouldn't let anyone under 14 read it unless they were very mature!.

I know it's the "new hip thing" and everyone is reading them, but they really aren't that great!. You aren't really missing out!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It may not be sexually explicit but the books are inappropriate for an eleven year old!. It glorifies abusive relationships, stalking, paedophilia, sexism and suicide!.

For example let's take Edward!. The majority of Twilight fans think that it's perfectly acceptable for him to remove the engine out of Bella's car, prevent her from seeing her friends, manipulate her into marriage, watch her sleeping without her consent (at first), OIL HER WINDOWS so he could sneak into her room at night without her knowledge!. Don't even attempt to try and say 'oh he does it because he loves her!.' He has NO right whatsoever to control her regardless of his intentions; he is not her father!. Though according to many Twi-tards this ABUSIVE behaviour is seen as being romantic!. There is nothing romantic about mental and psychological abuse!.

Pfft!. Though I know I wasted my time, I doubt you actually read any of this, the Twilight 'saga' is definitely not appropriate literature for someone your age!.


Www@QuestionHome@Com

they curse 3 times in the first, 5 in the second, (so far as I've read) 7 in the third and the last will have more than the others!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's pretty bad, and because you're so young, you might become one of those awful crazy types of fans!.
They're not even good books anyway!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Not too appropriate for a 11 year old, unless you're extrememly mature!. Which probably isn't the case!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I don't think its inappropriate, it's not like they talk bout sex or anything or being nude!. It's just a love story with really nothing sexual at all!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

honey, if you are 11, then they are inappropriate!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

okay, the books ages are ranged from 12yrs and up!. i dont think their innapropiate!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i dont get how theyre bad -- you should totally read them!!
and I dont think it inappropriate at all (im 14 btw)
I <3 the twilight series!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

ur 11 kind of young for that kind of love I dont read those books but i know what there aboutWww@QuestionHome@Com