Question Home

Position:Home>Theater & Acting> Whats your input on the casting of twilight?


Question: Whats your input on the casting of twilight!?
okay so im a die-hard twilight fan, and ive read all the books!.
but i think the casting was WAY OFF for the most part!.

edward;; hes alright, but not as beautiful as i imagined!. i give him a B!.

bella;; dude!. no!. i think shes a bit too pretty to be bella, bella is just an average girl in the book!. she just is always looking away and being like nervous throughout the whole movie!. and what happened to her blushing all the time!? that didnt happen!. not a good choice for bella!. i giver her a D-!.

Esme;; Shes alright!. B+!.

Carlisle;; Perfect casting! he could of been a little younger though!. A-!.

Emmett;; One of my favorites! he was casted correctly!. A!.

Alice;; PERFECTTTT! shes exactly what i imagined alice to be and more!. A+!.

Rosalie;; She wasnt as beautiful as rosalie is in the book!. though she did bring rosalie to life!. B!.

Jasper;; He didnt have a whole line in the movie! and i would of thought he would be more hot!. C+!.

Charlie;; hes great!. A!.

Laurent;; F!. i didnt imagine him to look like bob marley!.

Victoria;; C- what happened to the fiery red hair!?

James;; great casting! A!.



the movies special effects werent that great either, but whatever!.
all in all i loved the movie, just because im obsessed with all things twilight, but it could of been way better!.

what are your thoughts!?Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
edward: I think he had such an ugly face and he was too emotional!. In the book you know he is a bit smug and confident and I like that!. This fellow was just odd for me!. Going off your letter grade system C!.

bella: I thought she did alright, I didn't think that she was pretty, but she just didn't fit Bella for me you know have the stubborn die hard smitten by edward attitude!. She was more like blah blah blah you're impossibly fast!.!.!.!.!.!.!.C

Esme: B

Carlisle: Did good but his makeup bothered me I know he is supposed to be way pale but it just looked too caked on for my taste!. B+

Emmett: He was grand! I loved it when he said "DUH HER NAME IS BELLA!" A

Alice: I agree completely with you!.

Rosalie: I pictured Rosalie to be much more striking this one had too dark of lipstick on, and her face just wasn't as pretty as I visioned her!. B

Jasper: Actually Jasper had one line where they were in the garage and he said i've delt with their kind before they aren't easy to kill!. His hair bugged me! B-

Charlie:PERFECT A+!.

Laurent: Laurent seriously alright he isn't black in the books because in the second one bella mistakes him in the woods for edward from behind worst casting on that one! Agreed with the F!.

Victoria: I hated her furry cape! And you are right her hair is a dull red color and I didn't like it!. D

James: He did good I just wish his hair wasn't so long! B+

Jacob: I know his hair is super long in the books but i didn't think it was that long!. I imagined it like to his shoulders at the longest!. But he did good!. AWww@QuestionHome@Com

TWILIGHTS STUPID STOP TALKING ABOUT IT!!!
Edward:not like i imagined him to look,but good actin B+
Bella:man voice
Esme:okay B+
Carlisle:eww
Emmett:A+
Alice:A+++ my names Alce aha
Rosalie:man face
Jasper:A+ hes awesome
Charlie:A++ hes tight
Laurent:ahaha he does look like bob marley
Victoria:pretty
James:so hotWww@QuestionHome@Com

i think every one was perfect!.!.!.except laurent, haha i didnt expect Bob Marley either!.!.!.
and they did a good job on the Cullens, the books descrption is impossible to fill!.!.!.perfection=unacheivable


also ppl need to remember that this is a
LOW BUDGET MOVIE!!!Www@QuestionHome@Com

it's funny cuz when i read that book i pictured kristen stewart as bella and that was long before the movie was cast, so that was cool, and i guess it makes it an a+Www@QuestionHome@Com

agreed all but charlie i pictured him different but i totally agree with ur rating for everyone elseWww@QuestionHome@Com

bella ruined it for me!.
she ruined the whole movie!. she has no emotions, and she can't act!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm a twilighter too!.!.!.Here's my take:

Edward: Horrible, horrible casting!. his acting in the movie was so bad I wanted to cry!. Not only that, but what happened to the funny Edward!.!.!.the one who could insert his dark humor into anything!.!.!.I give him a D-

Bella: Bella, to me, was pretty great!. I think her character was right on par!. Remember, she's described as average, yes, but then again, beauty is in the eye of the beholder and her self-confidence wasn't exactly sky-high!. She always under-valued herself!.!.!.Bella to me was an A

Emmett: No words!. That dude was AWESOME!!! A+

Rosalie: Her acting was good!.!.!.not exactly what i imagined, but she will do!.!.!.I give her a B

Esme: not what i imagined at all, but she played her role to the best of her ability and for that i give her a B+

