Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Twilight question/opinion?


Question: Twilight question/opinion!?
Do you think the only reason Bella and Edward fell in love was because he was beautiful and a vampire and Edward couldn't hear her mind and her scent wasstrong to him!? I mean would they have fallen in love if Bella was like a normal girl and Edward could hear her mind and the scent wouldn't be so strong!? I honnestly think that the only reason they started to be together was cuz he was beautiful and she interested him and then maybe once they got to know eachother, they fell in love!. What do you think!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
It is purely physical attraction!. The fact that Edward is (supposedly) really pretty and the fact that Bella smells like delicious food are the *only* reasons they "fall in love", because those are the only reasons there *are* for them to "fall in love"!. Bella is boring!. She doesn't do anything!. She has no interests, no hobbies, no ambitions!. She is a thoroughly unpleasant person!. There is nothing appealing about her, other than, to Edward, her smell!. Edward has no decent personality traits either; he is emotionally abusive!. Why does Bella put up with it!? Because he's pretty!. Let's imagine that, say, Mike was the one who followed her to Port Angeles while she shopped with her friends!. That Eric had climbed into her room to watch her sleep!. That Tyler had sabotaged her engine so she couldn't go to see Jacob!. Would she tolerate those things from them!? Absolutely not!. In fact, when Mike gets protective of her because of Edward, she laughs in his face!. Why does Edward get the special treatment!? His looks!. Simple!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think the attractions they had had a lot to do with it!. If Edward were not good looking!? If Bella didn't have the scent!? Maybe even then!. They still would have been lab partners in biology, and they would have impressed each other with their knowledge!. They would have chatted and found that they shared certain traits, likes/dislikes and values!.

I think Bella would have intrigued him even if he'd been able to see into her mind!. The thing is, she wasn't much like other teens!. He liked everything he heard her say in her sleep, everything she said to him!. I think her mind would have attracted him!. And since she'd never had a boyfriend and was more into the type of men in historical novels, his ways would still have appealed to her!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i agree with you!.
if he could read her mind and she smelled normal then edward would of never of looked at her twice!. just like jessica stanley!.
however theres also the possibilty that if edward could read bella's mind the first day when he tried that what she was thinking could of stood out to him!.
edward always said that bella had an interesting mind!. and he never understood it!.
but we'll never know cause he cant read her mind and she smells really good!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i think that he was drawn to her because of her smell and because he couldn't hear her but i think the attraction was more than that!. if you read the first bit of midnight sun on stephanie meyers website then you understand i bit better why he loves her and what attracts him to herWww@QuestionHome@Com

Edward was always rescuing her from danger so maybe he got off on that!. Maybe he likes to rescue his damsel in distress!. Bella probably enjoyed being rescued!. What girl would not want to be rescued by their Knight in shining armor!.

BTW I love the Twilight series!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

yea thats what it was all about in the beginging but as they got to know each other they fell in love!. i believe that it was very beutiful!. i wish real life could be as easy as that!. SM is a great wrighter, but needs to get over herself right now!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yeah, I think the only reason he was interested was because he couldn't read her mind

also, her strong scentWww@QuestionHome@Com

I think that no matter what they would have been together they were meant to be together!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i think they wud of fallen in love anyways!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com