Question Home

Position:Home>Visual Arts> How is my artwork?


Question:Can you rate my artwork and give me good criticism? I'm 15 and in 10th grade (high school).

http://i28.tinypic.com/258wdmo.jpg
4~5 hours, v different from my normal style...first time doing an anime-ish drawing. No particular character I was trying to recreate, just drew the outline in class.

http://i26.tinypic.com/212zcxs.jpg
4 hours, for a Robert Frost poem for lit class. Wanted to make it better, more realistic but I had other homework to do...here is a closeup,
http://i29.tinypic.com/10oqhcl.jpg

http://i27.tinypic.com/15mlf21.jpg
Poster for math week, used a reference for the spiral.

http://i30.tinypic.com/2lm70ib.jpg
UNFINISHED, green elf I'm trying to make very good.

http://i27.tinypic.com/6qxu04.jpg
Third time playing with conte, trying to see what I'm capable of

http://i26.tinypic.com/n2ycti.jpg
Just doodling after test, 15 minutes

Sorry for the ugly marks, I had bad experience with someone using my art without my permission. Please ignore them.

Thanks in advance!


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Can you rate my artwork and give me good criticism? I'm 15 and in 10th grade (high school).

http://i28.tinypic.com/258wdmo.jpg
4~5 hours, v different from my normal style...first time doing an anime-ish drawing. No particular character I was trying to recreate, just drew the outline in class.

http://i26.tinypic.com/212zcxs.jpg
4 hours, for a Robert Frost poem for lit class. Wanted to make it better, more realistic but I had other homework to do...here is a closeup,
http://i29.tinypic.com/10oqhcl.jpg

http://i27.tinypic.com/15mlf21.jpg
Poster for math week, used a reference for the spiral.

http://i30.tinypic.com/2lm70ib.jpg
UNFINISHED, green elf I'm trying to make very good.

http://i27.tinypic.com/6qxu04.jpg
Third time playing with conte, trying to see what I'm capable of

http://i26.tinypic.com/n2ycti.jpg
Just doodling after test, 15 minutes

Sorry for the ugly marks, I had bad experience with someone using my art without my permission. Please ignore them.

Thanks in advance!

I'm a graduate of the Columbus College of Art and Design. It's one of the top five art schools in the nation. I majored in Illustration which by the looks of what you're doing would be your best bet as far as a major.

Your artwork is very average. I'd guess based on your work that you're in high school. Your profiles are not good...the proportions and anatomy are wrong. You're rendering is ok on the green thing but nothing else really impressed me. Keep up the studies and work on anatomy! Practice, practice, practice. Draw all the time and ALWAYS carry a sketchbook with you. C.F. Payne told me that we all have bad drawings inside of us and that it's best to get them out onto paper. If you keep them bottled inside of you, they'll come out when you're trying to do something for real. So sketch!

i think you have real talent. if it is something you want to do with your life, go to an art school after high school. you have a lot to learn, but you have the skill to learn it! keep it up!

very good !

really good

You seem to be very accomplished, I think that you should major in art as I can see that you have a possible career in illustration.

wow, for 15, you are really good!!!!

if u want criticism, the lady's neck is very long~ other than that its really good!

you really have talent! its incredible! i will give them 10 on 10

You have talent. that is undeniable, a fact, a sure thing. You are gifted.
The real question is can you be businesslike about your art so you can make a living doing what you love??????
Until I retired, I had a t-shirt that said " ART PROSITUTE "
on it because I wasn't going to be famous after I died, I wanted the money now!!! so I did what people wanted to buy.
I did sculpture,

Wow! Your art is great! I don't believe that that was your first time doing anime! I mean, WOW! You are really great, and you have talent. I suggest a career in art or design.

One word......ExCeLLeNt!!!!
I like your style of your drawings ...called also illustration
All the best for you.....keep it on!!!!!!

It is very difficult ti bring across feeling in drawing.But you do.I wish you luck for your future.We will hear about you in years to come.

You have a gift, hold on to it and you will be very successful

They all look good, just push yourself to your limits. I have a feeling that you are holding back on your true potential. Some library books on human anatomy will be a good aid in having a better understanding of each body part.

Your perspective is good, too. Try putting in elements to give the artwork more depth.

Not too bad, I must say. You are great with colour. I loved the colour and shading on your first picture, awsome. Other than the last scketch they were pretty good.