| Question Home |
Position:Home>Visual Arts> Rate my photography... PLEASE?Question:I am new at photography with NO professional training or education, all my knowledge is based from online research, advice and inspiration... Please leave feedback negative or positive or advice and rate on a 1-5 scale 1 being lowest and 5 being highest. I do admire advice from all people professional or not. I have been taken photo's for about 3 month now... Thank You 1: portriat http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 2: still life http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 3: bridge http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 4: rock http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: I am new at photography with NO professional training or education, all my knowledge is based from online research, advice and inspiration... Please leave feedback negative or positive or advice and rate on a 1-5 scale 1 being lowest and 5 being highest. I do admire advice from all people professional or not. I have been taken photo's for about 3 month now... Thank You 1: portriat http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 2: still life http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 3: bridge http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 4: rock http://i255.photobucket.com/albums/hh144... 4th one s awesome......5 mrks,,, bridge .....cud be better ...4 mrks... portrait ...better........ still life....highlight s bit low......(acc to me) overall 4.5 .......keep goin trisha...n hey share ur photograpy of ur recent projects...even i m very int ... I like the 3rd one the best, followed by the first. I'm not a fan of the coloring in the second one and I didn't really particularly see any direction with the fourth. Just being honest! Looks awesome! Keep at it :D id say about a 4.5 for a beginner! Peace WOW!!! I wish you had done my wedding pics! Really good for 3 months work. 1 - 4 (cute kid :P), 2 - 3, 3 - 5 (great pic), 4 - 4. all the pictures look great, just the portrait seems a little to close missing some crucial body movement...but real great work Its awesome especially the photograph of the bridge 3.5 they're really pretty good although the framing around the photos is hideous you should find like a program that'll make a watermark so put on your photos because the frames to distracting. Photo 1 - 3 (expressions could have been better) Photo 2 - 4 Photo 3 - 4.5 Photo 4 - 3 1. its good 2. i like it how you cough the ball in midair 3. i like it how u used your vanishing point as the subject of the photo 4. u must have played with the focus PS. not so much black and white, it gets boring. all of the pictures are nice but you should use more creativity like take a picture of something no one else would take a picture of so you stand out more As a long time amateur photographer, I must say you have an excellent eye. You're a natural. I would rate your work a very high positive 5+. Where was your picture of the pier taken? 10! i like the bridge one the best but the little kid in the first one is so adorable 1----5 needs a little more room on the left and a little less on the right, love the off center. 2----4 maybe crop closer to focus more on the hand and ball 3----4 well done 4----3 lacks a more powerful point of interest I think you have talent :-) I am not a photographer but I am allowing myself to criticize your art: Pic 1: Nice use of the closeup 4/5 Pic 2: The angle could have been more decisive. It makes me feel like I want to see a bit more of the boy's face. 2/5 Pic 3: Very nice choice of angle to show the perspective. 5/5 Pic 4: I appreciate the use of the focus but the composition is not interesting. 1/5 Hope this helps! You definetily have a talent for this. Keep at it, if you really like it. They're not bad for a beginner, but you can tell they're not professional - that's not to say you couldn't be in time!! Good luck portrait - the little boy is adorable but the lighting could have been better it looked a little too dark! still life - loved what you did with colored ball and black and whiting everything else but you could have picked a better still life. The Bridge - was great perfect I loved the grainy look it really added to the effect the rock - gave great deminsion and made you really feal like you were standing on top of it! some really great shots! 1.) I would have centered the subject 2.) does not look natural ( like you said throw the ball) then took the photo. 3.) does not look in focus and has little contrast as well as lacks impact for me. 4.) Is disturbing the rocks are fighting for attention and I don't know what to look at. over all I like number 1 but am trying too look at them with a broad perspective. Number two is not still life mediocre remove the tacky border |
