Question Home

Position:Home>Visual Arts> You always seem to give such helpful photo critiques...?


Question: You always seem to give such helpful photo critiques!.!.!.!?
!.!.!.judging by the questions I've posted in the past!.

I haven't gotten much of a chance to take many photos since the last time, seeing as chemistry pretty much monopolizes my free time!.

As usual, thoughts/critiques/advice on any of the posted shots is appreciated!

[By the way!.!.!.the shots that are loaded on black take a bit longer to load, but no longer than 30 seconds or so!.]

one!.
http://bighugelabs!.com/flickr/onblack!.ph!.!.!.

two!.
http://farm4!.static!.flickr!.com/3041/2521!.!.!.

three!.
http://bighugelabs!.com/flickr/onblack!.ph!.!.!.

four!.
http://bighugelabs!.com/flickr/onblack!.ph!.!.!.

five!.
http://bighugelabs!.com/flickr/onblack!.ph!.!.!.

six (not sure whether I like the grass or stone shot best)!.
http://bighugelabs!.com/flickr/onblack!.ph!.!.!.

seven!.
http://farm3!.static!.flickr!.com/2006/2434!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
One: you have a lens with a wide aperture, dont let it be your crutch!. Stop down just a tad and get the statues head in focus as well!.

Two: I personally dont like this one!. Not the right tone and not in focus enough or out of focus enough to be abstract!.

Three: Nice capture, try to lead off the dogs nose a little next time only slightly!. Give some space for him to look at!.

Four: Not much of a focus point!. It wouldnt look as good on a white page!.

Five and Six: I like these!. clear, well focussed in the composition!. On five I would not have cropped it that close but it looks good!. Six, what can I say, the red against the green is a very good mix!. Dont change a thing!.

Seven looks a bit like a snapshot just grabbed out of no-where!. You cropped at the joints (or so it seems to me)!. Lets see more of the subject next time!.

None of these are horrible by any means!. Keep it up!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

1!. Makes me feel really depressed, like someone just died!.

2!.Looks like something that would come in a picture frame you just bought before you put in your own picture!.

3!.That dog looks kind of like a lemur from that angle with that tail and such large eyes, but I like it!.

4!. Captivating, the lilacs are a strong focal point!.

5!.Cute enough, I guess!. Looks like something one would see all over photobucket!.

6!.I like this shot much better than the stone shot, even with the E bing a bit blurred, it gives it perspective!.

7!.Makes me feel all warm and snuggly!.

[x]melanieinuyashaWww@QuestionHome@Com

you have an amazing camera!? what type is it!?

number two is amazing! did you edit this!? i like the framing

number three: captured in the moment

number 4: i like how the flower is off the frame

definitely like it on the stone!. the grass seems too harsh because the red is dark!. it looks neutral with the stone!.

number 7: the colors work wonderfullyWww@QuestionHome@Com

The one on the grass is absolutely amazing!.

I think you need to raise the 'E' a little bit though, just to make it a tad more readable!.

It looks much better on the grass if you ask me!.

Why not try that idea on the flower you photoed!? Laying the letters round the petals!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

i really like them my fav!. would be the one with the dog sleeping and love in the grass my third fav!. is the grayish flower the only one i don't like is the purple flower thingy!. but they're really good and i feel ya with the chemistry thing!. it's a killer!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Wow, God has blessed u with good talent!
seriously, i'm blown away!
gorgeous!
oh, and i prefer the one where the word "i love u" is on the stone!. looks much mature and natural!. but i also think the other one rox 2!Www@QuestionHome@Com

The angle of your shots are AWESOME, you inspire me to go take pictures now!.

Btwn the Scrabble pieces(LOVE) i prefer the sand one, the grass seems to take away from the piecesWww@QuestionHome@Com

I like the stone shot best (5/6)!.
Looove #7!. My dog used to sleep like that when we let her on our bed before we got a new one!. Very talented!. I'm a big fan of b/w pics!. I think #1 is my fav!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Nice photos!. :]

I really liked number 3 and number 5!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Those are some great photos, if you took them then it looks like you are a great photographer!. :)>-Www@QuestionHome@Com

yeah they are all really good

i like the grass picture the bestWww@QuestionHome@Com

these are amazing! they are so unique yet unusual!. i would hang these up in my room!

btw the stone looks better!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

you took these, they are niceWww@QuestionHome@Com

i love them especially number 7 and 8Www@QuestionHome@Com

five is the best without a doubt!

thats awesomeWww@QuestionHome@Com

these are awsome!!!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

good photosWww@QuestionHome@Com

i thought you wanted a critique!?!?

wow they are great or wow you must have a good camera is not critique

critique is an analysis of an image by those trained in photography to say things with more depth tahn wow they are great\

critique is a tool for people the learn from, wow they are great is a total waste of time

if you want a real critique post one or two images next time

EDIT: if you oick one out i will critique it for you

you could say in your question you are after proper critique so you can advance your photography and fluffy answers are pointless or not what your after, i have given lots of critiques here, now i only do it for those that i have relationships with or that post one or two images, tired of idiots sending me emails being abusive because they are stupid and uneducated in photography and think me telling someone to study lighting is insulting or something!?!?


aWww@QuestionHome@Com