| Question Home |
Position:Home>Books & Authors> How do you think Stephenie Meyer will react to the negative feeback on BREAKINGQuestion: How do you think Stephenie Meyer will react to the negative feeback on BREAKING DAWN!? Do you think she'll make a statement!? Because in both US and here in UK people aren't really digging the book, many are insulting it and calling it 'bad fan fiction'!.!.!. How do you think she'll handle that!? Will it be a blow to prevent the making of Midnight Sun!?Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: I agree that people's expectations were not what they should of been!. People dont seem to be very happy that Bella got she everything wanted!. It was what Stephenie wanted for them after all the trails and tribulation, and I for one, am happy that they got a happy ending!. And even if Renesmee is the most ridiculous, laughably ugly name I have ever heard, its sort of endearing that shes called Nessie in the end!. And contrary to other opinions I have been reading, I think that Bella did grow/mature with the birth of her daughter, and in the same coin, Bella and Edwards relationship developed also!. I will agree that I was disappointed by the lack of focus Stephenie put on their relationship, in that there wasn't alot of private time for them, or insight into their relationship as there was in the previous books!. This book was very different than the others, in style and focus!. But for sure, not disappointing!. New Moon was the worse, by far, but still good in its way!. Www@QuestionHome@Com I think everyone is calming down about it!. I agree that the spoilers are what really pissed people off (and that they turned out to be true)!. I think it's pretty good, I actually found myself liking Jacob portion better than both of Bella's (even though I was an Edward fan)!. I saw someone talking about the other book it was based on and I had heard it was the Princess Bride!. I don't really see how it related to Princess Bride but w/e!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I don't know!. Honestly, the first three books of the Twilight saga were decent!. They were believable!. But in this book, everyone is just so ridiculously out of character - particularly Bella, who is obviously the most central character, the one every reader is supposed to 'relate' to!. There were way too many holes!. It read like it was rushed!. I wouldn't blame her if she did; it was a lot of pressure to write under!. But the fact is, it was a poorly written finale!. I'm not sure if she knows that!.Www@QuestionHome@Com Happy Puppy's right!.!.!.people are starting to calm down!.!.!.next thing you know it will be back to the same hype Twilight got! You never know!.!.!. I wish that Stephenie will come out already and make a statement, explain these plot holes, unanswered questions, reveal the second book that she based Breaking Dawn on, etc etc!.!.!.And also redeem herself!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I think the book could have been a lot worse!.!.!. somehow!.!.!. the weird plot line for one thing but i dont think that will ruin the hype for midnight sun as we all know what to expect in that anyway, plus twilight itself was probably the best book out of the four so it cant be THAT bad!.!.!. can it!? =/Www@QuestionHome@Com I don't think the reaction has been all negative!. I for one loved the book! It was everything I wanted it to be!. I think people were just a little upset when the spoilers turned out to be true!.!.!.but the way they were written didn't make the story sound silly!.Www@QuestionHome@Com She won't give a sh!t, i wouldn't either with what they're paying her!. But i didn't think it was bad at all!. People's expectations were way too high i think!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I think that she's worried her publisher won't let her write another sick series from Ed's POV!. LuthienTWww@QuestionHome@Com People are starting to warm up to it, i'm noticing!.!.!. WOOF!Www@QuestionHome@Com |