Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Breaking dawn...whats with it?


Question: Breaking dawn!.!.!.whats with it!?
I was wondering if everyone could tell me their thoughts on breaking dawn!. I know many people have asked this question but theres a twist!. Here are the quetions to answer

Tell me the pros and cons(you have to tell both)
Did you think Jacob was acting really weird in the book!?
Did you like the ending!?
How many stars would you rate it and why!?
Did you think bella should have become a vampire!?
And last but not least,
how did you like it overall!?
Thanx for ure answers!Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Pros: I think this book left all of us happy Team, Jacob, Edward and Switz can all find comfort here!. Everyone was happy, and nobody died!.

Cons: NOBODY DIED! I know that sounds odd, as I love all of the characters, like they were family, but I wanted to see Rosalie, or someone die, defending their family, the Cullens!. The cover-art on the book symbolizes the final scene with the Volturi, and I guess in a way somebody did win, but the chess game was never really played, I guess!.!.!.

Did you think Jacob was acting really weird in the book!?
-No, not weird he just wasn't the Jacob we know, but it seemed to me a lot of characters were out of character!. I never was a fan of Jacob, but I really like him in Breaking Dawn, he moved on, accepted that Bella had moved on!.

Did you like the ending!?
-Yes, I was pleased that it was all happy!. I really wish their would have been a huge Volturi fight, with minimal, but important casualties [not Edward or Bella!]!.

How many stars would you rate it and why!?
-I give it 4 out of 5 because a lot of writing leads up to something that didn't end up happening more than once! The Volturi fight, the "lavish wedding" I was expecting was only what 2 pages long!? I think the wedding was less detailed then the honeymoon!.!.!.which also sucked!. I want details! In a non-creepy way of course!.!.!.!.=]

Did you think bella should have become a vampire!?
-Yes, I wanted that the whole time!. The thought of Bella and Edward together for eternity is amazing!. But now that she is, it is a guarantee that there will not be any more books, it would not be entertaining, which makes me very sad!. I'm like what am I supposed to do now!? Lol I guess just look forward to the movie!.

And last but not least,

How did you like it overall!?
Over-all I was pleased, even though I was expecting a sad ending, and maybe a 10-years later type thing; you know Jacob and Renesmee, what Edward and Bella are up to, how Rosalie and Jacob are getting along!.!.!.things like that!. I was dissapointed that it ended back at the cottage, with Edward finally being able to read Bella's thoughts as well, but at least she can control it!. I'm glad the series ended the way it did, and a lot of people are dissapointed by it, I think later on they will realize it's a good ending, to a great series!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well I guess we know now how it ends whether we like it or not!.
I think that all of the characters were acting different and weird!.
I thought the ending was boring and actually kind of scary!.
I probably wouldn't give this book any stars but it does deserve something I guess for effort!.
I don't think Bella should have become a vampire!.
I don't really know why this book was so long because it was so uneventful that it did not need that many pages!.
I did buy it and read it so I guess I got some kind of enjoyment from it!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Okay here are my pros and cons PROS- Lots of humor like Emmett making fun of Edward and Bella's sex life, Jacob and Rosalie messing with each other etc!. There is a lot of romance, and just all around good parts!. CONS- The only thing was that Stephenie didn't have Leah or Seth or Embry imprint on anyone, and I really wanted them to find that special someone!.

I did not think Jacob was acting weird at all! This was the one book i actually started to really like him!!! He was so sweet to Bella and all the Cullen's!.

I thought the ending was very romantic and sweet!. It was perfect way to tie Bella's story all together!.

I would give it 4!.5 stars out of 5!.

I was so happy Bella finally became a vampire, and she can see Charlie also, so I thought that was awesome! Edward and Bella can be together sooo much more when she is a vampire! And do so much more <3 haha

I thought it was great over all! I loved it! Could not have asked for more from Stephenie Meyer!

TEAM EDWARD <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Pros: in part of the book it explained jacob's point of view which was really awesome, and it was probably the only part in the book i liked
Cons:in the end when they were supposed to fight with the volturri was really boring because all they did was talk, and nobody that was important died!. the ending was a little bit too unrealistic happy for me!.
No, only when he got over bella so quickly, that was like writing two books for nothing
No, hate the ending
I'd give it three stars, just because i liked the middle of the book
Yes, she's been putting it off for way too long
Overall it was ok, but definitely not what i was expectingWww@QuestionHome@Com

Pros: i loved the beginning!. and everything up until bella got pregnant!. i liked jacob and rosalie's hatred toward each other!. i know people didnt like this much but!.!.!.i loved all the sex!. i know!.!.!.im perverted and gross!. all of emmett's sex comments too!. haha!.

