Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> About the Jacob Black/Edward Cullen thing!?!?!?


Question: About the Jacob Black/Edward Cullen thing!!?!!?!!?
So i just read that text from cameron and I'm really shocked about how much she hates Jacob Black!.First of all:I'm on Team Jacob but I love Edward Cullen,too!.I just don't get why everyone is hating on Jacob Black!.Of course a few people think that he is trying to pull Edward and Bella apart and well yeah he tried this for real,but you would do the same if you were in his situation!.Everybody fights for love so what's wrong about that!?But we all know that Bella and Edward will be together forever and even Jacob can't change that so stop hating on him!.He'll probably imprint in Breaking dawn on another girl and finally forget Bella!.So calm down!.And the people,who are on team jacob just want a happy end for him because they love him so much and his boyish charm!.I want a happy end for Edward and Bella too but I just love Jacob the most and want him to find his love!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
i definately do NOT hate jacob!!!! (even though i LOVE edward)
yes!.!.!. jacob can be obnoxious but what guy isn't!. in my opinion, the only reason that people don't like him is because, compared to edward, he's not the perfect guy!. i feel bad for him, actually!.
if things were the way that they were supposed to be, bella woud be in love with jacob!. edward shouldn't be alive, therefore bella's heart shoudn't be taken!. in truth, bella and jacob are soulmates (it's hard for me to say this, because i want bella to end up with edward!. lol)
edward would be almost anyone's number one choice, that's because he's perfect fiction!. jacob is the more realistic character of the two though!. i don't think there is any guy out there, like edward, and i don't just mean because he's a vampire!. haha
yes!.!.!. jacob is fighting for love, and there is nothing wrong with that!. that's why breaking dawn is so highly anticipated!.!.!. who will bella choose!?!?!? i hope she chooses edward, and i hope that jacob imprints on someone better than bella!.
sorry i wrote so much, i just feel very strongly on this subject!!! lol
im going to give you a star because i completely agree with you! haha
;)Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm on Team Jacob aswell, but I know that Edward and Bella love each other!. I hope Jacob imprints on a girl in Breaking Dawn so we can see his happy ending = )!.

EDIT: I do agree with you, she does treat Jacob like crap,
sometimes it gets me mad! I'm like "If only he were real, I wouldn't treat him bad like she does" haha I'm a loser!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i think he will imprint on someone thats not bella whether he likes it or not in breaking dawn!. and then i think people will stop hating on him so much!.
i love jacob
he = raddest werewolf everr (;
answer my !?!? peeps!
http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index;!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

i feel the same way that u do
i think that jake will find someone while he's running away(like at the end of eclipse)
and of course bella will b jealous but that's just her problem
in the end, i think that every thing will work out for bella, jacob, and edward!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

maybe cuz stephenie makes him sound so glorious and perfect, everyone who hates jacob only hates his cuz compared to edward hes not that great!. (that's what I think, anyway)

i do want jacob to find love, though!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

to the first person to answer this!.!. (because we care!?)

ha!.!. okay!.!. i think maybe Jake WILL imprint but not with anyone in the books so far!.!.!. I LOVE Jake to DEATH and i want him to find happiness but i DONT want him and Bella to stop being friends /:Www@QuestionHome@Com

i found it so cruel on how Bella was only using Jacob from the very begining!. He doesn't deserve that and like Bella said in Eclipse, if he does find his soul mate, she'll say that girl is not good enough for him!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I hope Jacob imprint's on Jessica!. That would be funny! I have decided I am Switzerland so I like them bothWww@QuestionHome@Com

Why would someone hate a character in a book!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

AHHHHHHH I LOVE JACOB HE'S THE BOMB!!!!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I want Jacob and Leah to get together, but I know it's not so because he didn't imprint on her ]D:

I personally don't like Bella, I don't think she should be with anyone!. For some reason, Edward loves her, she loves him, so I guess they should marry!.

It creeps me out that she wants sex so much, but that's personal too!.


Or maybe Jacob can imprint on Kirsten Dunst!. That would be good too!.


Not just because she played Claudia in Interview with the Vampire and the irony of it would be awesome!.


I for one would love Jacob to have a wonderful life!.



Because I'm glad that he knows the truth!.
That all vampires are evil!.


I'm probably going to get plenty of thumbs down, but it's true!.

Didn't you read, Edward killed people for ten whole years!.


And Jasper!. All of that!.



It would be cool if Bella is sleeping, and goes into her period!. I really would love to see what would happen!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

People usually hate Jacob because they don't understand him!. They don't understand exactly WHY he "gets in the way of Bella and Edward' or WHY he wants to stop Bella from becoming a vampire!. They don't understand his motivations or the reasonings behind his actions!. For instance, most Jacob haters say his motivation is, "He just wants Bella all for himself and doesn't care about her feelings"!. That right there shows just how much they misunderstand him!. Sure, he fought because he loves her!. But the biggest reason he fought was because he wanted to save her life!. And most Jake-haters seem not to understand that!.

Jacob reacted in the way any rational human being would react if they found out their best friend, and the person they cared for most in the world, was planning to join their enemies and throw their life away (which is how Jake sees it)!. Jake and Rosalie are absolutely right; being a vampire sucks and it is NOT a fate you should choose!. Jake knew he would lose and that he didn't stand a chance against Edward; but he knew he would hurt worse if he didn't at least try to save her!. He was trying to be a good friend!. He reacted the way most people would react!.

Sure, he messed up!. But he's a 16 kid who has a lot of growing up to do!. He's never been in love before; he's just making it up as he goes along!. And he's not working with the advantages Edward is working with!. He has to use whatever he can!.Www@QuestionHome@Com