This kinda popped into my head one night...?

Question:When I first met him,
I thought he was the only one
The only one for me.
Well, he was for a while.
Later, I met another man
Here I was thinking,
He was the only one
That lasted only for a while too.
I've met over a dozen men
Each one of them was "the only one"
But this time
I'm telling you
I found the only one
I had auditions
I had interviews.
This person knows all the answers to my questions
This person sees me every day
And this person has known me the longest
I've decided I'm the only one for me
Next time Mr. Right comes knocking on my door
He might want to mention
His first name is Right
And his last name is Now.

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: When I first met him,
I thought he was the only one
The only one for me.
Well, he was for a while.
Later, I met another man
Here I was thinking,
He was the only one
That lasted only for a while too.
I've met over a dozen men
Each one of them was "the only one"
But this time
I'm telling you
I found the only one
I had auditions
I had interviews.
This person knows all the answers to my questions
This person sees me every day
And this person has known me the longest
I've decided I'm the only one for me
Next time Mr. Right comes knocking on my door
He might want to mention
His first name is Right
And his last name is Now.

Cool. That's pretty good, and it's easy to understand with making it too wordy.