Breaking dawn was it good or was it bad what do you think?

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Breaking dawn was it good or was it bad what do you think?

Question:

I personally thought breaking dawn was rubbish for these reasons first big chunk of the book was jacobs point of view secondly the cruddy ending i mean what happens next it would of been better if they all died but alice and jasper in the fight with the volturi and last come on stephenie purlese cant bella of had a better gift i mean yawn tell me what you think Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

Ugh I though it was absolutley awful!. Bella annoyed me more in this book!. She suddenly became a mary sue 'perfect character' and her little demon child renesmee soon followed!.

Renesmee was my biggest problem with the book!. Stephanie Meyer actually said 'Vampires couldn;t have children' so why did she make Bella pregnant!? It seemed like bad fanfiction!.

The whole book seemed rushed and was written in a totally mediocre way!. It almost seemed like she wrote this book for the sake of it, just so everyone got a happy ending!.

I agree with you, if someone had died it would have made a waay better book!.

Ugh, and lastly this book totally killed the point of eclipse!. The whole theme in eclipse was the fact that Bella would have to choose between Charlie, Jacob, Renee and all of her human friends, or Edward, her true love!. But in the end she gets all of it!?! AND a child!?

I must say, I used to think SM was a fairly good author, but BD had left me with doubts!. BIIG doubts!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yeah, I was kind of hoping she would be able to like move things with her mind or something Cool at least, i mean a shield is kind of boring considering she could always do it anyways!. Yeah and I was kind of hoping someone would die, like maybe someone of the volturi or something It would have made the book more dramatic!. I didn't like book 2 in Jacobs POV its was soooo boring and long, I mean It was basically just him talking with his pack for half of it!?!? I like the book up till page 120, except for a few details like Bella crying to get Edward to have sex with her and the fact that she turns into a complete sex addict was a little strange too Lol, I thought the rest was all just rubbish too!. They should have made a fight or something at the end to add a wee bit of entertainment, but no she just like basically said they all live happily ever after!?!? Man, i was soo dissapointed when I read it, oh and when would you ever see Bella wearing a silk cocktail dress!?!? Like never!!? Stephenie completely changed Bella's personality, like she turned her into an alice!. Ugh anyways I was completely unsatisfied with this book and steph should write another one to make up for it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I thought it was REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY good!. I think some people are mad because things didn't happen that they wanted and she "ended" the series!. I mean yes there are no more books from Bella's POV but there are more (the same stories) from other peoples POV!. She ended it because if she went on it would get boring and also she wanted US the readers to be able to fins the story how we wanted!! If they all died people would like kill Stephenie! And yes Bella could have had a better gift but then she wouldn't be our Bella!. I see how it could be better, but even more than that, i see how it could be worse!.So people STOP complaining! If you don't like it don't read it ok!!? I mean seriously! This is Stephenie's baby for crying out loud!!! If you cant say anything nice, don't say anything at all!.
I will say it was not at all wat i thought!. But the funny thing is my friend and i wrote fan-fiction b4 Breaking Dawn came out!. and in it Bella got pregnant, Emmett made similar comments, and Jake came back!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It was the best book ever! If you don't like this book you are Rubbish!!
Many people dont like this book, I don't know why my friends seemed to like it but that is just my opinion!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

personally i dont think it was bad but it wasnt as great as the first book but it really wasnt all bad and i still love it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

What do I think!? I think you should kick start your brain and then use the search box!. This same question is asked about every four seconds on this board!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Just going to copy and paste what i said to someone else::

Book One:
I liked it, especially the first 2 chapters! xD The book was spoiled for me so i knew Bella would be pregnant!. But when she found out she was Pregnant i was Like WHATT!? Lmao!.!. not that cared! I Didn't mind her having a baby, but it just wasn't Bella, She seemed more and more mature!. She wasn't even Clumsy like she is, so she was a bit out of character!.!. xD

Book Two:
my Favorite!.!. I Loved it so much! lol Jacob was so funny!. But i didnt like the way he was in so much pain Because of that ***** Bella!.!. lmao I Wanted him and Leah to imprint on each other even if i knew that was impossible!. But it didnt happen!. I also wanted him to imprint on that girl in the park lizzie!. I Was so annoyed when he imprinted on Bella's child! Out of all People herrrr! How dare stephenie Meyer!?But i grew to like Renesmee so i dont mind now!. The blondie jokes were soo funny, and i got to know Seth more, so now i like him!

Book Three:
This was the one i least liked, But i still enjoyed it!. It was annoying and it dragged on!. Bella and Edward's love wasnt interesting anymore!. Something was missing and i dont know what!. Bella was over Jacob so quickly and it felt impossible, like she never even loved him in the first place!. At the end i badly wanted a fight so i was disappointed when one didnt happen!. But i really liked the ending, it was amazing!. They all played happy families!. =D

Www@QuestionHome@Com

the only things that bothered me was the whole pregnancy thing, the name renesmee, jake imprinting on her, the lack of fight with the volturi, and the difference in bellas personality!.

first, i thought that bella getting pregnant was unnecessary!. we really didnt need it!. the volturi could have come for a totally different reason and it would have been fine!. bella is just a kid herself!. she should have a baby girl!. its wrong!. its not a very good message, and i know that this book doesnt have a message, but heres a girl thats giving up everything at 18 to be with the guy of her dreams!. not exactly a role model for teenage girls!.

renesmee!. that just says it all!. i know its supposed to be one of a kind, but really!.!.RENESMEE!? carlie would have been better, and thats not even a great name!. and i hated the nickname EJ!. that would have been worse!. at least renesmee has nessie!. i think thats a pretty ok nickname for her!.

jacobs imprinting SUCKED!. it was too convienient!. it shouldnt happen!. jake deserves so much better than that!. he should have ended up with leah!. because its wrong to just make him forget everything that happened with bella and him!. just plain wrong!. he should still remember that!. and being with leah would have given him that memory!. and leahs such a strong, dependable character!. both of them have been through so much, and that would have made their relationship strong!.

the 70+ pages that i read about the volturi were horrible!. it was all talk, no action!. it was very boring!. i had to just stop at some times and make myself keep going!. i really wanted a huuge battle!. i had the whole thing planned out in my head!.!.!.!.!.oh well!.

and finally, i didnt like the new bella!. she became kinda sex addicted during book one, crying about not being able to do it with edward, and then she becomes maternal, which is SOO not bella!. and finally, she loses everything about her when she becomes a vampire!. sure, she still loves edward, but shes not bella anymore!. shes not clumsy or easy to embarrass!. thats what i liked about her!.

ohh, and some another thing i didnt like: the birthing!. ahhh, too gross!. disturbing!. i didnt need to have all those mental pictures!. i was about to throw up!.

but of course, there were parts that i liked in breaking dawn!. i liked the wedding and the honeymoon!. i liked jacobs POV until the last chapter!. i llooooooooove jake!. im totally team jake, so no dissing! =)
i liked bellas transformation, and the introduction to all the vampires that meet with the cullens to witness!. and finally, i liked that edward finally got to hear bellas thoughts!. it was a nice way to end the book!.

i give it a 3 out of 5!. not the best, but still good!.Www@QuestionHome@Com