Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Ok wtf do EVERYONE hate breaking dawn !?!?!?!


Question: Ok wtf do EVERYONE hate breaking dawn !!?!!?!!?!
*****SPOILERS*******


I am so incredible furiouse at the reactions her book got

are you all kidding me!?!?

jake imprinting on nessie was wierd at first but it's not like he is IN LOVE with her he just loves her like a sister he wants her to be happy it just like quil and claire!

her having a baby with edward was best of both worlds

soooooooo WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH THAT!

i will admit her writing seemed a bit off and she filled up a lot of pages with things nonessential to the book but i feel she's always done that!.


so my question out there is is there one single person who lies the ending!.!.!.=(Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
I'm iffy! There are things I liked and things I hated!. Example: I hated that Bella ended up getting everything and was perfect!. It made her the perfect Mary Sue, and that really bugged me!. I didn't want her to die or anything, or Edward, but at the very least never get to see Charlie again!. it didn't make sense for her to get it all!.

HOWEVER I did enjoy the ending because it was happy! SM had me SUPER worried and I was so sure Edward and Bella were going to die! I admit I was hoping Nessie would shrivel up and die so she wouldn't ruin it for one of my favourite fictional couples :P I know I'm just that evil!

And I'm 100% happy with the imprinting!.!.!.okay 95%!. I kinda was rooting for Leah! I feel bad for the girl! But it's great that he imprinted and it's not perverted like poeple are insisting it it -_- they just didn't read the book well enough in my opinion!

I'm worried how SM will feel! If she still cares about her writing (I'm sure she does) she'll be so upset to see so many angry people! I hope she keeps writing anyway and knows that not everyone hated it!. Or that she sees a lot of the negative comments aren't very well thought out!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well!.There are,if you liked the ending isn't that a single person!?

Well,Jacob professed his love to Bella and then she has the kid and it seems like nothing ever happened and he can just come back into HER life,and her child's life!.

And she leaves the impression that it is totalllllly okay to just marry right out of high school and have a kid right away!.

It was like a baby having a baby,not the best of both worlds!.

It's SWEET that the baby was literally EATING Bella from the inside!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well so far a lot of people hate, but my beta told me that she at first went into denial, then rage, then bargaining, then depression then finally acceptance!. So I hope that lots of other people will pass on to the acceptance soon!.

I also think most people started reading the book with high expectations which is why everyone is let down!. People should never start reading a book with expectations or it will most likely end up crappy!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

idunno, i saw a lot of people mad about the ending too!. i thought the book was ok/good!. i mean there was a plot hole two, and idunno!. it was sorta slow in some parts, but it was ok!. i think a lot of jacob fans were just mad that he didnt end up with bella!? idunno!. the charecters seemed a little off!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I know! I can't believe everyone's reactions!. I thought it was great!.
I completely fell in love with Nessie (after she was born, though!. Haha)!.
I'm so scared for Steph right now, because almost every review I've seen is a negative one!. I just hope she knows that there are some of us that adored the book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Personally, I've found all of her books went on a downhill slide to crap-dom after Twilight!. They are just not that good, but I will admit, Book 1 and part of Book 2 in Breaking Dawn had good "Ah HAH!" moments!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I liked it!. It left me with sort of a happy feeling haha!.
I was kinda hoping there would be like a battle between the Cullens and Friends and the Volturi, but I still really like the bookWww@QuestionHome@Com

i just think SM could have made a better ending for jake, i don't hate the book thoughWww@QuestionHome@Com

I have a love/hate relationship with the book!. I definately loved that Bella and Edward ended up together and that Jacob finally has somebody to be happy with even if it is Bella's daughter!. I thought SM had gone insane when bella got pregnant, not at all what I was expecting to happen, but the little girl has a way of pulling at your heartstrings!. I wished there had been more Bella/Edward time in the story, and that so much time had not been emphasized on the pregnancy in Jacob's perspective, though he is very funny!. I missed Alice too, I hated that she was gone for a good portion of book 3, but completely forgive her!.
I love the characters and am so glad that none of the main characters had to be sacraficed, it would have broken my heart!. So all and all, I really did like Breaking Dawn, maybe not agreed with the way things went throughout the storyline, but it was a pretty good ending to one of the best series I have ever read!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i thinkk the people who think jakes a pedo didnt read the books, or were too caught up in hatingg it to know what the hell imprinting really is!.


andd yeahh the baby was good, but i read something someone posted somewhere and had to agree!. who ever it was said that steph was basically telling girls its ok to get married young and have a baby, or something like that!. that isnt the most wonderful life lesson ive ever heard

the writing did seem off!.!. like the charecters were differentt in a way :\

andd i liked the book and the ending!. dont think just cuzz i dissed on it a little that i hate it!. mainly im just sad that the series is done ):Www@QuestionHome@Com

i gotta alot of stuff to say to u people and its probably not what you want to hear!.

