Question Home

Position:Home>Books & Authors> For Harry Potter freaks only?


Question: For Harry Potter freaks only!?
I am soo disappointed in JKR!. She set up a mystery, played it for several books, and totally avoided the question in the final book!. I am referring to Aunt Marge!. Whats up with her!? Who sent the howler!? What did "remember" mean!. How did she know about dementors!? From her sister during childhood!? Not likely!.JKR originally said that a muggle would end up at Hogwarts, and I bet it was Marge!. But WTF!.She wouldn't let her hubby kick Harry out!. WHY!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Dumbledore sent Petunia the Howler!. Petunia knew about dementors because she heard Snape telling Lily about them!. She wouldn't let Vernon kick Harry out because Dumbledore sent the howler!.
I think you got Petunia and Marge mixed up!. Marge is the crazy dog breeder that Harry turned into a balloon in PoAWww@QuestionHome@Com

Um, you mean Petunia :P I don't think there was much mystery surrounding Aunt Marge :P

Dumbledore sent the howler and I think he was referring to the letter he left on the doorstep, which probs explained why Harry had to stay with them so that his mother's love would stay with him!.

also, he sent her another letter when she was young because she sent him a letter asking if she could go to Hogwarts too but he sent her a letter saying that she couldn't!.

And the dementors thing, if you remember, Petunia was hiding in a tree when Snape was telling Lily about the dementors when they were little kids!.

Hope this helps :)Www@QuestionHome@Com

The howler was sent by dumbledore, but it wasnt sent to aunt marge, it was sent to aunt petunia (marge was vernons sister that harry blew up at the beginning of PoA)!.

Petunia was jealous of lily's abilities and was more aware of the happenings in the wizard world than she ever let on (this is revealed through snapes memories in deathly hollows)!. She also knew about the magical protection that was placed on Harry when she accepted him into her home, and the danger he would be in without it!. it's been a while since i read it, but if i remember correctly dumbledore left a letter when he dropped baby harry off at the dursleys that told her what was going on!.

Dumbledore explains all this to harry in half blood prince!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think you mean Aunt Petunia!. Aunt Marge was the one that Harry accidentally turned into the human balloon!.

Dumbledore sent Petunia the howler, reminding her of the letter he left with Harry on the front step!. By taking in Harry as I child, she agreed to house him during the summers until he turned 17!. The letter reminded her of her promise, and not wanting to break it, she forced Vernon to let Harry remain!.

As for knowing about dementors, Petunia overheard Lily and Snape talking when they were kids!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

aunt marge had no significance to the story except that harry blew her up in the third book!.!.!.!.maybe u were confusing her with aunt petunia(mrs!. dursley)!.!.!.dumbledore sent the howler!.!.!.!.wen the howler said remember, dumbledore was referring to a past meeting they had, maybe wen petunia wanted to join hogwarts or the letter he had sent with harry explaining his predicament and the bond that petunia and harry have!.!.!.petunia knew about dementors because she over heard petunia n snaoe talking about wen they were little kids(it was in the 7th book) and she probably could have experienced it once!.!.!.the muggle that ended up at hogwarts!.!.!.well that one ii dont know!.!.!.!.!.!.n petunia wouldn't let her kick husband kick harry out because she made a promise to dumbledore that she'd keep him in the house until he is 17 years old, because thats when the magic thing would break!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.READ THE BOOKS BEFORE MAKING STUPID REMARKS ABOUT THINGS U KNOW NOTHING ABOUT!!!!!!! im disappointed in u, for being disappointed in her when u had like all ur info wrong!.!.!.!.u could have at least had the name rightWww@QuestionHome@Com

Didn't you read the last book!? Or the 1st person who answered this question!? Petunia got the Howler, not Marge, that's Vernon's sister!.!.!.hello!. She didn't know about dementors!. She couldn't let her hubby kick Harry out because of what Dumbledore told her!. Maybe you should go back and re-read the books!. I re-read 7 a few times cause it was so good, but I only needed to read it 1 time to know what you're asking!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Answer:: JKR was smoking pot whenever she wrote the final book!.
literally, that book pissed me off so bad!.

I really am almost begining to think that someone cast a spell on effing hedwig and he turned on harry or something!.
That book was gay, and i'm dissapointed!.
End of story!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

didnt u pay attention when u were reading it!? i got all of those questions answered!.

dumbledore sent the howler!. remember ment remember the promise they made or something like that (thats the only one i only half-got)!. she knew about dementors cause of her sis, yes!.
reread it and pay attention and youll get all that!Www@QuestionHome@Com

wow well ya we were all like "OMG WHAT!?!" at the end of the last book turning the last page over to find where she hid the rest of the story!.!.!.!.!.i think she was just tired of writing it and wanted to drop it!.!.its sad i would never to that to my book its my baby i would try very hard not to end it poorly!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

you mean aunt petunia!?!? dumbly sent the howler reminding petunia of the letter he placed on the baby harry the night voldy "died"!. petunia remembered snape telling lily when they were little because petunia wanted to be a witch!.

did u read the last book at all!?!?!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Did you pay ANY attention at all the book!?
You're referring to Petunia!.!.!.Marge was never mentioned!.
Dumbledore sent the Howler to Petunia, and Petunia learned about dementors from eavesdropping on Severus and Lily!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Stefanie and Paralyze are 100% correct!. Give one of them best answer!.

Jim
? http://www!.life-after-harry-potter!.com ?Www@QuestionHome@Com

marge wasnt mentioned in the seventh book
the howler was to petunia!.
saying to remember they had to keep harry!.
she knew about the dementors from harrys mom when she went to hogwarts!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I absolutely love the books and im a #1 fan but i must say you've confused me!. nothing was mentioned about marge in the last book!.Www@QuestionHome@Com