Who is better Edward Cullen or Jacob Black and why?

Question: Who is better Edward Cullen or Jacob Black and why!?

Who do you like more!? Please answer and explain!. I can't decide!. I love the books!. I have read them all over 50 times and I don't know!. Jacob seems more fun but Edward is sweet!. Edward is overprotective but Jacob can be careless!. Who do you like more!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

Jacob, I like that he has a personality, even with his faults!. It's easier to relate to, unlike Edward!. I don't like characters that are so perfect!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think Edward and Jacob both have their own strong points but I don't think it is a matter of who is "better"!. If you are talking about who is better for Bella I def!. think that Edward is, they belong together all three books are just proof that their relationship/bond is so powerful that it can overcome every obstacle thrown at them(IE Edward's desire to kill Bella, thirsty tracking obsessed vampires, Cullen Family attacks, Charlies aversion, Edward's paranoia, Jacob's meddling, Victoria's insanity!.!. so on and so forth) !. Even after all of that in the end, Bella believes Edward is better for her too and chooses Edward (and his baggage)!.

I think weather you like Edward or Jacob's personality better is a personal choice,(if these characters were real and not fictional haha) I would probably go for an Edward type!. Besides being gorgeous he is witty, intelligent, caring, virtually selfless, has a crooked sense of humor and is a romantic!. But he is def not perfect like others claim, he tends to be a bit of a know it all, he overreacts, he's whiny, and he is a bit of extremist!. Although Jacob is adorable and sarcastic and means well, I feel like we'd argue way to much he's a little bit frustrating sometimes, I just want to shake him!.

PS!. I'm not crazy, I promise I realize these characters are NOT real, I just got a little into this question!. lolWww@QuestionHome@Com

EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.!.!. He is soooooo sweet and kind, the only reaason he seems over protective is because he is in love with Bella and doesn't want anything to happen to her, I mean, just in Twilight she almost died three (four if you count the first encounter with James in the clearing) right in front of Edwards eyes!!!!!!!!!!!!! How couldn't he be!?!?!?!?!?!?!?/ And Jacob is a total jerk!. Bella tries to be nice and tell him that the only way she loves him and will EVER love him ,is as a friend, nothing more!. Yet he still tries to force himself onto her!. At least Edward was considerate of what Bella wanted and let her go see Jacob, but Jacob could NEVER get along with Edward or even put up with him, not even for Bella who he SUPPOSEDLY LOVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Worst of all, he almost let Bella DIE several times right in front of him because of his stupid carelessness!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

EDWARD!!! he is way way better then jacob!. jacob thinks thats he' supposed to be with bella and ewards says whatever makes u happy bella!. and edward is not as pushy as jacob!. edward is just a way better person and also better looking and bella can be with edward for ever and ever jacob could fall in love with anyone else cause he is still human and bella cannot become a werewolf lk she can become a vampireWww@QuestionHome@Com

Edward!. Well, one because Edward is more understanding!. He is sweet , Beautiful, and caring (According to the book!.)!. And Jacob!. Well he is Jacob!. I just really dont like him!. He kisses Bella against her Will!. I mean!. WTF!?!!?!!? And I mean why cant Jacob just get along with Edward!. Like Seth!? Anyhoo, I think Edward because He sounds better!.

My vote is :

EDWARD CULLENWww@QuestionHome@Com

Edward!. He is mature, handsome, manly, kind, sweet, and passionate, and for goodness sake, he's a fantastic vampire! Unlike Jacob he is careless, a freakin' fur ball, and he is cocky and full of himself!. Good luck deciding, and hope I helped!Www@QuestionHome@Com

of course Edward is better!. Jacob is such a jerk! ur right he is careless and and moronic!. i don't know y some people like him!. 4 all i care he is trying to steal someone else's girlfriend!. just imagine if Jacob was in Edward's place he would have probably killed him by now, right!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Edward Cullen is the perfect guy ever! I mean, Jacob's cool and all, but he's too childish!. Edward is caring, sweet, protective, mature, and just down right awesome!.

Edward's better!

:)Www@QuestionHome@Com

I love Jacob!. He's straight out AWESOME! He's explained to be warm, while Edward is explained to be cold!. If I were Bella I'd totally choose Jacob!Www@QuestionHome@Com

Edward!. But they are fictional!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Doesn't matter!. They're fictional characters!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Edward, for sure vampires are alot better than werewolves!. I dont even need to explain that one!. lolWww@QuestionHome@Com

what the hell i don't get it and what book you talking about!?Www@QuestionHome@Com