Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Do you think Holden Caulfield from the Catcher in the Rye was crazy?


Question: Do you think Holden Caulfield from the Catcher in the Rye was crazy!?
Okay, so a lot of the “experts” seem to think Holden Caulfield has some mental illness!. I didn’t see that though, at all!. I believe, if anything, Holden is extremely mentally gifted!. He is actually concerned about the world, ya know!? He is a very unselfish person, which I believe is rare!. And, yet, people are so eager to jump on the fact that there is something wrong with him!. Yes, he thinks everyone is a phony, but isn’t that kinda how it really is!? There are really so many people in this world who act like tools!. How many people actually think about making a mark their mark in the world!? And how many people actually go out and make their mark!? How many care!? Not many, they’re to busy buying fancy cars and expensive cloths for themselves, am I right!? I mean, not everyone is selfish and ignorant like that, but I don’t think there is enough of people who aren’t!. I mean, if people weren’t so concerned about appearing as something, if they weren’t social tools, but actually were who they are, wouldn’t there be so much more contributed to the world!? Maybe there wouldn’t be people dying in Africa, or maybe we’d have a cure for cancer!. I mean when the number of deaths in a day is just a number, there is something wrong!. I think Holden sees this!. And yet, people say Holden is depressed, but I think he just concerned for others!. I think he sees what most people just put up blinders to!. Furthermore, it frustrates him that some people don’t really care!. I think Holden is a cynic, but I also think he is positive!. If he was totally negative, like so many people say he is, why would he even care about the world!? He is persistent in his feelings and I think he realizes that he probably can’t change the whole world, but I think he wants to change what he can!. Ya know, at least lead some horses to water!.

So, that’s what I see in Holden!. But what do you think!? I don’t want to be one-sided or anything either!.

So yeah, what is your opinion of Holden Caulfield’s (Catcher in the Rye) mental condition!?

Peace =]

Keep on rockin' in the free world!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I love your question, even though there isn't much point in me answering it!. I just agree with you, pretty much absolutely!. The whole "Holden is mentally ill" thing bugs the crap out of me, and has for years!. I first read Catcher more than thirty years ago and when I read it in HS a couple years later, that was not the focus at all!. No one taught that there was anything wrong with Holden, it was taught that his world was a mess, which is how I had read it myself!. Obviously we knew he was being "treated", but that was considered to be because his parents didn't want to deal with the person he was!. Our assumption was that his parents were the troubled ones!. Being on Y!A, and seeing the Catcher questions, obviously from school, has unnerved me!. It seems that people are now being taught that to disagree with or fear the status quo is a symptom of illness!. To me the main points are being missed and I am grateful to you for seeing it the way I think it is and for not being willing to swallow the current contemporary view!. I love your phrasing, you have provided me with the most fun I've had on Y!A all day!. Thanks for that, and for having a mind of your own, especially one which seems very decent!. My opinion of Holden's mental condition matches up quite nicely with my opinion of yours!.

You, my friend, keep on rockin' in the free world! Here's a Neil song for Holden:

http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=H1JPWESil!.!.!.

http://www!.lyricsmode!.com/lyrics/n/neil_!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

He was definitely "touched in the head"!. Why wouldn't he be!? Normal people just don't think like that!.

Crazy doesn't mean he's not brilliant though!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think he was crazy!. But its been so long since I've read the book, who knows!. I'm glad that they didn't make a movieWww@QuestionHome@Com