Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> Tanya in Breaking Dawn?


Question: Tanya in Breaking Dawn!?
Today's Quote of the Day is:
Tanya: "Ah, Edward!. I've missed you!."

I think Tanya loves Edward and there is a bit more to their relationship then Edward told Bella!. I think that he!.!.!.um!.!.!.might have slept with her and that's why he doesn't want to tell Bella much about her!. I think Bella will find out and get so jealous that she runs off to Jacob and maybe one thing will lead to another!.!.!.but what do you all think!?!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
OMG! okay so this might be a far stretch!.!.!. but heres what i just thought of!

so!.!.!.!.
Tanya comes down for the wedding with all of the Denali coven!. She and Edward talk (blah blah) and they laugh and she says the quote!.
THEN (okay heres the far strech, but hopefully not TOO far, cuz i like this possibility) Everyone goes to sit for the wedding!. Jacob and Seth and some more werewolves are there, and Jacob sees Tanya!. And he imprints on her! i think that would make it a bit like a midsummer nights dream, no!?
and so the drama could come from edward going for tanya, and bella for jacob, but then (just like in a midsummer nights dream) everyhting gets all bandaged up, and WHOOSH! hapy ending! Jacob and Tanya (even though she is a vampire, the legend never said a werewolf couldnt imprint on a vampire, right!?) and Edward and Bella end up together and Bella becomes a vampire!.
As for the possibilities for Bella's power as a vampire!.!.!.!.
here are my thoughts!.
Since Bella hates the smell and the sight and pretty much anything to do with blood, I think she will have AMAZING self control when it comes to her "thirst"!.
and since she has such a shielded mind, i think it will grow stronger, enabling her to do some kind of shiledy-thingy to protect herself and others from people!. maybe something like making everyone freeze!?!? idk!. but it will have something to do with shielding i bet!.
so ya!.
long answer no!? ahahaha
but i still like the idea of Jacob imprinting on Tanya!.

and here is a scary thought!. What if the Denali coven is there because a war is going to happen!? as in all vampires reunite, and all werewolves!. then in the end they get a truce done!. but still!.!.!.!. it scary to think about it!.!.!.!.

anyway! i hope you people liked my answer!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think there is a lot more to there relationship and i think Tanya loves him but i dont think he loves her!. I think it might be more complicated but i know that she would be back for the wedding!.
I dont think he's slept with her, i dont think he loves her and i dont think SM would write about sex or anything like that!.
I dont think she would be jelous and Edward is her destiny so i dont think she would run off but i think that Alec will change emotions, in the way Jasper does and this will mean that there is mixed emotions and edward wants Tanya and that would cause confusion!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think that Tanya and Edward did have a strong tie between them, i want to think that edward changed her but im just not sure!. maybe its a bella story all over again but with Tanya, im really interested to read it anyways!

Stephenie meyer was going to write more books in the Twilight Seires but decided not to because they would have 'adult content' and its unfair to switch for the underage readers!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I really think something like that could happen!. Maybe something did go down between Tanya and Edward which Edward did not tell Bella!. But I don't think he slept with her!.!.!. And Stephenie did say that Braking Dawn is based on Midsummer Night's Dream which would insinuate that Edward has a more complex relationship with Tanya then he is telling Bella!. OMG, shouldnt have started thinking about this now! It's really late and now I won't be able to sleep!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

OMGOMGOMG!!!!!!! I would ADORE the book if that is what's really gonna go down!. OMG! You're a genius!. I mean, I love both Edward & Jacob!. I don't so much love the fact that Bella's running from one guy to another, but what I really like is the shock & suprise!. Now THAT's something I wouldn't expect -- I really hope it's something like that!.

Breaking Dawn 08!.02!.08 - 18 more days from now *squee*Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think that Bella will run to jacob but just as a friend!. But i dont want that to happen because i just wanat it to be perfect!
Or maybe edward runs off to tanya because Bella runs away from the wedding! But than how would we know what Edward and tanya said because the book is from Bellas POV you know so bella has to be with Edward!



-Alice Cullen
Days till breaking dawn:18Www@QuestionHome@Com

I don't think that they slept together b/c when bella was trying to convince edward to do it in eclipse, he said he wanted to be just as "clean" as bella in that field!. remember!? i think tanya doesn't really have a chance and neither does jacob!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

honestly i think they were invited to the wedding!. and she says ah edward i missed u!. i can see bella getting upset!. but but i also think theres something edward didnt tell bella!. i think they will get married!. it just ofcourse theres going to be issues as alwaysWww@QuestionHome@Com

I don't think that Edward slept with Tanya!. He's implied that he was a virgin on more than one occasion!.

I just think that Tanya will either be a guest at the wedding, or they will see her later in Alaska!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think Edward and Tanya did have a stronger relationship then he told Bella, but I don't think he slept with her and I don't think he loves her!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think it would be perfect if Jacob imprinted on Tanya!. No one would be alone and so no one could go and ruin each other's relationships!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Umm!.!.!. I'm pretty sure this dosen't mean anything huge!. And Edward will not end with Tanya because on the poster on the Eclipse Special Edition shows the cover of Breaking Dawn with quotes under it saying:

"Don't be afraid," I murmured!.
"We belong together!."
I was abruptly overwhelmed by the truth of my own words!.
This moment was so perfect, so right, there was no doubt about it!.
His arms wrapped around me, holding me against him!.!.!.!.
It felt like every nerve ending in my body was a live wire!.
"Forever," he agreed!.

So!.!.!. she is obviously marrying Edward so I don't think we have to worry about Edward being with Tanya!. Like someone else said she probably just there for the wedding!. Even Stephenie Meyer said that these quotes won't be that important!. No need to get excited over it!. also, Edward wouldn't lie to her about something like that!. Any ways Alice would have known and probably would have told Bella earlier on about it if it was that serious!. And Bella is not going back to Jacob, like she said before, it would cause a lot of pain for both and things would get complicated :P!. And if that did happen it would ruin the book!Www@QuestionHome@Com