Would Breaking Dawn have been better for you if Renesmee had died?

Question: Would Breaking Dawn have been better for you if Renesmee had died!?

This sounds cruel, I know, but this is an honest question!.

The reason a lot of people, me included, didn't find Breaking Dawn to be all that good was because everything turned out too perfect in the end!. EVERYONE got what they wanted, & to me, it made me feel that the first three books in the series was just a waste of time, because those conflicts eventually amounted to nothing, since everything turned out utterly perfect!. Would you have found Breaking Dawn to be a better book & a better ending for the Twilight Saga is there had been SOME loss, such as Renesmee dying!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

It would have been better if Bella didn't become pregnant AT ALL!. Can't Stephenie think of a fight with the Volturi without that creature involved!?

The book dragged, I know!. They just kept talking, I resisted the urge to put the book down!. It was too much of a sugar-coated happy ending!. And Jacob imprinting on Renesmee!? Please!. Quil already did that, Stephenie! You're running out of ideas, eh!?

Someone of importance in the book should have died, but definitely not in the Cullen family!

Agreed, if Jacob died that would be so much of a loss and I would have cried, even if I am not a Jacob fan!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It would have been better for me if there was no Renesmee!. Breaking Dawn was disappointing!. I loved the first three books in the saga but I didn't find any liking to the last!. Stephenie could have done so much with the last book, instead she chose to get Edward and Bella hitched, then she knocks up Bella, and to top it off they live in the Cullen's backyard!. I don't get it!. Renesmee ruined everything!. It wasn't even sweet like the other three books between Edward and Bella, everytime they were alone they just had sex, I mean not that I'm complaining about that, I was hoping for it to happen all throughout Eclipse, but it ruined it for me!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

honestly it would have been a better ending if they all died or it ended in the middle of the action with the volturi attacking, so then it would have left us in a little suspense and not revealed who died and who did not!.

i wish renesmee just was never conceived, because the plot just got worse after that, i mean come on jacob imprinted on bella's baby!.!.!.!.ugh so many things make me mad about this book

WHAT HAPPENED TO THE CHARACTERS they werent even the same 'people'Www@QuestionHome@Com

I definitely see where you're coming from, but I didn't want Renesmee to die!.!.!.

I wanted a war! Seriously- the Volturi show up prepared to waste the entire clan, and then!.!.!. "Oh!.!.!. Well, we'll be going now!. Enjoy your happy ending!." It's so stupid!

I was kinda expecting Seth or Jacob to die, to be honest!.!.!. That would have made it better to me!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i totally agree with you
something should've happened at the end of the book everything was just to perfect and it didn't feel like the end of the amazing seris

Www@QuestionHome@Com

I wanted an all out war: vampires from ALL over the world + "shape shifters" against the volturi!.
That would've been ULTIMATE!.
also, having Jacob die in the battle would've completed the book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I would have liked a battle between the vampire/werewolves and the Volturi, but I would NOT want Renesmee to die!. I still loved the book, though!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

yeah i guess it would be a tad better
but stephenie meyer made everything perfect i guess
so that everyone has a perfect ending idk
her book :\Www@QuestionHome@Com

SPOILER

yes i believe so!. i wish she wasnt born in the first place!. but i also wish bella was never a vampireWww@QuestionHome@Com

How about her not being born at all!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

your so right i thought jacob would die defeding bella or renesmee and i hate how easy the book was the last line might as well have been, "and they all lived happily ever after" it was such a disapointment!. It also seemed like all of the characters changed for the last book, everyone seemed duller to me!. And having the book in jacobs POV seemed stupid to me!. Edward was like a minor character!. BD had so many flaws it was a waste of my time freaking outover and waiting in line in front of B&N at 7pm-12am!. and they should have fought in the ending scene the whole peace thing mad me so angry!. and i was reading an article someone wrote about SM's religion being a reason so many things were kept "disney" pg!. the sex scenes fight stuff & more!.Www@QuestionHome@Com