Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Breaking dawn? Did you expect this?


Question: Breaking dawn!? Did you expect this!?
I didn't see it coming!. but did any of you expect Charlie to laugh when Bella and Edward said they're getting married and told them that Bella had to tell her mom!? Did you expect that!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Not!.At!.All!. I thought he was going to flip out and like get mad at Bella and Edward and have like a heart attack!. But it didn't happen!. lol

I loved his reaction though!.

Another reaction I loved was Bella's reaction when she found out Jacob imprinted on Renesme!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

No, I didn't!.

And I didn't expect Renee to be upset about it!. What the hell was the point of making everyone think that Renee would flip out during Eclipse, only to turn it around and have Renee frolic through a field of daisies at the news in Breaking Dawn!? Anti-climatic and negating plot points from the previous books much!? It was SUCH a cop out!. It made the entire Renee plot from Eclipse completely and totally unnecessary!. Like I said-- it was a cop out!.

Both instances seemed SO out of character to me!. Renee's reaction shocked me even more than Charlie's did, though!. What kind of mother finds out their daughter is getting married at 18 and doesn't worry or have any objections!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

I didn't expect it, but I think it fits only because they both know Rene's feelings about marrying young!. I think it was a bit anti-climactic that there was no negative reaction, but the reasoning seems fair- Bella never was young!. Rene refers to her as being an "old soul" and even mentions that she was expecting it after the visit she had in the previous book!.

I think its okay that he did this since his first reaction (pregnant) was very legit!. Interesting though that he seemed to be forshadowing future events!. !. !. !. Www@QuestionHome@Com

I thought Charlie had lost it!. I was surprised he didn't go right for his gun-belt! First he blames Edward for Bella falling down the steps in Phoenix, then Edward leaves and Bella totally loses it, so him laughing it off was something I defiantly didn't see coming!.
But Renee, I just don't feel like I know her, like I do Charlie!. So her reaction way kind like 'Oh well that's good!.' But at the same time had she flipped it would have added to the plot, so I guess if she had made a big deal about it I would have noticed more!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Really hnestly I had No Idea What Exactly To Expect in BD!. But Charlie Laughing and Renee going along with it is well!.!.!.!.I have no words!. But Charlie did get mad, but he didn't throw a tantrum!. He just started laughing because he thought that Renee would be the one to give Bella the hard time!. But noooooo, Cheery Renee was all fine with it and she even was expecting it to happen soo!. So to answer your question:

No, I don't think anyone expected that to happen and I certainly did not!.

Hope this answers your question!

:)~?*Carina* ?~:)Www@QuestionHome@Com

most of the book was a shock too be honest!. The whole jake imprinting on bella's daughter thing messes with me!. When she grows up will jake be like so i used to dream about your mom naked!?" it just seems weird to me! Www@QuestionHome@Com

I didn't think that either, i thought he would of flipped out at bella, nd like kinda disown her!. but she's like 18 now so she has her own life now!. I didn't expect him to laugh thoWww@QuestionHome@Com

BREAKING DAWN IS THE BEST!!! It really is : )Www@QuestionHome@Com

not reallyWww@QuestionHome@Com