Cons: uh the whole volturi thing!. no action!. SM spent like 100+ pages on them and it comes up to!.!.!.uh!.!.!.!.!."ok!. you did nothin wrong!. a-bye!!" man i wanted some ACTION!! and i disliked how leah was suddenly blown out of the picture after bella became a vampire!. she should of had a happy ending too!. i liked her!.

jacob was!.!.!.jacob!. no weirdness there!.

the ending was eh!.!.!.ok!. didnt love it!.

it was an 8/10!.

OF COURSE I THOUGHT BELLA SHOULD HAVE BECOME A VAMPIRE!! although i thought it was unlikely to happen!.

i liked it!. didnt love it!.!.!.but hey, atleast it ended happily!.!.!.!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Pros are that Edward and Bella are together!. And no one really died!. Cons!.!.there's no Team Jacob or Team Edward!.!.or even Team Bella!.
Yeah!. He's been imprinted!. that changes a person!.
no!. It's too quick!. there wasn't really any tense moments!. no fights!.
um!.!.outta 10!? i would give it!.!.4 or something!. I hated to see the series end and I didn't like it as much, it was different!.
Yeah!. But I didn't like the way it happened!. I'm not sure how I would've like Bella to become a vampire, but I knew she should've!.
No!. I'm sorry!. I bet everyone else loves it!. I just think it's not like the other ones which I am so obsessed with!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Did you think Jacob was acting really weird in the book!?
I think he reminded me of a depressed teenager!. "Emo" would be the word!. But honestly I felt bad for him!. Bella is kind of mean to him!.

Did you like the ending!?
No!. It was cliche and unrealistic!.

How many stars would you rate it and why!?
Three!. It has its ups and downs!.

Did you think bella should have become a vampire!?
Yes!. I don't really know why she shouldn't!.

And last but not least,
how did you like it overall!?
One side of me was enjoying it immensely!.
The other side was enjoying mocking it immensely!.

Clearly I am of two minds!.
I'm sorry if my pessimism offends anyone! Remember these are just opinions!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Pros: It had a beautiful ending
Cons: Jacob is a pedophile!

Jacob is ALWAYS acting really weird!.

I LOVED THE ENDING! it was the best way ever to end a book ^_^

ten stars, i simply loved it!. it was different and creative!. and it had Edward in it, so yeah!.!.!.

Of course Bella should have become a vampire! she had a freaking vampire kid already!

Umm i loved it overall, if you hadn't already guessed!. People need to stop hating and suck it up cuz they aint gonna get a rewrite :DWww@QuestionHome@Com

Hmm!.
I don't think jacob was acting any weirder than usual!.!.!.!.!.
Hes always been a little annoying and arrogant

I loved it:)

1,000!. Hah i love twilight!.

Uhm yeahh she should have!. That's been her goal through out all four books!. It'd be stupid not to change her in the final book!.

I LOVED itWww@QuestionHome@Com

loved renesme hated pregnancy
bella turns thats a plus

I think he should have imprinted on Leah!. shes all alone now

I LOVED the ending

10 stars because it toys with ur emotions

i loved it overall bt a little 2 much sexWww@QuestionHome@Com

Q:Did you think Jacob was acting really weird in the book!?
A: honestly, yeah!. i mean, i personally think that he got over bella WAAY to fast!. and i think that he was out-of-character in the book too!. like some of the crap he did just didn't seem like stuff he'd do at all!.
[sorry for the vagueness, lol, i'd look up an example but my friend has my book right now]

Q:Did you like the ending!?
A: BOOOOOOOO!!! i was sooo pissed off!. like i sat there for a minute like, what the fxck just happened!? HALF THE BOOK, they're preparing to fight the volturi, and scheming, and preparing for like 200 freaking pages!. and then at the climax when they FINALLY meet them!.!.!. THEY TALK IT OUT WITH THEM AND THE VOLTURI LEAVE!. whaaat!?!!?!!?!!?!!?!

Q:How many stars would you rate it and why!?
A: Like 1 because it was honestly a major disappointment!. It was an insult to end the series the way she did!. especially with jacob being like some pedo who's inlove with her baby renesmee!. i know, the most uncreative name ever!.

Q:Did you think bella should have become a vampire!?
A: yeah, but i don't think it should have happened the way it did!. i think that because it was like you know SUCH A SPECIAL moment, it should've been heartfelt and meaningful, not a last-ditch attempt to save bella's life!.]]]:

Q:how did you like it overall!?
A: it was soooo disappointing!
Www@QuestionHome@Com