Have you read the book recently!? The writing style is terrible!. It didn't pull me in!. I didn't feel a connection with any characters!. I could barely keep reading!.

Now, Eclispe was a great book but it got my hopes up that Jacob had a chance against Edward!. That he would fight for Bella or something like that!. Not imprint on Bella's baby!.

Does anyone remember all the feelings Jacob felt for Bella before her baby!? Do you remember their relationship!? They were best friends!. In this book Jacob is just an annoyance to Bella's perfect life!. And then for Jacob to imprint on her baby!. Forget all about what happened with Bella (Not like Stephenie Meyer even hinted there was love between them!.) and find that his soul mate is her daughter!? Cmon people are we that twisted!? I know he's not a pedaphile for sure!. But the way Stephenie Meyer played it out is terrible!. I would have rather had him love by choice!. Maybe Leah!. Maybe someone new!. Maybe Bella before the honeymoon!. With the stupid pregnancy!

I honestly wished she had died when you thought she had!. Relieved Jake of the pain he put her through!. I was so happy when Leah stuck up for him like that!. But no matter what they said Bella did!. She didn't change at all! She was still the weak, clingy, female who couldn't let go of the perfect male (Edward) for a minute!.

And their whole relationship in this book! Oh my god it made me sick!. You wouldn't have been able to tell this was the fourth book if it hadn't been for the names of the characters!. I felt so bad for Jacob!. I don't care what made Bella happy!. I would have been happy if he could have left from her!. Found someone new!.

She's so selfish and for no reason too!. You couldn't even tell Jake and her were best friends with her acting like the olderly overprotective mother all the time!. The whole book was a huge letdown!. Everything just fell into place without any hassle or any mishaps!. She got turned into a vampire, she had her wedding!.

Everything discussed for this book was solved with orderly fashion but not discussed in the book!. They skipped all those parts (the pain of being a vampire, the craving!. The wedding and how much it hurt for Jake not to be there!.) and went on to some wack weirder ones!.

I for one want to burn my pathetic book and wish it had never existed!. I want to remember Jacob as happy!. And not pushed to the side so Bella can have her happy ending!.

I couldn't even finish the book it got to be such a bore, such a chore!.

And the ending sucked!. Sounded like some cheesy movie!. And the fight that never happened was probably because Stephenie was getting rushed and had to solve it quickly!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

i complety and udderly agree with you the twilight saga is phenomenal coming from the girl that reads nicholas sparks , political books and mitch albom not to mention sisterhood of the traveling pants !.!.!. the book is amazing i mean read the last chapter the intenstiy !.!. the book was extending and overbearing at times !.!.!. to blah yet it was perfect physical compassionate love and emotion JACOB cares for NESSIE!
not in the way he ever cared for bella in a love manner !.!.!.
i mean read the book :
" you said we belonged in eachother's lives right!? that we were family!. you said that was how u and i were supposed to be so now we are its what you wanted!.
:]
i love the twilight saga !
and for those that think that its a bad influence or anythingof a misfortunate hope its NOT !
rather its a light like what bella had when she meet edward its hope and lately thats what we all lack !.!.



love jenn !.!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

first off all, the book is just so DIFFERENT from the other twilight books!. its pretty gross too!.!.!. i mean edward biting the baby out of bella!? wtf!. come on now!.
whoever likes this book obviously didn't enjoy the first three, because breaking dawn is nothing like the other ones!.
im so dissapointed in this book its unbelieveable!.
in my mind the series ended with eclipse!. no rennenenesme whatever her name is, and jacob imprinted on leah in my mind!.

--
also,
im so incredibly SICK of bella expecting EVERYONE to rush to save her sorry little a!.ss!.
in twilight 'oohhh nooo cullens help mehhh james is gonna kill mehh'
in new moon 'blah blahh im gonna get turned into a vampiree edward stick up for mehh so i wont get killed by tha volturi'
in eclipse 'omgz pack help mehh, join up with tha cullens and save mehh from victoria'
and in breaking dawn she expected everyone to run and protect her sorry little mutant baby !!!

i wish jacob would just rip her throat out! ugh!Www@QuestionHome@Com