Carlisle:!.!.!.I actually found it kind of sad he is hotter than Edward in the movie!.!.!.He was a great actor though, and great eye-candy, so for that, i give hima nd A

James: !.!.!.C'mon!. It's Cam Gigandet!. There are no words for him!. A+

Victoria: !.!.!.I think Victoria was awesome!.!.!.but every scene she showed up in was so extremely cheesy (especially with the horrible background supposedly "bad-***" music) I wanted to cry!. As an actress though, I think she's great!. I give her a B

Charlie: Great actor!. He really stpped into character!. I give him an A

Laurent: !.!.!.!.Well, not at all what I imagined!.!.!.I mean AT ALL!. But he did his job well so I give him a B+

Alice: !.!.!.She looks EXACTLY like her imagined her!.!.!.i just wish they'd given her mor elines!.!.!.

Jasper: His whole look in the movie was soo extremely comical i couldn't take him seriously!. His image is very Jasper-esque though, so I give him a B





Www@QuestionHome@Com

edward- A+ VELVETY VOICE!.
bella- A /yeah, bella is supposed to be plain looking, but think about it she had to be somewhat appealing for the audience to watch her for a good hour and a half!. plus she's a wonderful actress, and ya i thought her voice was odd, but stephanie meyer said that's just how she imagined it!.

Esme-- A+ for me, she portrays the charcter well!.

Carlisle-- A+ hott

Emmett-- A+

Alice-- PERFECT!.

Rosalie-- A; yes, she wasnt the most beautiful woman ever, but she did an EXCELLENT job with the character!.

Jasper--A+ he was awesome he did a nice job being mysterious as he was at the beginning of the series; however, i was upset his power wasnt mentioned!.

Charlie-- A++ HAHAHA PERFECT!. HE WAS SO AWKWARD!.

Laurent-- D sorry!.

Victoria-- C she was good, but COME ONE FIERY HAIR, it something that can be fixed so EASILY-- its called hair dye!.

James-- meh B!.


I was fairly satisfied with the movies, especially because i went in there with not expectations, since the Golden Compass was TOATLLY ruined for me!.
BUT i was upset about the lullaby!. For me, it was a HUGE part of their love, and it was kind of meh!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Edward: B+, he looked like the way I imagined him, but he didn't laugh enough!. He seemed to young/inexperienced!.
Bella: I don't think she was so horrible! B!. Her acting was more the director's fault, like he probably told her to be more serious to make the whole movie more intense!.
Esme: Couldn't tell, she didn't have many lines and wasn't very involved
Carlisle: B, he was ok!.
Emmett: I agree! A! He looked and acted perfectly Emmett, lol!.
Alice (lol, that's my name too): She hgot the picie thing down, but I don't think she was AMAZING, A-
Rosalie: Yeah, I agree!. But I think in real life you can only be so perfect, then you just don't exist, haha!. She seemed meaner in the movie; the book is more subtle bitchiness!.
Jasper: HE WAS SMOKIN, ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?! A++
Charlie: UGGHHH NOOO!!!! C! He was terrible!. I didn't think Charlie would be that muscled, he also was to like!.!.!.ugh no!.
Laurent: Lol, he was okay!. B+
Victoria: Ehh, B!. I think it was fiery enoiugh but not long enough!.
James: Omg he was hot hot hot A+!.=DWww@QuestionHome@Com

Have you seen how Kristin (Bella) dresses in real life!? Comapred to the materialistic woman she's become, she was very "average" for the movie!. I thought she played the part nicely!. Her looks matched perfectly, although she was, of course, very tiny!.

Edward was a horrible actor!. His facial expressions were crucial to the plot, and he failed miserably!. He was alright looking, not how I imagined him though!. Sexy with the glasses on!.

Agreed, Carlisly could have been a little younger!.

Rosalie's hair was very fake!. For the "most beautiful girl in the world", I don't think Nikki Reed was fit to play that part!. As well as in serious moments, when Rosalie was ticked - Nikki's character was smiling at Bella's jokes!.

Alice was absolutley perfect, disappointed we didn't get to see much of her!. Jasper's facial expression was great, I wish he had more lines!. I thought he was adorable though!.

Emmett fit the "big brother" role perfect!. I imagined Esme to be wiser looking, not so "desparate housewives"!. It looked like she enjoyed Carlisle's love bite!.

Jacob's teeth were too white compared to his skin, hated his hair!. Not attractive at all!. Charlie and Billy tried to fit in too hard, not like they did in the book!.
Victoria, agreed about the fiery red hair!. Same with Laurent, AS WELL AS TYLER, AND ERIC!. They just had to throw the multiculturism in there!.

James was the most affective vampire, I think!.

I LOVED the books, am very disappointed in the movie though!. They turned the whole atmosphere from romantic and magical to funny!. The movie was too squished together, I wonder if the director even read the books!. The acting wasn't too great!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com