Is this a good photo ... critique?

Question:this is for a class the topic is historical we have to make it look like its from a different time period im going for retro 50s with this one please tell me what u think of it thanks!

http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x302/...

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: this is for a class the topic is historical we have to make it look like its from a different time period im going for retro 50s with this one please tell me what u think of it thanks!

http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x302/...

there are some good things about it that make it look as if though you had taken pictures of things from the 50's. However the high shene from the glass, and the small reflection of the LED stop light in the background shows evidence that this is a modern digital image. I think photo shop has something to take away the digital appearance and make it more 35mm like.
Good job though, for a rookie!

good photo.

I like it! It's really cool

u can tell its photoshopped

it looks edited, with the hotel sign

I like it lots! Good job!

irr......its not the best..plus you can see a reflection in the background

its good but the floating neon motel sign is kind of ruining the whole picture...:]

Its a cool photo, but its kind of shiny and new looking, the objects are good, but maybe if you fade the picture more and maybe add scratches

It's pretty good :]

FABULOUS!!!

yea its good

The idea is awesome.. but the actual picture is a bit sloppy.

I like it except the sign is floating. Monroe on the right can hardly be seen. Pick a focal point and center things around that. Dont forget balance. You should have maybe 3 colors that repeat throughout as to make sure the picture isn't too much.

it rocks. especially in relation to your theme. good idea.

well u can definatly tell its edited... but good photo=]... wat is the motel sign for tho?

i would think its from the 5os.it looks old. like the music thingy. thats old.

that is realy cool! it looks 50ish to me. and i like the actor/singer in the back round

real good

u coulda fooled me =)

thats a really good picture. and i love how you can just barely see the reflection of some people on the glass : D

i like it

It's awesome! Sweet!

Luv, SweetGator.

ya i really do like this pic alot its cool and retro

its good but you need to pick a focal point. at the moment your eyes arent drawn to anything in particular. making you lose interest. love the idea tho =D